Falling ALT - Pathway to Sarcopenia? ... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,380 members26,746 posts

Falling ALT - Pathway to Sarcopenia? - More Exercise Needed?

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
32 Replies

Two years in to my de novo high volume metastatic prostate cancer diagnosis, I am pleased to report excellent results so far with triplet therapy (Docetaxel chemo completed, Abiraterone ARPI, Firmagon/Degarelix GnRH antagonist as ADT).

However I would be grateful for any advice today. My ALT has fallen from about 35 steadily down to about 22 now. I've been struggling to exercise. All my other markers are pretty good in my PSA is sort of undetectable.

But I see that a low ALT maybe evidence of declining muscle mass and pointing in the direction of sarcopenia. Of course sarcopenia is predictive of progression and reduced LE.

If I push myself to exercise again, and maybe even build a little more muscle mass, is it possible that the ALT marker will rise?

Written by
JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
32 Replies
Mgtd profile image
Mgtd

John all I feel even remotely qualified to comment on is your actual exercise modality. Its effect on your blood is truly beyond my knowledge. I will leave that to a real expert.

In regards to exercise there are three things that you need to consider - Form, Intensity and Duration. These are really best addressed by getting instruction and guidance from someone trained in the field.

After your initial training and plan development then perhaps a 3 month follow up is appropriate to make sure you are on track in regards to those three above.

OzzieJ profile image
OzzieJ

For what its worth my ALT is 12. So not sure what to read into that. My white and red cell counts are also on the low border of normal or just outside.

Everyone says to exercise but whenever I try to get into a fitness regime I end up completely fatigued and it is difficult to get through the normal week of work and family stuff which takes priority.

Ive been on ADT and Apalutamide for the last 20 mths.

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to OzzieJ

Fantastic comment Ozzie; it really resonates. I do take methylphenidate pills a couple of times a day (Ritalin). And I have a pretty good exercise plan (per Mgtd above, good advice). This is important because it's hard to figure out how to exercise!

For example, the importance of Zone 2 (just walking briskly); whether one should have high intensity intervals; how to do resistance exercise otherwise known as weights when three of my vertebrae could fracture at any moment; the question of weekly exercise volume (there is evidence that volume counts and I was targeting 10 hours a week). The balance between aerobic, resistance and even isometric exercise. Apparently any exercise is good exercise.

And as we know the myokines which are generated especially by resistance exercise are also anti-cancer adjuncts. But then again I'm tired. I find that the support for the importance of exercise for people with metastatic prostate cancer is not really there in the depth that is needed.

My RBC's are little low and I'm slightly anemic. From what I read apparently my slight anemia is probably not because I'm not getting enough iron - and thus supplements are of no help and could even be dangerous of course. My anemia is probably driven by a prostate cancer specific process.

About every 6 weeks or so I get a blood panel with 20 different things. And there isn't a lot of interpretation as to the implications.

Our goal of course is to avoid progression, resistance, and sarcopenia! And in terms of things that we can do, exercise number one!

My next plan is I'm going to try to make an effort of the will to exercise!

OzzieJ profile image
OzzieJ in reply to JohnInTheMiddle

Did your onco prescribe the Ritalin? Do you know if there are any studies I can refer to? Maybe I can try that...

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to OzzieJ

My palliative care doc prescribed it. It's a long story, I wasn't expected to be thriving. But GP's can probably prescribe. If you look there's quite a bit of literature (see methylphenidate too). Watch your BP.

mrscruffy profile image
mrscruffy

In my personal experience I worked out doing HIIT and lifting heavy. I actually lost muscle until I got my nutrition right and started taking body building supplements. In the following 2 years I added lots of muscle lifting heavy 4 days a week and cardio two days a week. It can be done. Good luck in your journey

Schwah profile image
Schwah in reply to mrscruffy

What supplements did you take? Any concerns those may feed your cancer?

Schwah

mrscruffy profile image
mrscruffy in reply to Schwah

MO approved of all supplements taken, my trainer has gone to appts with me to ask about them too. I take creatine, BCCA's and a non FDA approved substance called Ostarine which is a SARM. MO knew exactly what it was and how it worked as it was an early PC drug. Introduction of the Ostarine really turned things around for muscle growth

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle

Thanks Mrs. Cruffy!

mrscruffy profile image
mrscruffy in reply to JohnInTheMiddle

Come on man it's Mr. Scruffy hahahaha

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to mrscruffy

Oh sorry, I will get it right in the future. I appreciate your ongoing helpful messages 😃

London441 profile image
London441

There are of course a number of possible reasons for your low ALT, but if you’re concerned about sarcopenia have you had a dexa scan lately? The detail of body composition it provides what you need to know about that. Then you can exercise towards the predictable goal of increasing your lean muscle mass while lowering body fat-but armed with the numbers to mark your progress. Good times!

As one of my favorite guys Dr Mark Moyad says, ‘if you don’t measure it, it doesn’t exist!’

Despite your vulnerable vertebrae, you should still be able to lift weights with parts of your body safely. Get specific guidance if necessary. Nothing is more important.

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to London441

Thanks London - this is good advice. I saw a reference once in a paper on the topic of prostate cancer and metastasis to bones - and to the fact that biomechanical engineering analysis, which while it is an actual thing, is basically not available. This is a missing and important service that can make a big difference. Why? Because then you have specific details on how to exercise safely. And in fact bone breakage is an important event in the decline of many men metastatic prostate cancer.

London441 profile image
London441 in reply to JohnInTheMiddle

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl....

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to London441

Super thanks for sharing this comprehensive article London! I actually have participated in a study that encouraged exercise. And as the article mentions the field is growing rapidly. My sense is though that the value of exercise and guidelines on how to do it is still mostly missing in action. Exercise for men with metastatic prostate cancer is enormously important! Both for quality of life and strength and avoidance of injury - and also even directly working against progression. I'm still fatigued.

London441 profile image
London441 in reply to JohnInTheMiddle

You’re a smart man, moreover your comments on here are always supportive and detailed. Put the weights up front! All the exercise is good, but for ADT fatigue lifting is superior. Just go. 90% of it truly is just showing up.

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to London441

100% that 90% of life is just showing up 😂. And 100% on board with starting with weights, aka resistance exercise etc. Can't be said often enough.

Gs-rider profile image
Gs-rider

Exercise is a cornerstone, allways. It must go hand in hand with good nutrition, allways.

SimMartin profile image
SimMartin

I’m confused as I thought it’s High ALT that the issue and 22 is I thought normally considered good ? Or am I missing something in us PCa guys !?

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to SimMartin

Good question Sim - in my case it seems that I'm now on the borderline of concern in terms of the graph that the hospital gives me - but the big concern is the direction it's a steady decline over the last year. From what I read this points to muscle mass loss.

Cape1 profile image
Cape1

John, although I hadn’t done much swimming since my teen years, I’ve now made it the cornerstone of my exercise and I’m having a very good remission. By definition, swimming laps is the definition of HIIT, as you can stop between sprinting each lap, for a rest phase, or in my case , rapidly bouncing/bounding, which simulates being on a trampoline, while building bone , leg and arm muscle. I’m 69 , and have built up to swimming 28 fast laps. Also, my homegrown “freestyle “ involves holding my breath the entire 40 yards, so I’m doing great things for my heart rate. No risk of falling or bone breaks. You might try it.

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to Cape1

Your swimming program Cape is fantastic! Although I don't understand the bounding part. I have read specifically that swimming is fantastic for aerobics, especially in the volume you do, and I really like the holding your breath part, but I've seen actual research that it doesn't help build bones because it's so low impact. But then you mentioned bounding and bouncing! 😃

Cape1 profile image
Cape1 in reply to JohnInTheMiddle

Go in the deep end of pool and jump up and down , coming up quickly off the bottom, as if on a trampoline. That’s bouncing.

Do that same concept while moving across the pool, and that is bounding

My legs, knees etc get plenty of value

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to Cape1

Wow that's fantastic!

Cape1 profile image
Cape1

and here’s an interesting fact, Perplexity AI says that people who play tennis into old age live ten years longer than those who don’t! I played a lot of tennis in years gone by, but it’s too much now. However, if you think about it, the bounding/bouncing involves a lot of arms flaying and twisting and turning that comes very close to whatever might be good about tennis. Imo, it’s about moving lymph, which basically just sits there, unlike blood. Just walking or even light weights does not accomplish what is needed.

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to Cape1

Apparently bones are not fixed but astonishingly are living in constantly adapting and building and rebuilding themselves all the time. It's amazing! So that's why exercise is so helpful because it can help the bones in their job. The bones respond to stresses and strains and especially impacts. Little impact such as brisk walking or pounding on the clay of a tennis court sends the right signals to the bones.By the way the lives longer by 10 years if you play tennis all your life sounds like a really sketchy study. It's the best possible example of correlation not being causation. Because tennis is well known as a sport of the upper middle and upper class. And of course such cohorts live longer. 😂

LongTimeRunning profile image
LongTimeRunning

Your ALT seems to be still within reference range: <50 (lifelabs), 5-48 (labcorp (US)).

I've only had 2 recorded ALT measurements before starting ADT, one was ALT of 24 and the other was 19. The ALT 19 one was the day after a 18 mile run (possible factor) but a PSA of 24.1 was measured at the same time. After about 15 months ADT, ALT has moved around a bit: on April 11, 2024 it was 23 but up to 28 on May 2, 2024, other times in 30s.

Strenuous exercise can raise ALT, but usually this is transient.

I'm also slightly anemic, confirmed by MO that it is caused by ADT treatment (my ferritin levels are normal, so no iron intake issues).

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle

Interesting. In fact my ferritin levels are high. As for ALT I liked what your comment about exercise driving it up, even if it is a little transient. This is my "something that I can do that's not crazy" plan right now. Build muscle mass by more consistently exercising.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

It all went south when we lost the love muscle.

Good Luck, Good Health Good Humor.

j-o-h-n

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle in reply to j-o-h-n

Oh well. I'm OK in this new existence. Happy to have more time. No hankering for before. Sorry could not find a more humorous way of putting this 😂

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Funny enough..........But you left out how women used it a gear shift lever and practiced shifting gears with it.......

Good Luck, Good Health Good Humor.

j-o-h-n

JohnInTheMiddle profile image
JohnInTheMiddle

Plural?

You may also like...

How much exercise needed?

the ADT makes recovery from exercise longer. So I’m actually thinking of scaling back exercise even

More articles reinforcing the role of Exercise and PCa mortality

cancer/138999-understanding-the-mechanisms-of-exercise-as-a-medicine-to-increase-survival-of-men-wit

And again news about clinical trials

trial tests creatine monohydrate and exercise to preserve muscle mass in prostate cancer ...

I want to try SARM's-Yes or No?

month off ADT and receiving an injection of testosterone the month off of ADT before restarting...

Testosterone Recovery During Intermittent ADT

replacement for myself for my severe sarcopenia (loss of muscle mass that resulted in a collapsed...