klonopin vs Xanax : hey y’all! So I’m... - Anxiety and Depre...

Anxiety and Depression Support

88,370 members82,871 posts

klonopin vs Xanax

Siobhanny profile image
23 Replies

hey y’all! So I’m on my 6th go of trying new meds for my panic disorder. Tried a lot of things in the past and right now my Dr is thinking of adding either klonopin or xanax to my twice daily buspirone, but I told her I wanted to ask around first. I know everyone experiences things differently but I’d be interested to know anyone’s experience adding either of these to their roster.

And if I should lean towards one over the other?

a little bit of my back story is I’m 30 and I’ve been diagnosed with panic disorder, health anxiety and agoraphobia and have been living with this for about 5 years. I’ve been off and on stuff in the past and have hated most things I’ve been on. So far buspirone has been the least terrible but makes me super nauseous and uncoordinated. I also do a lot of meditation and endurance running as some other methods of medicine but totally interested in trying others! Any advice is appreciated ☺️

Written by
Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
23 Replies
Nothing_but_books profile image
Nothing_but_books

No one can tell you more than their personal experience. One person may react badly to a drug, and another be fine.

One more thing: If you've never taken a benzo, you should know there are tolerance issues that can lead to dependency. The more you take it, the less it works. And it's hell cutting back.

You'll probably get more answers if you lock your post for privacy.

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to Nothing_but_books

Thank you 😊 and exactly, I am looking for peoples personal experiences. And I know that those could be different from mine. But I could find comfort later if I start to experience something that someone else did and I can reflect on it here and feel less scared and less alone.

Coming off the meds is for sure one of my worries, but I think living in my current situation any longer is more worrying. I’m being told the plan would be to take it while I go through more intense CBT and then pull back. So hopefully not long enough to have long lasting issues.

Starrlight profile image
Starrlight

benzos worked great for me but I became addicted.

I found that at first none worked. It took taking them a good number of times until I felt any results.

Nothing_but_books profile image
Nothing_but_books in reply to Starrlight

Pretty much everyone does, to one degree or another.

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to Starrlight

Thank you for sharing :) That’s for sure something I’m trying to be cautious of. But I am nervous of letting my attacks get worse too. So I’m still weighing out my pros and cons

Agora1 profile image
Agora1

Hi Siobhanny, my personal journey started with a small amt of Xanax .

A half tablet of 0.25 mg once a day. Practically nothing but it helped with

Anxiety as well as my Migraines. That is until it didn't work anymore.

But I wouldn't have traded the time it bought me while I went through

therapy as well as finding other methods/tools that I use to this day.

Good Luck with your choice. :) xx

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to Agora1

Thank you for sharing that ☺️ of course I have some time left to decide and hearing everyone else’s experiences helps try to decide what will work for me. And My migraines have been thru the roof lately, I’d do most things for a quick break lol

designguy profile image
designguy

Klonopin was the only med that directly helped reduce my anxiety and I didn't have trouble getting off of it, I just did a slow taper. I've never tried xanax so I can't tell you the difference between the two from my experience. i did a psychopharmacological test a number of years ago that used my dna to determine which meds were best suited for me genetically and my test showed that either Klonopin or Xanax would work for me.

Hope61 profile image
Hope61 in reply to designguy

how did you do the genetic testing?

designguy profile image
designguy in reply to Hope61

Mine was prescribed by my therapist and the test was from Genesight and paid for by my insurance.

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to designguy

My dr has told me that I’d most like have an easier time stopping klonopin so that’s nice to hear that that was the case for you, since I’m worried about coming off them most.

designguy profile image
designguy in reply to Siobhanny

Just taper off slowly and slower even than what most doctors recommend, it took me about 3 months to taper off. I even used an xacto knife and cut the pills into smaller pieces although a pill cutter from your pharmacy will work well also. The other thing is to taper off when you feel good emotionally and balanced and not overly stressed to make it easier for yourself and also know that you will probably have some anxiousness about quitting but that is normal.

MrsMaagu profile image
MrsMaagu

try massage!

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to MrsMaagu

Thanks MrsMaagu! I’m so afraid of going but I think that would be a great thing to try, maybe I’ll pull the band aid off and go for it

Craigliving4Jane profile image
Craigliving4Jane

I have a ton of experience with Buspar and Clonopin . How much busprine are u taking

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to Craigliving4Jane

Right now I’m at 30mg.

Craigliving4Jane profile image
Craigliving4Jane in reply to Siobhanny

I’m a biggger guy 6’3 275 who’s been taking Klonopin for 20 year at .5 mg per day. I was at 5mg for 6-7 years on Buspar and my anxiety was horrible. Year ago they upped my Buspar to 30 mg a day and it helped immensely. I’m not a 60 a day. 80-90% reduction in symptoms, so for me I was pretty under medicated and suffered from it for many years. That’s on me.

It’s so hard to know how each person will react but I will say this. I wasn’t aggressive enough and suffered too long from it.

All the best

Hope61 profile image
Hope61

dont do it! I am coming off 0.5 xanax and it is being replaced with Klanipin and 10 mg Lexapro. I am going through HELL with withdrawl syptoms!

Siobhanny profile image
Siobhanny in reply to Hope61

Oh no I’m so sorry to hear that, that must be horrible. They want me to change from buspirone to lexapro (then add Xanax or klonopin) and I’ve been reluctant to make the switch.

I hope it gets easier for you, you’ve got this <3

Starrlight profile image
Starrlight in reply to Hope61

I hope you feel better soon Hope.

Atlantic77 profile image
Atlantic77

Any benzos should only be used in the very short term, otherwise very high risk of severe dependence and crippling withdrawal symptoms. Basically it just pushes the problem down the road but there is a heavy price to pay. If you can you would be well advised to avoid them!

Barbloki profile image
Barbloki

I've never tried klonapin but I've been on xanax for many years and it works for me BUT... it has the be the correct manufacturer. Last year I refilled at Walgreens and started taking it and nothing was happening. I was still in panic mode. Come to find out they changed to sandoz brand and it wasn't working for me. I found out from my therapist that these generic manufacturers are only required to put 51% of the active ingredient and they can cut it/buffer it with anything else. I had to get my dr to write a new prescription for a different manufacturer of xanax and it started working again. I hope you find something that works for you.

Beevee profile image
Beevee

Try letting your panic disorder pass through, mustering as much acceptance as you can throughout. In other words relaxing your mind as much you can instead of tensing up and thinking "oh no, here it comes again 😱"

Allowing yourself to feel the waves of panic wash over you with a relaxed attitude, will eventually draw its sting and those panic attacks [they are just an adrenalin rush designed to protect you from perceived danger] will gradually disappear.

It is our fear or intense dislike of these uncomfortable feelings that continually fuels the anxiety fire.

For more information about overcoming panic disorder or any other fear based disorder [e.g. GAD, agoraphobia, health & social anxiety, OCD, PTSD etc etc...they are all the same thing with fear being the common denominator] look up Dr Claire Weekes and practice her teachings in full.

Learn to cope with the sumptoms the right way and recovery will follow.

Acceptance is the best tranquilliser. It's free and you can carry it round with you for ever. ❤️

You may also like...

Klonopin

I've never taken Klonopin for this long. in the past only a month or two. And i've been reading...

Any experience with Klonopin?

see him. He has been my doctor for years and knows me quite well. He prescribed Klonopin 1mg at...

Xanax when it's really bad

all my body tenses and I have panic..I have been under alot of stress lately but never had this...

Herbal supplements? Xanax? Esketamine?

(I'm skeptical but ya gotta try everything). I'm also interested in Xanax but not sure if it's...

New here / Xanax prescription

get into it, but now my panic attacks may prevent me from doing so. I've been working really hard...