A ONE-ARMED man trying to claim disab... - Fibromyalgia Acti...

Fibromyalgia Action UK

59,855 members66,977 posts

A ONE-ARMED man trying to claim disability benefits said staff asked if he thought his limb might grow back.

esagestapo profile image
12 Replies

Gary Swift, whose right limb is missing from below the elbow, says he faced the question while being medically assessed.

He had applied for an employment and support allowance — paid to people who can’t work through disability — and went to the meeting with his carer mum Tracey Perkins.

They say the interviewer asked: “Do you expect your condition to improve? Do you expect your arm to grow back within the next two years.”

Gary, 30, of Chesterfield, Derbys, said: “I replied, ‘Well it’s not grown back in the last 30 years, so I can’t see it happening over the next two’.”

ATOS Healthcare, who assessed Gary for the Department for Work and Pensions, said last night: “That question would never be asked. Staff carrying out the assessment are trained doctors, nurses and physiotherapists.”

Gary said he was later sent on a job seekers’ gardening course — and handed a spade.

He said: “If it wasn’t so ridiculous it would be laughable.”

thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/n...

Written by
esagestapo profile image
esagestapo
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
Malwimmy27 profile image
Malwimmy27

Souds about right. It would be good if some of the atos bigwigs could see video recordings of these interviews then see just how ridiculous some of these interviewers really are! Becky x

Tannels profile image
Tannels

You could not make it up if you tried. Well it's clear that the interviewer's brain had stunted growth and had not reached it's full capacity. How to these people ever get employed.

Tannels x

ladymoth profile image
ladymoth

It worries me terribly that these people are in charge of stuff ... :O

Moffy x

mistymeana profile image
mistymeana

I'm beginning to wonder if these "trained doctors, nurses and physiotherapists" got their degrees from the university of Outer Mongolia via correspondence course. Either that or Atos has a secret training facility that foregoes standard medical training and just brainwashes drivel in its place! If you made a sitcom of this people would be outraged and think it too OTT.

mistymeana profile image
mistymeana

PS - no disrespect intended towards Outer Mongolia or it's citizens. Just the most remote place I could think of :D x

in reply to mistymeana

Timbuktu is pretty remote.

Cat53 profile image
Cat53

My husband who is an above knee amputee was told by his doctor that she had to fill out a form for five years running to say his condition was permanent! Nothing changes! I have to say that 17 years on his leg has not re grown yet! We are not holding our breath! Lol!

tessintrouble profile image
tessintrouble

Perhaps Gary should have helped himself to some "miracle gro" fertilizer at the gardening course - you never know ..............................

Honestly, you could not make this shit up, though Atos do. Just about says it all.

esagestapo profile image
esagestapo

“That question would never be asked. Staff carrying out the assessment are trained doctors, nurses and physiotherapists.”

Does anyone else find anything wrong with this quote from Atos? They are trained, by who and for what exactly!! Surely Atos would not employ medical staff that need training? I would expect them to be qualified to begin with!! Imagine going to hospital and being told, you can have an operation as soon as a DM trains the surgeon to do the op. Or go to your nearest JC and they will show you how to do the op yourself.

tessintrouble profile image
tessintrouble

According to their own guidelines - they try and match you and your illness with an assessor who knows about that particular thing. I am living proof they DO NOT!! My "nurse" did not know what rheumathoid arthritis is, she muddled it up with osteo arthritis. She acually put in wrting that my pain killer caused some hair loss and nausea. That " pain killer" was methotrexate - a toxic chemo-therapy drug that suppresses the immune system, you couldn't make it up...............

Slowrunner1 profile image
Slowrunner1

Completely against the view of this thread- I have one arm- I'm twice this guys age and have worked without any problem for my whole life. Having one arm is not a hardship and should not warrant any government payment- plus I can use a spade,shovel,etc etc

We have a choice when faced with problems. I got on with life

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

People have no idea! So angry

A woman I know, that I have known for about 8 years has totally blown me away, On Facebook people...

Got the dreaded ESA medical assessment back !!! 0 points

Finally had my dreaded ESA medical result's ... 0 points the one small bit I have had the courage...

Update! struggling at work

Hello everyone hope u are all feeling as good as can be with this horrid health condition. I wrote...

ATOS Undercover - Why am I not surprised . . .

that the Dispatches programme scheduled for Monday shows that ATOS assessors have been told to keep...

vindictive neigbours................ help

hi all, im in the surport group e.s.a. and have disability as well. I dreading November as both pf...