Question about hcl+betaine and histamine syndrome - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,936 members161,765 posts

Question about hcl+betaine and histamine syndrome

Justiina profile image
11 Replies

I know there are tonns of questions /answers about hcl on this forum, but I remember reading some ingredients can actually worsen leaky gut braking down villi. Cannot remember was it discussed here and what type of product was it.

There are so many different types of products on the market.

Is there lactose free hcl betaine someone can recommend? Saw solgar on sale but it had lactose. This

About histamine intolerance which I do think I have as it goes hand in hand with hashi. I have let myself understand histamine intolerance also causes low stomach acids and with hcl+betaine+B6 it is possible to help histamine intolerance too if not possible to get DAO as a pill.

Anyone with histamine intolerance who has got help from hcl+betaine?

I have never understood why I am so sensitive to bananas, getting hives or feeling incredibly weak and wobbly. Also really sensitive to coffee but possibly because it prevents producing DAO which brakes down histamine. The list of my sensitivies is long and goes for both hashi and histamine intolerance.

Written by
Justiina profile image
Justiina
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

I can't help with much of what you ask but I took Drs Best HCL +Pepsin + Gentian Bitters and there does not appear to be lactose included

drbvitamins.com/products/be...

Hello Justina,

Histamine plays an important role in our bodies inflammation when related to allergies and also as a neurotransmitter .. regulating sleep patterns and stomach acid.

It is broken down in the gut and liver but when in excess .. (.. due to allergies and over active immune responses..) .. your body is unable to break it down .. resulting in histamine intolerance.

Stomach acid is mainly hydrochloric acid, potassium and sodium, made via the parietal cells lining the stomach. It helps digest foods and especiallly proteins. .. and protects against gut dysbosis.

Both histamine intolerance and hypothyroidism will discourage adequate stomach acid levels and so supplementing Betaine will replace missing gastric acids allowing nutrient absorption and helping gut inflammation. I also supplement digestive enzymes and biliary support.

Do you have a DOA mutation or just low levels of DOA enemy activity .?..

Both encourage high histamine as DOA is responsible for breaking down histamine in the gut. Low DOA may also be caused by GI conditions such as Crohns, IBS and gluten intolerance, and NSAIDS ... in which case may be reversed if gut issues are managed.

Fermented foods should be avoided as histamine is a by-product of the fermentation. Heal your gut with a healthy diet ... and populate with probiotics after eradicating any bad bacteria, yeast infections and/or parasites.

Some recommend liver support too as if your gut is suffering, your liver will be overloaded as well.

Cytoplasm supply a lactose-free Betaine where a 20% discount is given to members of ThyroidUK.

I hope you feel better soon

Flower

Histamine & thyroid health

naturalendocrinesolutions.c...

Evidence showing Histamines control over immune system

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/128...

Stomach acid explained

stopthethyroidmadness.com/s...

Histamine & DOA

metabolichealing.com/histam...

Cytoplan details

cytoplan.co.uk/Betaine-Peps...

Various Betaine brands & additives

toxinless.com/betaine-hcl

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to

Thanks flower :) I am now on strong probiotic which I am finally tolerating and I take l-glutamine and enzymedica digest basic.

I avoid food causing me hives or other symptoms and try to be brave enough to take hcl. I am super scared about vitamins and supps and so on :D

But I feel that is the missing link to heal my gut.

Ppi's I had to take 10 years ago made things worse. Before that my intolerance was not this bad. After strong ppi's I went into so bas condition. I did not think it could ppi's making things worse until last year.

Thanks again!

in reply to Justiina

Justina .. You are right.

Over 2,500 years ago Hippocrates said: “All disease begins in the gut.”

Most of us on the forum have some form of gut issues as this is what hypothyroidism does. Fortunately a lot of the damage can be reversed if managed correctly.

Taking probiotics is excellent if you don't have yeast , bacterial or parasite infections . Otherwise these need dealing with first or you are just feeding the infection.

If you haven't read the link below it shows how everything ties together.

F

chriskresser.com/the-thyroi...

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to

According to stool test I did six months ago I don't have over growth of bacteria, more so I was low on e.coli, completely missing enterococcaeae which apparently is responsible making vitamin B , was hard to find info of that. I was also mildly low on lactobacillus.

No yeast detected. Other bacteria and stuff normal. Said it is mild dysbiosis but completely missing one strain and low on e.coli was enough to cause issues.

Was said low e.coli causes food intolerance , fatigue and so on.

About parasites I don't know. Years ago homeopath said I have ameba based on test she did. Supplements did not work but no parasites found from proper tests.

I am rather constipated and rarely have diarrhoea anymore after quitting gluten , corn and rice.

Last Jan my blood showed eosinophil % over ranges which can be caused by parasites but allergies as well. Doctor ruled out parasites based on symptoms and figured it was down to recent episode of hives as other values was completely normal.

After starting b12 many of my gut issues has resolved like constant irritation and burning feeling in bowel area. So I have figured it is low good bacteria and low stomach acids. Might be wrong but as I not so bloated anymore, less nausea, less irritation because of b12 I think I am heading to right direction. Also the tiny amount of iodine I know tolerate makes a big difference.

in reply to Justiina

Justin,

You are lucky if you have no gut infections or yeast. ..

I have been battling for a while and do now see improvements but the regime is very strict... and I have swayed just a tad now & then.. lol.

A usual stool test may not detect parasites.

If this is an avenue you would like to explore I would recommend the Genova Diagnostics Comprehensive Digestive Stool Analysis 2.0.

Otherwise just keep populating with the good bacteria.

When gut is healthy you should see a reduction in histamine levels & feel better.

Flower

Justiina profile image
Justiina in reply to

Yeah I have been thinking about Genova Diagnostics Comprehensive Digestive Stool Analysis 2.0. but symptom wise it is not recommended.

But never say never. If hcl+ betaine does not give me the last boost I will probably take that test as well.

I have heard parasites are difficult to treat and it is a long road :( know one girl who has been ridiculously ill without any proper help, eating anything feeling like eating sharp glass ending up only eating cooked potato for weeks.

She then found help from product called Tre örter, which apparently is swedish product made of certain herbs. With that she has been able to heal enough to eat better.

I cannot say which symptoms are gut related and which are due to low t3. I am not yet on medication, but self medicating is the next step if doctors wont help. I cannot separate is weakness etc down to low t3 or what as this has been this way for so long. But wanted to be properly supplemented and help my gut first and then start to self medicate to have it all covered.

I hope you are able to fix your gut :)

in reply to Justiina

keep in mind you cant populate your gut with probiotics. Probiotics are good for temporarly increasing the count. But the biggest impact is with prebiotics. if you have SIBO, you need to wait with FOS and lactulose is not advised. One of the most tolarated is partially hydrolized guar gum. Also its good you take L-glutamine but the lining is produced by Akkermansia and you should really feed them. You can do that with pomegranate, cranberries and resistant starch. Please watch Dr Hawrelak videos. It will show you how people use probiotics the wrong way.

in reply to

Can you please explain why you think histamine release encourages low stomach acid?Thank you. I healed histamine intolerance, healing leaky gut and endometriosis right now. Overall very low levels of inflamation after 1 year of treatment and 8 years of being sick. I presume my fertility will go up also...

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to

When you see a user name of Hidden, it means that the person is no longer a member of this forum.

.

If you wish to call your post to the attention of another member, you can follow this Help topic:

support.healthunlocked.com/...

Hi Justiina,

What an interesting post. I finally got to this connection. I personally got histamine intolerance after IBS when the doctor gave antibiotics. 1.5 years later while i took anti inflamatory things and killed pathogens like C diff and klebsiella (I used Ubiome), I dont have histamine intolerance anymore. I can give more details anymore. I still have sibo even though i tried a lot of protocols. Last summer I was operated and they found endometriosis which I was sure I had even if it was silent. Now they now endometriosis is cause my pathogens in cervix. I did a microbiome of cervix and there also found pathogens and dysibios. I did some treatment for endo plus some vaginal implant (only working with an microbiologyst). It looks like the colon needs to have high diversity but cervix needs to have low diversity plus there are 4 models of vaginal microbiome. My cancer markers went down and my Sensitive C Reactive protein went from 1.5 to 0.2. Yes, my parents also died in the end and that I was left with a period of no probelms to solve. But yeah, now I want to know why my sibo is not going away. I thought i had scar tissues from endo and operation but now i think its the acid. I am trying to listen to nirala jacobi. I found out about the acidity gradient from plant paradox diet. Anyway, there is hope. Even though i have the mthft mutation, no histamine issue. Also, i started exercising, goal was 5 times a week cardio at 130bpm.

You may also like...

Baby aspirin and betaine hcl

and I have decided to give betaine hcl and pepsin a try but I have heard it’s not recomemended to...

Betaine HCL with Pepsin and breastfeeding

isn't too well. I thought about getting a good Betaine HCL + Pepsin supplement, but I'm...

Betaine HCL - How Long For?

the morning. If you do have low hcl, how long do you stay on hcl supplements for? Is it a long...

Does HCL Betaine help Hashimotos- success stories please

Hi, I am wondering whether to try HCL betaine; I am not on levothyroxine and am working on boosting

If Betaine HCL is derived from Beets...