Hey Houston we have a problem!: After Helen's... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,182 members166,424 posts

Hey Houston we have a problem!

helenshubby profile image
28 Replies

After Helen's last set of results we decided to take things into our own hands and start with some supplements after a long discussion with Greygoose and Jaydee 1507 we have been useing the following:

1. Magnesium Bisgycinate which has been changed to Magnesium Citrate as Helen became bound up, However despite switching she has still had issues in going to the toilet and still has feels full but not bloated.

2. Vit D3 3000iu

3. Methyl B12 sublingual spray use 1st then go to B12 Complex

4. B12 Complex (B complex Thorne Basic B discontinue 4-7 days before any blood test). (Also individual B12 and Folate for that period prior to any testing.

5. Increase Potassium using natural sources.

6. Vit K2

7. Colloidal Silver nasal spray & XClear nasal spray to help clear her sinuses. I've been told using the spray should not interfere with T4 absorption.

8. Zinc

9. Selenium

10. Levothyroxin 100 mcg/day

Already on 2, 5, 8, 9, 10.

We are not taking the full recommended doses and Helen had a blood test last Tuesday after about 5 weeks on this regime and Blue Horizon have confirmed receipt of the sample last week. We have yet to have the results.

Can anyone explain why she is still having this feeling of abdominal fullness but not costipation and decrease in bowel movements. It is becoming frustrating for both of us but I guess until we can compare the blood results from her last medichecks and this Blue Horizon Test which I will do as % through the range as opposed to the actual readings to see what effect these supplements. I will come back with the results when we get them but if anyone has any ideas why Helen is having trouble going to the loo when she's started a supplement that should help her go isn't other than the fact she is taking less than she needs where she is tempted to stop it altogether as she was going better without the ssupplements.

Written by
helenshubby profile image
helenshubby
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
28 Replies
greygoose profile image
greygoose

Firstly, how much magnesium is she taking?

Secondly, do you know if she has low stomach acid, because that would cause the feeling of fullness, and the constipation.

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply togreygoose

Low Stomach acid would obviously have an effect on Helen’s nutrition intake yet we need to get all her bloods into the 3rd percentile including her T3 before we can see how she is progressing. I am trying to handle and manage Helen’s expectations, without a Dr onside because as far as they are concerned her bloods are in “range”, so don’t want to know despite her still not feeling well. Regarding

Blue Horizon have confirmed receipt of Helen’s bloods last Thursday and because it’s the full well woman test it’s a seven day turn round so I doubt we’ll get the results till tomorrow or the weekend. I am also having to deal with the fall out from my Dad’s death in March and to top it off my Mum died last week so we have got to get probate sorted for both which I am doing as my brother and sister are more involved in the hands on management and sorting the house out and only my brother lives close by, and is the only one of us still working.

This is in addition to my own spinal problem where information is slowly being drip fed out by the medics that suggests my lower spinal cord and cauda equina have taken 4 and possibly 5 separate hits in different places.

So you can see we’ve got our hands full.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tohelenshubby

You have indeed got your hands full! I appreciate that. But I don't see what any of that has to do with Helen's stomach acid. Blood tests won't tell you that. And no point going to a doctor about that because they refuse to recognise that low stomach acid is a thing, although we hypo patients know it is a thing!

Get her to do the burb test and take it from there:

loveleafco.com/baking-soda-...

healthline.com/health/hypoc...

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply tohelenshubby

Hi, we've got Helen's Blue Horizon test results back and I am somewhat concerned about them. Firstly, they were supposed to be in a 24 hour tracked envelope to the lab and took 51 hours to arrive so I am concerned somewhat that her sample was haemolysed by the time it got there. Can I send you by PM the last 4 tests she's had done including the BH ones which show a high Ferritin at 355, Vt D barely moved up from last test done a few months ago despite sublingual VitD/k2, B12 >150 on only 300mcg sublingual/day. slightly high Selenium and magnesium, but normal copper and zinc as well as high Cholesterol with virtually unchanged T3, T4 levels. There's a few other things that concern me as well like a high MCV. We've stopped the magnesium and cut the selenium back to one every other day. I'd be interested in your thoughts. This really is difficult given the delay in getting it to the lab. Did the nurse hold onto it too long/put it in a post box where the next collection was next day etc etc.

TiggerMe profile image
TiggerMeAmbassador in reply tohelenshubby

I'm not sure who you were aiming this at as you have replied to yourself? I shall tag in   greygoose and   SlowDragon

The lab would have rejected the blood if it were too old or haemolysed so the fact you have results suggests no issue, best to post up results here where you will receive various input 🤗

RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

helenshubby 'Can I send you by PM the last 4 tests she's had done '

We strongly advise against doing this. Neither greygoose nor anyone else here is medically qualified, and should not be expected to take personal responsibility in this way. The whole point of a forum is to share such information publicly, so that it can be fully moderated, challenged, commented on, and of help to others.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply tohelenshubby

Don't know if this was in reply to me, but I agree with the other: post the results here.

In any case, these results won't tell you if she has low stomach acid - although they might suggest it. I don't understand why you're ignoring that possibility when I explained to you that it could be the reason for her constipation and feeling full. I would have thought you would want to explore all avenues - especially when it's only a matter of drinking a glass of bicarb. :)

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply togreygoose

Stopping the magnesium has started to ease Helen’s bloated tummy and it was her that made the connection so can’t argue there. Also cut Selenium down to one every other day as this was a suggestion by previous surgery.

There was a caution on the results re RBC’s due to delay and response by the BH Dr was plain weird. Having spent a large sum of money on two full blood tests plus 24 hour cortisols x 2 I’m a little disappointed with PO not getting a 24 hr tracked to the lab in time. Whether the nurse stuck the bloods in our local post box which is collected at 0700 or it was simple incompetence on the part of Royal Mail is a matter for conjecture. If the nurse I would expect her to at least read Collection times on the box before posting and if RM it’s pretty disgusting if she took it to a box that’s emptied regularly. I will be taking up with BH as to be honest I not sure which results we can rely on and which are dubious. The BH GP was suggesting Helen may have liver issues when her LFT’s are within range. It’s going to take a while to put the last 4 bloods together from early last year up for comment but I’m puzzled by the ferritin and TFT results and singular lack of movement on max vitD/K2 spray as it’s barely shifted despite an increase in dose to 3000iu which is the max we can put into her. Helen’s TFT’s show her T4 at 20.2 and and T3 at 4.4 which is almost identical and a TSH a bit higher than last time when it should be around 1. I doubt if I’ll be able to post anything til Tuesday as we have so much going on as a result of losing Mum so folks can view the findings.

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

and singular lack of movement on max vitD/K2 spray as it’s barely shifted despite an increase in dose to 3000iu which is the max we can put into her

Why is this the maximum dose?

Many members on here find they need 4000-6000iu daily

Better You Vitamin D with K2

One spray = 1000iu

Try 4 sprays per day

Personally I take 5-6 sprays everyday

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

high Ferritin at 355,

Extremely common for ferritin to increase post menopause

Ferritin also rises with inflammation

Probably absolutely fine

Presumably she isn’t taking any iron supplements or multivitamins that contain iron? If she is …stop them

If concerned, get FULL iron panel test every 3-4 years

Test early morning, only water to drink between waking and test. Avoid high iron rich dinner night before test

Medichecks iron panel test

medichecks.com/products/iro...

Updated reference ranges for top of ferritin range depending upon age

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Thank you for your incredible patience while you have been awaiting the outcome of our ferritin reference range review. We conducted this with Inuvi lab, which has now changed the reference ranges to the following:

Females 18 ≤ age < 40. 30 to 180

Females 40 ≤ age < 50. 30 to 207

Females 50 ≤ age < 60. 30 to 264l

Females Age ≥ 60. 30 to 332

Males 18 ≤ age < 40 30 to 442

Males Age ≥ 40 30 to 518

The lower limits of 30 are by the NICE threshold of <30 for iron deficiency. Our review of Medichecks data has determined the upper limits. This retrospective study used a large dataset of blood test results from 25,425 healthy participants aged 18 to 97 over seven

Vt D barely moved up from last test done a few months ago despite sublingual VitD/k2,

what’s the result

How much vitamin D is she taking

Very common to need higher dose with thyroid disease

B12 >150 on only 300mcg sublingual/day.

that’s normal on B12 supplements

you can swap to just vitamin B complex now

slightly high Selenium and magnesium, but normal copper and zinc

We've stopped the magnesium and cut the selenium back to one every other day

Reduce, rather than stop magnesium

Selenium….perhaps just taking twice week

high Cholesterol with virtually unchanged T3, T4 levels.

What are Ft4 and Ft3 levels

High cholesterol directly linked to low thyroid levels

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply toSlowDragon

TC was 6.89 but HDL Cholesterol was 1.7 and TC/HDL ratio was just over 4. When Underwriting we took a ratio of less than 5 as being OK regardless of TC levels.

FT3 4.4 and FT4 20.2. FT 4 higher than last time when it was just over 19. I will set up a table of Helen's last 4 bloods going back to Feb '23 to see if anyone can spot some trends & post sometime next week. We've been hit by so many things lately we don't know if we are coming or going!

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

What’s range on Ft4 and Ft3

What was TSH

How long has she been on 100mcg

Always same brand at each prescription ?

Was test early morning, ideally before 9am, only drinking water between waking and test and last dose levothyroxine 24 hours before test

Sinus issues suggests dairy intolerance

Is she on dairy free diet and lactose free levothyroxine

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply toSlowDragon

TSH 1.53 (0.27 - 4.20) Free T4 (12.0 - 22.0) Free T3 (3.1 - 6.8) on 100 Mcg over a year and luckily same brand until recently. Lloyds bailed out of our local pharmacy and now it's independent but run by ?NHS Helen's had Teva [in the past, And Accord and current ones are Hillcross but show MA holder as Accord. Contents: Anhydrous Levothyroxine sodium, lactose, magnesium stearate, maize starch, stearic acid and pre gelatinised maize starch.

Takes Arlo Lactose free skimmed Milk, Lemon Tea, DeCaf Tea, water, Actimel which I think you can only get as dairy as there is a cow's head imprinted ion the bottles. Gluten free seedless bread Kirstie's apple pie, Gluten free Lemon dessert from Morrisons. Rest of diet Fish, Red/white meat, fresh vegetables and fruit, some frozen. And Galaxy Chocolate a couple of nights a week. Can't really think of Much else except a Cream Horn once a week. Also Morrisons Gingerbread offerings!

Can't think of anything else. So what do you suggest we do?

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

Dairy free means dairy free….not lactose free

Many thyroid patients react to enzymes in dairy not the lactose

Look at dairy free milk alternatives

Oatly is good option - widely available in most supermarkets

plenishdrinks.com/shop/mult...?

Avoid the “barista” version as it has sunflower oil added ….makes it bitter

Actimel do make a dairy free -

personally I don’t like the taste

groceries.asda.com/product/...

Or you can get other prebiotics dairy free

Eg

Biomel love your gut (chocolate one is good)

Available in supermarkets

biomel.life/products/biomel...?

And Galaxy Chocolate a couple of nights a week. Can't really think of Much else except a Cream Horn once a week

Obviously these contain dairy

Loads of fantastic vegan chocolate available now

And ditch the cream horn for something dairy and gluten free

Gingerbread also needs to be dairy and gluten free

There’s little point being “almost” gluten free or dairy free

It has to be strictly to be effective

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

Free T4 (fT4) 20.4 pmol/L (12 - 22) 84.0%

Free T3 (fT3) 4.4 pmol/L (3.1 - 6.8) 35.1%

Thyroid results show poor conversion rate

Extremely common on just levothyroxine

Hence significant numbers of patients need SMALL DOSES of T3 prescribed alongside levothyroxine

Here’s link for how to request Thyroid U.K.list of private Doctors emailed to you, but within the email a link to download list of recommended thyroid specialist endocrinologists who will prescribe T3

Ideally choose an endocrinologist to see privately initially and who also does NHS consultations

thyroiduk.org/contact-us/ge...

suggest you retest again 6-8 weeks after being absolutely strictly gluten and dairy free

Assuming Ft3 remains low ….then look at adding T3

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

vitamin D

Been taking 3000iu daily

Suggest you increase vitamin D by a 1000iu daily

Retest again at next test

May need higher dose, especially in winter

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

until you get thyroid results back you don’t know yet if she is not on high enough dose levothyroxine

Or if she needs T3 added if Ft3 is low

How much magnesium citrate is she using

Calm Vitality magnesium powder (mag citrate) is easy to adjust dose

Start with a teaspoon in small glass warm water at bedtime (or early evening 4 hours before if taking levothyroxine at bedtime)

increase dose slowly until get desired improvement. Too much can cause diarrhoea

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply toSlowDragon

This is what we’ve swapped to Magnesium Supplements High Strength 1480mg - 240 Magnesium Citrate Capsules (not Magnesium Tablets) 444mg Elemental Vegan Magnesium Powder Capsules for Women & Men - 4 Month Supply - VitaBright UK from Amazon.

SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator in reply tohelenshubby

I would get Calm vitality magnesium powder.

Cheap and flexible on amount you take

Distressedthyroid profile image
Distressedthyroid

I found taking a combination of chai, hemp and flax seeds greatly improved my digestion.

Marz profile image
Marz

VitC can also help improve gut motility - keep increasing to bowel tolerance...

Diet ? Water ? I have had a few gut surgeries for Crohns since diagnosis some 50 years ago - have managed without drugs and focus on diet to the best of my ability. Also good quality water...

Ukie profile image
Ukie

Just to let you know, Medichecks are currently suggesting 2 weeks without B12 before a blood test.

Chasing-rainbows profile image
Chasing-rainbows in reply toUkie

Is it 2 weeks for biotin or just B12?

Ukie profile image
Ukie in reply toChasing-rainbows

Letter from Medichecks

Letter from Medichecks saying no B12 for 2 weeks before blood test.
helenshubby profile image
helenshubby in reply toUkie

We need to see what benefit the extra B12 and b complex vitamins are providing so unless there is a specific effect on other test results we won’t be doing that. We need to know how much the 300 mcg Helen is taking sub lingularly are increasing her levels to somewhere in the 3rd percentile of the range but thanks for the info.

helenshubby profile image
helenshubby

regarding the biotin Blue Horizon only wanted biotin stopped for 72 hours. I think we got to almost 92 (Friday through to Tuesday)

FoggyThinker profile image
FoggyThinker

I certainly get that symptom when undermedicated, so it'll be interesting to know how Helen's results come out.

All the best to you both.

silverbelle51 profile image
silverbelle51

Most of what you are talking about I can't address with surety, but the constipation. fullness I will address because when you put food in it must be processed and eliminated to remain healthy or else your body goes TOXIC ! What works instead of a lot of OTC chemicals that can actually cause possible problems I recommend unsweetened apple sauce 1/4 cup with a TBSP or 2 of grd. flax seed and plain yogurt about 1/4 c or more if you like . You have your prebiotics and probiotics which your gut needs to function well . It is really healthy and found this on you tube put up by a couple of physical therapist it works and will also reduce your BP . You also need to stay hydrated about 8 glasses of fluid a day and physically active as best you can . It works for me. I use Magwell Magnesium which is a combination with Zinc and Vit D3 and like that product as well and can be purchased on Amazon . I use Amazon a lot cause stores her in U.S.A. are not all that well stocked with a variety. Wish you well !

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

High FT3 level and other results.

Hi my daughter has just received her results from Blue Horizon and her FT3 is very high. She was...
lucylocks profile image

Thrown a Curve Ball with my daughters latest results. Advice please...

My daughter on 100mcg T4 daily for 3 years. Endo thought she wasn't converting to enough T3 so for...
KIRM profile image

My friends results

My friend who has no thyroid condition had her bloods checked recently. She has cold hands, feet...
McPammy profile image

Best thing for us to do is to keep complaining to Drs/Endos/etc to carry out tests we know we need! We add FT3 TPO etc on our blood forms!

My GP rang me earlier regarding messages I sent online. He said come for face to face appointment...
Thyb profile image

6wk blood test results - MediChecks

Hi all Here is my up to date results from today. I’ve been on levo 50mcg since 24th April. My TSH...
betty2480 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.