Vitamin K2 - can soy affect thyroid meds? - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,948 members166,084 posts

Vitamin K2 - can soy affect thyroid meds?

clarabelle17 profile image
14 Replies

I have a questions about Vitamin K (Mk-7 which is from soy). I have heard that those on thyroxine are supposed to avoid soy, as it affects the function of Levo - is that true - does anyone know or have experience of this?

I want to take Vitamin D3 (I have osteoporosis), and have researched that it is best taken together with Vitamin K2. I have also read K2 can be MK-4 or MK-7, and that it's the soy (from Natto) that is in MK-7.

I am getting a bit confused as what best to take - any advice please?

Written by
clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
14 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

clarabelle17 Yes, you are right, we Hypos should avoid all forms of 'unfermented' soy. Natto is 'fermented' soy so it's fine to take K2-MK7 from Natto :)

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply toSeasideSusie

Ah - thanks SeasideSusie - I had missed that completely - that helps to know! :-)

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply toSeasideSusie

Is the soybean oil in the capsules ok to take?

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17

Are these ok for those on Thyroxine (together with D3), and how far away from thyroid meds do these need to be taken please? amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B00...

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply toclarabelle17

clarabelle17 That is the one I am hoping to take for two reasons. One is the fact that there are only the two ingredients so you avoid all the unwanted fillers etc. The other is because I have difficulty with capsules and find softgels easier to take. However, I want to avoid soybean oil.

The Jarrows website shows it contains olive oil jarrow.com/product/241/MK-7

I have contacted Jarrows and they replied

"Thank you for your e-mail query to Jarrow Formulas. We recently changed the inactive ingredients in MK7. Currently, this product contains a base of olive oil. Given that this change was quite recent, there will still be bottles of both formulas in the inventory of online distributors, until the older formula sells out ."

So it's a case of finding someone who has this latest formula. I contacted one supplier I use sometimes, BigVits, and they replied

"I have written to Jarrow concerning this as all the stocks we have are still containing SoyBean Oil although we received new stocks from them just a couple of weeks ago. Certainly, at the present time, we do not have any of the new stock with Olive Oil."

I am waiting for another of the suppliers I use to have their new stock but that looks like being a few weeks yet, and I will ask them to check the ingredients.

So at the moment I haven't been able to obtain that particular one.

I'm not saying that the soybean oil will be a problem, just that I don't want it.

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply toSeasideSusie

Thanks for that - will have to keep an eye out for the new ones! :-)

Marz profile image
Marz

Have you seen Dr Myhills supplement protocol for Osteoporosis ?

drmyhill.co.uk/wiki/Osteopo...

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply toMarz

Thanks for that :-)

K2 is made from nattokinase which is fermented soy. Fermented is OK as it negates the goitrogens. It's unfermented soy (as in soy milk, fake meat, fake cheese etc) that is the problem - unless you have a sensitivity to soy itself unrelated to thyroid. However, after going through a lab, I suspect there is no recognizable soy left in the product.

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply toAngel_of_the_North

Is the soybean oil in the capsules ok to take?

Hi, I buy mine from Healthspan online. It does not contain any Soy. It is the MK-7 type. It truly works because it as been slowly lowering the excess calcium in my blood. This is where the calcium goes if you don't use K2. x

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17 in reply to

I think the Healthspan tablets contain fermented chick pea powder (which could use Natto as a starter). Also they use Hypromellose (Hydroxypropyl Methylcellulose) as a filler, which isn't supposed to be that good...

in reply toclarabelle17

Hi thanks, I haven't had any adverse issues with taking the Healthspan ones. My blood calcium is lowering too. Are you going to use the ones from Amazon? How about the Soybean oil? x

clarabelle17 profile image
clarabelle17

Good point Mango_555 - maybe Seaside Susie or Angel will know - is soybean oil ok in capsules for those who take thyroid meds?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Vitamin K2

I have Hashimoto’s and would like to know if I can take any type of K2, or does it have to be soy...

K2 from soy (natto) - OK or not?

Just this really. Have realised my current supplement contains K2 from soy and I know that soy is...
MiniMum97 profile image

Vitamin D and Vitamin K2

Hi How much Vitamin K2 should we take with Vitamin D ? Do you take the same dose of Vit K2 no...
lucylocks profile image

Vitamin K2 deficiency symptoms!

I have been taking K2 for a while, thanks to Greygoose for suggesting it :) I don't remember to...
Justiina profile image

Is Natto (fermented soy) harmful to the thyroid?

Natto is whole fermented soy beans. It is an exceptional source of Vitamin K2. It is a traditional...
rjb112 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.