Walking v Running. Which is better - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,084 members61,312 posts

Walking v Running. Which is better

Annde70 profile image
11 Replies

For those of you like me who find problems with jogging/running this article is very encouraging I no longer feel that I am not worthy as I cannot jog, in fact it has made me feel that I am doing my self a service by my regular walking.

prevention.com/fitness/how-...

Shared via the Google

Written by
Annde70 profile image
Annde70
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
11 Replies
Itsbab profile image
Itsbab

It's good to hear my walking and treadmill ( still walking, I am not built for running yet) is still of huge benefit and may be even better for you. I have also this morning been watching a natural arthritis cure program as I have it in my hip and conclusion seems to be a mainly plant based diet, gentle exercise and a good nights sleep.

Osiris275 profile image
Osiris275

I don't run, I couldn't t at first although I'm sure I could now but I'd be too embarrassed! I only do walking but I've lost nearly 6 stone so it must be enough.

VickyDLM profile image
VickyDLM2 stone in reply toOsiris275

I don't like running either Osiris! Even when I was younger (and smaller!) I was on the larger side, chest wise. And running with big boobs is just uncomfortable and, as you say, embarrassing. :(

Osiris275 profile image
Osiris275 in reply toVickyDLM

Ha, mine have gone from big to just saggy now 😜 bad side of weight loss!

I'd actually like to be able to go running. But I live in a small village full of gossip mongerers and I'd be convinced everyone was looking at me. Truth is probably no one would even notice or care!

VickyDLM profile image
VickyDLM2 stone in reply toOsiris275

I was very pleased when mine started to shrink! Could still use more shrinkage though. :)

I suppose you could always walk out of town and then start running when you're out of sight?

Look on the bright side, at least you don't live in Midsomer! ;)

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61

Exercise of any kind is a massive improvement for me!! But j do try to do some intense cardio on an exercise bike as well these days as my fitness has improved 😊

I'm sorry to hear you feel judged as 'not worthy' somehow for not running. I didn't feel like that back when I thought I couldn't run - I just thought I'm not a runner, it's something that 'other people' do... it was as much a surprise to me as it would be to anyone to realise I could when I managed it by the end of couch to 5k! But a point here is perhaps that not everyone can run as we all start from different points of health/physical ability, and it's important to bear that in mind. All exercise is definitely good, I really believe in little and often, things that are sustainable and that we enjoy :)

Annde70 profile image
Annde70

It was a comment made last week. I pointed out that due to my knees I was unable to join in and was made to feel that I was making excuses not to try. I was also told the thread was for those wishing to partake and not for people to post negative comments. To be honest I was angry. I walk miles, I do Aqua aerobics 3 - 4 times a week and to be put down like that was offensive and not what I expected from this forum

I just found this article and thought that it might be encouraging for others, like me, who for one reason or another find jogging painful.

I am sure the person encouraging the programme is doing great but must realise that it is not for everyone

I regret ever having posted on his thread but at least it encouraged be to search out the benefits of walking and I have found that a positive from a negative experience

Fran182716 profile image
Fran182716

I enjoyed running when I was younger (and thinner lol) but wouldn't now due to arthritis in my feet. I guess you could reduce the risk of further joint damage by running on a springy surface, but though physical excercise is important, walking is about much more than that to me. It relieves stress and lifts my spirits, if I was going faster I would miss some of the beauty around me. I like to stop and chat with people along the way, especially those with dogs which I find a comfort having recently lost mine. I think running is great for those who enjoy it but walking is just as worthy. With really good boots or trainers I'm hoping to protcet my foot joints enough to be walking and hiking well into old age (51 now)

Annde70 profile image
Annde70 in reply toFran182716

I'm 69 so I think walking is fine 😊

lowcaloriesteve profile image
lowcaloriesteve in reply toAnnde70

I am 63 do lots of walking .but also get the bike out in the summer.its all down to what works for you.lost 70lbs so not complaining .also i never run !

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Walking the weight off

I'm not adverse to walking, but today I discovered just how many calories can be burned by putting...

Walking!

Hi, I'm following my exercise plan from my Samsung health app which is great as it calculates my...
Hoops501 profile image

Which is better?

Is calorie intake worse than fat intake. Can anyone advise. Thanks.
CHRISSIE21 profile image

Tortoise and Hare Running Club 23rd - 29th December 2019

Hello everyone and Welcome to the Tortoise and Hare Running Club ! Here we share our running/...

walking

Is walking good for weight loss as I am unable to run due to a serious leg I jury
gunge80 profile image

Moderation team

See all
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator
moreless profile image
morelessAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.