Interesting article on iron, fortified fo... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

25,882 members27,179 posts

Interesting article on iron, fortified foods etc

LAJ12345 profile image
8 Replies

In my inbox today from Mark Hyman

Most people are aware of the importance of iron but less aware of the nuances associated with it—and where potentially problematic sources might be lurking in our diet.

How Our Bodies Use—and Lose—Iron

Iron helps deliver oxygen from our lungs to our tissues. The oxygen we breathe into our lungs hitches a ride from hemoglobin, the iron-rich protein inside our red blood cells. Hemoglobin and iron “carpool” together, picking up oxygen and dropping it off at its destination (tissue) and scooping up carbon dioxide on the way back to the lungs to be exhaled.

Our bodies are also extremely thrifty with iron. We recycle and reuse the iron from old red blood cells and have mechanisms in place that convert any excess iron in our blood to ferritin, the storage form of iron we can use if our levels ever drop too low.

Women in their reproductive years require significantly more iron than men. Menstruating women need to replace the iron they lose every month (approximately 14 mg) to prevent iron-deficiency anemia. Pregnant women also require more iron to support increased blood volume and the nutrient requirements for a growing baby.

Heme Iron vs. Non-Heme Iron

There are two types of dietary iron: heme iron, and non-heme iron. Heme iron is bound to hemoglobin and myoglobin (the hemoglobin that’s in our muscles), which is why it’s only found in animal foods like meat, fish, eggs, and poultry.

Non-heme iron is found in both animal and plant foods. The non-heme iron in plants is bound to phytates, oxalates, and other “anti-nutrients” that inhibit its absorption. That’s one reason why iron is a nutrient of concern for vegetarians and vegans—they must make sure they’re maximizing iron absorption from iron-rich plants like beans, dark chocolate, lentils, spinach, pistachios, and pumpkin seeds (see below for my recommendations on accomplishing this in the best way).

Unfortunately, for the average American, the primary sources of non-heme iron come from refined flour and fortified grains, which as we’ll see is a big problem!

Enrichment, Fortification, and Fallacies—Oh My!

Over seventy-five years ago, the FDA declared that food manufacturers must enrich the wheat flour used to make breads, pasta, and desserts with ferrous sulfate (a synthetic form of non-heme iron), in addition to the B vitamins niacin, riboflavin, and thiamin, to help prevent iron-deficiency anemia and other diseases related to nutrient deficiencies.

Despite these efforts, however, iron deficiency is still the number-one cause of anemia in the US today. Attempting to correct nutrient deficiencies by enriching popularly consumed refined flours with artificial nutrients seemed like a good idea back then, but we now know that this approach underestimates the complex nature of our biology. It also comes with unintended consequences!

The Trouble with Iron

We have biological mechanisms that tightly regulate iron homeostasis, but ferrous sulfate (synthetic, non-heme iron) isn’t recognized by our bodies in the same way as the iron we get from real, whole foods. Today, the average American eats 132 pounds of flour every year, which makes up the majority of non-heme iron in our diet.

Non-heme iron is already tough to absorb, but synthetic, non-heme iron is even more difficult. This means all of the iron-fortified grains and enriched wheat flour we eat isn’t doing much for us nutritionally. They do have an impact biologically, though, but it's not one that we should get excited about.

Refined wheat flour is one of the most inflammatory ingredients in processed foods due to its high gluten content, glycemic index, and being riddled with glyphosate residue. Not only that, refined flour is often kept in warehouses with poor storage conditions that make ferrous sulfate susceptible to oxidation.

Because refined wheat flour is a staple in the standard American diet, this excess, poorly absorbed iron circulating in our bloodstream can oxidize and cause damage to our DNA and cell membranes while accelerating aging. Studies show that men who eat refined flour have lower antioxidant levels and an increased activity level of antioxidant enzymes.

Food First: Optimize Your Iron Levels

With all of these problems, what are we to do? How can we eat an iron-rich diet that doesn’t adversely affect our health? The answer is to get iron naturally from real, whole foods.

Here are the best ways to meet your iron needs naturally:

The Pegan approach. This is the approach I take and the diet I recommend for most of my patients. Get your iron from both plant and animal foods. To increase plant-based iron absorption, eat your dark, leafy greens with a small side of meat. The heme iron in meat will increase the absorption of the non-heme iron from plants.

Three ways to increase iron absorption:

Pair iron-rich plant foods with vitamin C. This also increases the absorption of non-heme iron. Pair lentils with tomato sauce or add lemon juice to some sautéed spinach.

Eat fruit with non-heme iron. This isn’t an excuse to overdo it on sugar, but fructose does increase iron absorption. Adding some pomegranate seeds or blood orange to your spinach salad will increase non-heme iron absorption—and it will taste good too!

Don’t eat iron-rich foods with calcium. Calcium inhibits iron absorption. If you want to increase iron absorption in your meal and can tolerate dairy, don’t eat them together. This could mean not adding cheese to your eggs or goat cheese to your spinach salad.

Eliminate refined grains and flour. As if its blood sugar impact wasn’t enough to kick it to the curb, the high fructose corn syrup in processed foods significantly increases ferrous sulfate absorption, promoting oxidative stress and an imbalance of other micronutrients.

Our bodies have mechanisms in place that regulate iron absorption based on how much we have in reserve. The iron in refined wheat flour bypasses these mechanisms and can cause oxidative stress in our bodies that’s similar to rust, like a bicycle that’s been left outside in the rain. I don’t know about you, but I’d rather wear out than rust out!

The bottom line is this: focus on getting your iron in naturally and remove the harmful sources from your diet. Your body will thank you.

Wishing you health and happiness,

Mark Hyman, MD

Written by
LAJ12345 profile image
LAJ12345
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
faridaro profile image
faridaro

According to Dr. Mischley : "there are deposits of increased iron in the substantia nigra and iron catalyzes the production of free radicals within neurons. Iron is probably not to blame for causing Parkinsonism, but it is part of the disease process and a significant contributor to progression".

And here is one of the studies: "A large body of evidence suggests abnormal iron levels in the brains of PD patients and a role for iron dysregulation in PD pathogenesis", although it seems to be unknown if iron is the cause or effect of neurodegeneration.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/labs/pmc/a...

Annieartist profile image
Annieartist in reply to faridaro

I steer clear of supplements with iron because of this - should I be doing this?

faridaro profile image
faridaro in reply to Annieartist

It all depends on your ferritin levels. My ferritin is usually around 53-58 ng/ml and although the normal reference range is 11.0 -306.8 a while ago I made a written a note saying that optimal range is 10 - 40 ng/ml (unfortunately I don't remember the source of this information). So, going by that range, my iron levels are too high and for that reason I avoid iron supplements. However, if someone's ferritin levels are too low they would need to address that by supplementation.

Bolt_Upright profile image
Bolt_Upright in reply to faridaro

Yes! HS grad here, but I would lean more towards iron chelation than iron supplements.

(did I mention I have a high school degree?)

JustJeff profile image
JustJeff

About 10 years before a PD diagnosis and after seeing my GP because of sheer exhaustion my ferritin levels were found to be 4.3...unacceptably low (Consultant told me 15 is the lowest acceptable level) i was not anaemic just extremely low ferritin levels ...endoscopy top and bottom revealed no bleeds and no tumours. Ferritin levels continued to yo yo and the GPs final conclusion was poor absorption ? If there is a link with PD this would explain a lot .

Smittybear7 profile image
Smittybear7

My blood work indicates a slightly high iron level. My lumbar spine MRI showed red blood bone marrow issues but neither my neurologist nor my PCP are concerned. Any thoughts about whether I should consult with a hematologist?

LAJ12345 profile image
LAJ12345 in reply to Smittybear7

Sorry I don’t know anything about this. But if you can afford it or insurance covers it I guess it makes sense to go to the expert. Maybe first ask for the exact details of what the issues are and have a google to see what it means.

Smittybear7 profile image
Smittybear7 in reply to LAJ12345

Thanks

You may also like...

Quite an interesting article. Thoughts?

Restless Leg - Interesting Article

Article says iron is not getting across the BBB. Wonder if helps with PD. They are trying to

Interesting article in support of MSM methylsulfonylmethane

took that, have not taken any in quite a while. Our diets are practically devoid of sulfur.

A good article on Levodopa (dosage, toxicity, precautions etc)

Reducing oxidative stress and inflammation to slow Parkinson's disease

electrophiles. You find these in food and the best are in broccoli. Yep! Eat your greens! It's...