Poor converters: Can anyone give me some stats on... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,936 members161,765 posts

Poor converters

judycopage profile image
6 Replies

Can anyone give me some stats on the percentage of patients in the UK needing combined therapy T4/T3? That is, percentage of poor converters? Percentage of faulty genes Di01 and DI02?

Am writing a follow-up article to the one published for Central Bylines

centralbylines.co.uk/big-ph...

Thanks!

Written by
judycopage profile image
judycopage
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
6 Replies
jimh111 profile image
jimh111

It's a difficult question because the percentage needing T3 is much more than it might appear. The study into DIO2 polymorphisms showed about 16% (with the polymorphism from both parents) demonstrated a need for T3. However, there are many other groups of patients who have a greater need for T3. Those with a subnormal TSH will not convert nearly as welll as they should. Also, any form of resistance to thyroid hormone will need high dose T3. These latter two forms are never recognised and so don't get counted.

I would also argue that levothyroxine monotherapy leads to unacceptable cancer risks and so all patients should receive some T3 so that their fT4 can be brought down to safer levels.

HotelHurricaine profile image
HotelHurricaine in reply to jimh111

what's a safe ft4 level? I've never heard of cancer risk of levo monotherapy.

jimh111 profile image
jimh111 in reply to HotelHurricaine

I posted about it here healthunlocked.com/thyroidu... . It's not so much a safe cut off level but there tends to be higher overall risk as T4 levels increase. This does not apply to all cancers but the overall risk. You win some and lose some but the evidence suggests that higher fT4 is associated with higher risk of a cancer being more aggressive.

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame

I doubt you'd find a realistic figure because many people self medicate and are therefore " under the radar".

Many may be undiagnosed as poor convertors... so no stats there.

Some medics are reluctant to agree about poor conversion....again, no stats

I have the Dio2 variant/ homozygous and after self medicated T4/ T3 therapy I'm now high dose T3-only because I have a form of thyroid hormone resistance....there will be no official stats of this....

I'm not alone in the above.

Little about thyroid disease is clearly defined because it involves multiple variables and unravelling them may be like trying to untangle a a roll of barbed wire!

judycopage profile image
judycopage

Many thanks for these replies - I suspected as much! Extensive searching shows that even in medical journals no stats are found.

Muffy profile image
Muffy

No, sorry, but you may find this article in Pulse Magazine 15th Sept. 2017 very interesting. ‘A Ban on Liothyronine will be Devastating - I Should Know by Dr Renée Hoenderkamp

You may also like...

Am I a poor converter?

ability to convert FT4 to FT3? Assuming the answer is yes, what are the next steps? I assume my...

Medicheck results - am I a poor converter?

be correct to say that I'm a poor converter when I speak to him? Thank you in anticipation of all...

Poor converter hoping for better

Hi above is my latest Medichecks full thyroid test - taken 9th July 9am fasting (so no meds + no...

Calling all the poor converters here! :)

Hi everyone! I am a poor converter with high RT3. I have been on 150mg of Levo for 10 years and...

How to work out if you are a poor converter from T4 to T3

rule of thumb I need to apply to see if I was not converting from T4 to T3 proper or poorly. My GP...