Can you refuse NHS TSH test: Hi As part of the... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,936 members161,765 posts

Can you refuse NHS TSH test

Sparklingsunshine profile image

Hi

As part of the ongoing investigations into my balance issue my GP has ordered a raft of blood tests, B12, ferritin, estimated GFR, folate, liver function, bone profile, electrolytes, which I have no issue with, however he's stuck TSH in as well, I've managed to dodge GP scrutiny for 7 months but it's finally caught up.

I privately tested TFT in December, my TSH was 0.03, this was on 125mcg of Levo. I upped it to 150mcg in February as my FT4 and FT3 were well in range. And I tried to test privately in April but the test failed. Not enough blood, I found 150mcg a bit too much so following Tattyboogle's advice I'm on 137.5mcg and feel better so far but of course I can't retest myself until June.

My question is I don't think my dizziness is thyroid related, they are only testing TSH and it's highly doubtful my actual thyroid hormones will be tested. If my TSH is still very low they'll try and reduce Levo and assume my dizziness is that.

I know they shouldn't dose on TSH alone. So can I get out of this test and if so how? I did think about lying and saying I'm taking biotin, and therefore the test will be invalid.

Written by
Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

Sparklingsunshine

I did think about lying and saying I'm taking biotin, and therefore the test will be invalid.

The problem with that is taking a biotin supplement can affect any blood test if biotin is used in the testing procedure, so it can't be used as an excuse to refuse TSH alone because some or all of the other tests could be affected too.

I have refused thyroid function tests at times. I have to have other tests regularly for other reasons so I always ask the nurse what tests are being done. If she says thyroid and I don't want it I just say "Not thyroid this time, I've taken my Levo this morning as I didn't know thyroid was being included and I've been told to not take it before the test, always take it after the test". But I know my test wont be TSH alone, it includes FT4 and often FT3 as well so that might not work for you if it's just TSH they're testing.

You can try just refusing the TSH test, they have to have your informed consent to any medical procedure so if you refuse and they do it then they have breached medical ethics and your human rights.

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle

Assuming you do want the rest of the bloods done ?...then don't try to get out of the TSH or start talking about biotin , . they will probably still send it off anyway ... and you will just raise a lot of suspicion about what you might be up to with your thyroid hormone dose .

take the TSH test , but just tell them you are taking the 150mcg they prescribed in October... (which was evidently too big an increase from 100mcg )and if when they get the results a reduction is suggested.... only agree to a slight 'reduction' on your prescription to 137.5mcg (which is what you are taking anyway ).. or perhaps you should consider agreeing to try 125mcg (again) ... who knows , it might be that you ARE now a bit overmedicated even on 137.5mcg ? .

But don't let them put it back down to 100mcg , because your TSH went too high on that dose .

The fact that lowering from 150 to 137.5mcg has already made you feel a bit better is a pretty clear indication that overmedication might be the problem , and you would be wise not to rule this explanation out completely .

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to tattybogle

Hi

Thank you both, I've got a neck X Ray booked for next week, I'm going to have that and hopefully get the results and see if it's a neck issue. If so then that makes the blood tests redundant anyway. I'm not going to start on the propranolol either. What I've read isn't exactly encouraging.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to tattybogle

Hi

I'm not ruling out overmedication as nothing is off the plate but if they just test TSH it won't tell me if that was the issue. Its a shame they aren't doing FT4 and 3. I might be more up for it if they were.

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle in reply to Sparklingsunshine

the thing with the NHS is you can never really be 100% sure they won't do an ft4, (or even very occasionally an fT3.. i've had 5 over the years without asking , and for no particularly obvious reason). Depending on whether the lab uses a 'reflex' protocol . eg for 'TSH with Reflex' , then if TSH is under range, the fT4 may then be done on same sample even if it wasn't initially asked for by GP.

Lulu2607 profile image
Lulu2607 in reply to Sparklingsunshine

Hi. My tests for TFT have always had T4 included even when I was in range before becoming hypo. Maybe it depends on the labs where you live. Never T3 though unfortunately.

pennyannie profile image
pennyannie

I don't even get invited to get one nowadays .

When i switched to self medicating with NDT I wrote to my surgery to advise them.

I said i would make myself available for the yearly thyroid blood test providing a T3 and T4 were run .

I never heard back and Levothyroxine dropped off my prescription about a year later.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to pennyannie

Hi

Being on Levo only I'm obliged to play ball unfortunately 😂 otherwise they can get hissy and refuse my meds. But unless they test my thyroid hormones I'm not going to accept a dose reduction.

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to Sparklingsunshine

If you have been diagnosed as hypo then replacement hormone medication is for life!Hissy or not, for medics to withdraw your medication would be to put your health at risk.

Do your medics want to be responsible for that!!

Different if one makes a choice to self medicate, as I do, but you are under their care.

It sounds as if they are investigating/testing fairly widely regarding your symptoms.

I wouldn't complicate things by introducing biotin as a reason not to test...I'd have the tests as arranged then deal with the results.

You may very well still be overmedicated ...wait for results.

These articles might help you state a case against reliance on TSH labs!

thyroidpatients.ca/2021/07/...

bmcendocrdisord.biomedcentr...

"Time for a reassessment of the treatment of hypothyroidism"

Authors - John E. M. Midgley, Anthony D. Toft, Rolf Larisch, Johannes W. Dietrich & Rudolf Hoermann

So long as FT3 in within range then there is little chance that you are overmedicated.

But...you have already raised your dose to 150mcg then down again to 137.5mcg.

Test 6/8 weeks after starting 137.5mcg.

Ensure you are well hydrated before ( private) test.

You may need to explain this ....and "play ball".

You have 2 issues going on here....theirs and yours and now they clash.

They need to treat by both symptoms and numbers...and on 137.5mcg you feel better!

That proves something!

Might 125mcg be even better?

Have you optimised vit D, vit B12, folate and ferritin...all essential for thyroid support

Nutrient deficiency may be causing dizziness

I agree with tattybogle....don't drop to 100mcg without supporting FT4 and FT3 labs.

Lulu2607 profile image
Lulu2607 in reply to DippyDame

Re T3. I can't understand why, if you're TSH and T4 suggest overmedicated they don't then test T3 to get the full picture?

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to Lulu2607

Good question!In my surgery they stopped routinely testing FT3 in 2000

The powers that be decided TSH was the gold standard thyroid test

In reality it's a lazy shortcut(my opinion) and another cost cutting exercise

And, they don't seem to understand the function and immense significance of T3

If TSH is suppressed then the lab may then test FT3

I'm on high dose T3-only and have suppressed TSH and FT4... because I have RTH.

At an annual med review, that result prompted the lab used by my surgery to test FT3.

As expected it was over range.

My medics now understand why this happens!

But, I agree it should be a routine test

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle in reply to DippyDame

i'm probably missing something here , so apologies in advance ... but if resistance to thyroid hormones is the issue for you , why is hypothalamus / pituitary not also resistant too ?

ie. why was TSH also low ?

if T3 and /or T4 isn't working on a cellular level , why did hypothalamus respond as though it is ?

..... or do you mean a different sort of 'RTH', to the genetic kinds i'm thinking of ?

Shall i shut up now ? ( i realise it's probably the very thing you've had to argue about with doctors for years ... but i still don't really get it .... )

or is your RTH in the "i can't explain it scientifically , but i got myself better anyway " box.

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to tattybogle

That's a huge question tatty!

Where to start!

I've no idea if my RTH falls into the "genetic kind" because I have never had TRa and TRb tests for genetic defects.

Some years ago I found a link to these tests,( somewhere abroad to be precise!!) .....now lost the link and should really try to find it again.

However my labs don't/didn't fit the typical genetic RTH results so the rather useless endo I saw refused to consider RTH.

.There are various theories which distinguish between RTH and Pituitary Resistance...and more generalised RTH, for example Aquired Resistance to Thyroid Hormone (ARTH)

I do know that I have a very rare inherited genetic deletion - passed on to one son and one grandson - which the geneticist at the time did not think was related to RTH.

He did say that there may be an as yet unknown genetic variants that may be responsible

Basically..."we just don't know"!!

I've recently sent off a DNA sample to Ancestry, for genealogy purposes, but I doubt that will reveal RTH!!

I was convinced that my problem lay in this area so I just kept digging until I discovered that I need a supraphysiological dose of T3-only to function.

Self medication was my only hope...

I learned that the only reason I could tolerate a dose that may kill other people was the existence of some form of RTH.

I have had to talk my way round this in order to convince medics that I wasn't killing myself and I'm now guilty of ranting about those reasons here because I think there may be forms of RTH that are more common than medics realise.

It would help if they listened to the scientists instead of sticking their heads in the sand

My bio explains my journey....

I'm no expert, much of this is above my head.

Basically I'm just a bloody minded old woman who was driven by desperation to find out why over many years I slowly became barely able to function.

A lot of damage has been done over (possibly a lifetime) by the Cellular Hypothyroidism this RTH has caused ( that, to the best of my understanding) but high dose T3 has resolved or improved most of my symptoms.

Had I discovered this years ago recovery may have been even better.

I don't suppose this helps answer your initial question but it agrees with the last one!

Ranting again!

There are a lot of other people who don't "get it"....join the club! But thankfully it works for me... and that's good enough for me...

Sadly, a vast fortune and a TUK Foundation can only be a dream!!

tattybogle ...do you suspect that you may have a form of RTH?

tattybogle profile image
tattybogle in reply to DippyDame

No , i just have bog standard "my immune system ate my thyroid disease"..

.... it worked just fine before that happened.

I was just trying to get my head round how your thyroid cogs work (or rather .... don't work) after reading some stuff about the congenital forms of RTH on that complicated thing diogenes posted the other day.... have forgotten which paper it was now ..... think it was that one about "other potential markers for measuring tissue hypothyroidism " It's just that RTH is not something i've ever tried very hard to understand before .. so was curious.

But am quite happy to accept the "stubborn old bint finds own cure" explanation :) you can't argue with a bit of 'real world' evidence .

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to tattybogle

So, this morning I find that I may have attained the rank of, "stubborn old bint"...

who " finds own cure".

I'm curious too!

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to tattybogle

jimh111 may have more to say about your questions tattybogle His knowledge is greater than mine.

You may also like...

NHS labs refusing thyroid antibodies test ordered by doctor

sent off for more blood tests for glandular fever and thyroid antibodies. The GF test came back...

Can you be given TSH as medication?

had private blood tests done, the results just came back, all 'within the normal range' except TSH...

how accurate is a tsh blood test? can you have normal results but still have thyroid problem?

if you can have a normal tsh blood test .but still have a overactive thyroid? i am 31 yrs old...

TSH: Medichecks and NHS blood tests don't match

I had my TSH blood test with the NHS on Oct. 20. It was 0.98 miu/L range (0.35 - 4.78). 3 weeks...

NHS TSH test 1 week apart from Medichecks test

they refused to accept the private test results and requested an NHS one (TSH only). I did this...