GCA & COVID-19 Can Mimic Each Other: Sorry, after... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,340 members38,113 posts

GCA & COVID-19 Can Mimic Each Other

30 Replies

Sorry, after saying I wasn't interested in posting about Covid19, this article (which appears to be written by Dr Sarah L Mackie) popped up! It is directed at doctors and talks about diagnosing and distinguishing GCA from Covid19. Interestingly (and surprisingly to me) the article says, "Don’t worry about GCA in the under-50s..." and "A normal CRP makes GCA much less likely..." I was surprised to see two such sweeping, statements... just my opinion.

****************************************************************************************

(Cut and pasted from pulsetoday.co.uk )

Signs, symptoms, blood tests

Temporal arteritis (giant cell arteritis, or GCA) is an autoimmune disease of older people that causes headache, scalp tenderness, jaw claudication (jaw pain with chewing), fever, sweats or weight loss. There may be aches and pains in the neck and arms, and sometimes the legs. Occasionally patients may have a cough. On examination, a swollen, tender or nodular temporal artery may be felt on one or both sides of the head, and the pulse may be more difficult to feel in that artery. CRP and ESR are usually elevated. Transient monocular visual loss or double vision are worrying features, suggesting involvement of the blood supply to the eye. Treatment is with high-dose steroids.

A difficult diagnosis

GCA is a difficult diagnosis to make as the symptoms can appear one by one; urgent specialist assessment is advised, even in a covid-19 outbreak, since GCA is recognised as a medical emergency. This may be even more important in the current outbreak since patients might present late, with impending or actual visual loss. COVID-19 can also cause headache, so beware: COVID-19 and GCA can mimic each other. Don’t worry about GCA in the under-50s; and GCA is fairly rare in the under-55s. Do worry about GCA if there is jaw claudication (present in about 50% of GCA patients) or visual loss.

Referring to a specialist

Most hospitals will have some provision for specialist assessment, either face-to-face or by telemedicine. It is usually better to refer by phone: the patient may be offered an appointment within 24 hours and should always be seen within 3 working days. Patients with visual loss or double vision should be referred to ophthalmology (eye casualty) whereas those without visual manifestations should usually be referred to rheumatology, but check local arrangements.

Initial tests and treatment

If you think GCA is more likely than any other diagnosis (including COVID-19), you should immediately start prednisolone 40-60mg daily, pending specialist confirmation of diagnosis. Try and ensure blood is sent to the lab before starting steroids, if possible. The practicalities of getting urgent blood tests are difficult during the COVID-19 pandemic, and you may need to discuss with a specialist to help weigh up the risks of attending hospital for a blood test - especially out of hours - versus the risks of waiting for an urgent specialist review. Being on long-term, high-dose steroids has serious implications for patients in a global pandemic. A normal CRP makes GCA much less likely, and is very helpful in making the decision not to commit the patient for a year or more of oral steroids. Lymphopenia is rare in GCA and might instead point towards COVID-19. Lastly, GCA symptoms usually respond rapidly to steroids. If symptoms don’t respond within a week, then reconsider the diagnosis; by this time, they should have been reviewed by a specialist either by phone or face to face.

Biopsy and ultrasound tests

The diagnosis of GCA is usually confirmed by temporal artery biopsy; in some centres temporal artery ultrasound may be done as well as, or instead of, a biopsy. In the current outbreak, temporal artery biopsy may be unavailable; whether ultrasound is also available will depend on local arrangements. Ultrasound is best done within a few days of starting steroids.

Monitoring patients on high-dose steroids

Older patients taking high-dose steroids need to know they are extremely vulnerable to coronavirus, and should follow the government advice for the highest-risk individuals. High-dose steroids can cause depression, aggression or frank psychosis so a telephone follow-up to check on their mood is useful if they are socially isolated. Medical complications include diabetes and hypertension – if they have a home blood pressure monitor, encourage them to use it. Add a bisphosphonate, calcium and vitamin D to reduce fracture risk.

Tapering and relapse management

If the diagnosis of GCA is confirmed, after 4-6 weeks the steroid dose is tapered gradually over a year or more (see link below for dosing). During this time, make sure the patient knows who to contact if they have a relapse of GCA symptoms. Make sure they know to report jaw claudication urgently, even if they didn’t have this symptom at presentation, as this can be a precursor of visual loss. See the link below for steroid dosing at relapse, but if in doubt, seek specialist advice.

Further information for doctors and patients

The British Society for Rheumatology recently updated its clinical practice guidelines for GCA diagnosis and management[1]. The executive summary is free to read here. and includes checklists of symptoms, laboratory tests, how to taper steroids and how to manage relapses. For patients, there are patient-run support groups: PMRGCAuk and PMR GCA Scotland.

Dr Sarah L Mackie is associate clinical professor and honorary consultant rheumatologist at the University of Leeds and Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust

Read more about...
30 Replies

Unable to read without registering. I can't comments on the unders 50s issue without seeing/reading it. But if it says "less likely" to be GCA re 'normal' crp thats is different from "unlikely" to be GCA. As I say I can't read without registering and I limit my registration to these sites.

Yellowbluebell profile image
Yellowbluebell in reply to

Its saying you can not register unless you are a health care professional who would prescribe meds. So no gca patients can officially get access.

in reply to Yellowbluebell

I checked the link, as I always do before reading the full question, and saw the title so just came back to read the potential issues raised. I went back and it was then I realised it was by registration by health care professionals.

in reply to

Apologies.

in reply to Yellowbluebell

Apologies. I have access as my son-in-law is registered, I did not realise that when I clicked in.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Yellowbluebell

I got onto it originally but not now. How strange.

Maisie1958 profile image
Maisie1958 in reply to PMRpro

Same here

in reply to PMRpro

It allows you one look for "free" I think but then no more. There are a few of these kinds of sites. I mean free in broad way as in not getting hooked in by sponsors. I was scrolling through lots of them when I did my usual checks on links.

in reply to

(See full article now pasted above.) It says, "A normal CRP makes GCA much less likely, and is very helpful in making the decision not to commit the patient for a year or more of oral steroids."

...but I, and it seems many other people have commented that their CRP was never above normal. I felt the comment was a bit "black and white," especially if that is one of the measures being used to prescribe oral steroids, or not.

My ESR & CRP were both within "normal" levels, when I was first diagnosed and prescribed 80mg.

Yellowbluebell profile image
Yellowbluebell in reply to

Thanks for putting the relevant bits on here. YBB

in reply to Yellowbluebell

That was the WHOLE article.... 🤷🏻‍♀️

Yellowbluebell profile image
Yellowbluebell in reply to

Sorry meant to say whole but the brain is refusing to play ball today. Think it's on strike for the hols!!

in reply to

This is why I like to go to the proper reference rather than an interpretation of an interpretation.

"The evidence search was restricted to adult humans with GCA or suspected GCA, not limited by ethnicity, age or sex; however, since GCA is extremely rare in patients <50 years of age [1], generalizability below this age limit cannot be assured."

"From a treatment perspective, this guideline is intended to provide a framework by which specialists, general practitioners and patients can work together to deliver optimal care tailored to the individual patient."

I think less likely is not the same as unlikely as you quoted. It is disappointing, but sometimes when you are asked to do an overview in X amount of words, some thing's get lost in the limited word count. Terrible things to lose or mash up but I would always go to the guidelines. Hopefully health professionals are just that...professionals. of course I know many aren't. but despite the potential for under 50s and normal range CRP to be "discounted", this is not really a recommendation if the aim of the guidelines is to create a framework for optimal care tailored to individual patients.

Reading guidelines etc on a smartphone isn't ideal. But having used "find in page" for CRP and ESR I can't see reference to the statement made in the copy from pulse. In fact the recommendation is to start pred if

"GCA is strongly suspected, the first dose of glucocorticoid can be given without waiting for laboratory results."

Whether those patients are younger than 50 or have normal range CRP/ESR. Yes, could do better but it is also worth checking out the list of sponsors which was my first port of call and the main reason i used up my first look. As I say one would still hope drs, including rheumies would at least prescribe pred to an under 50yr old if presenting with symptoms including, but not limited to visual symptoms.

academic.oup.com/rheumatolo...

in reply to

I just thought it was an interesting read... to be taken with a grain of salt.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer

"If the diagnosis of GCA is confirmed, after 4-6 weeks the steroid dose is tapered gradually over a year or more (see link below for dosing)." ....

another disappointing comment - no wonder some doctors are in such a rush to get patients off Pred. Would have expected better from author.

in reply to DorsetLady

Yes, I was surprised by the broad brush comments.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to

Considering the esteem people hold her in bit surprised.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

I quote the author:

" The whole point of the article was to try and get GPs not to miss GCA but not to try and diagnose it without specialist support either.

GCA is rare in the under-55s, and COVID-19 fearsomely common right now. But I take your point. Maybe the “don’t worry” sounded a bit dismissive - I didn’t mean that - it was in response to a GP reviewer who wanted to know “when should we worry about...”.

Patients <55 with possible GCA definitely need to access specialist care just like anyone else."

And she has contacted Pulse asking them to add a note that the age bit isn't cast in stone.

I'm far from sure she has helped our cause with GPs!! Judging by some of the struggles people have had even without Covid 19 to mess things up at least ...

in reply to PMRpro

Super cool! Thanks

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to

PS forgot to say I edited the post so I could use the link - it needed a space before the close bracket

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to

And further:

"the issue is that GPs see headache with elevated CRP and think that must be GCA - but it could be early covid.

But also these days anyone with cough is thought to have covid and it is sometimes a feature of GCA. So message to GP -don’t miss GCA."

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

That’s my Rheumatologist. I am in the position of having GCA found in my left armpit during an Utrasound Scan in February. At that time my temporal arteries were clear of it. She is awaiting the Pandemic to clear before further testing and treatment. I do feel cast adrift and not at all confident about self diagnosis and finding emergency medical assistance. I have her number to ring but am Shielded in Sheffield. I am sleeping a lot and feeling generally unwell. I was very interested to read this article. Thanks for posting. For sure every headache is sinister and I can imagine that the two conditions could be confused.

Jane185 profile image
Jane185 in reply to SheffieldJane

Hi SheffieldJane, This seems a very unusual place to find GCA - may I ask what the symptoms are?

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane in reply to Jane185

I didn’t notice anything but we can get GCA in any Artery. I was lucky they scanned my armpit. Now of course it aches but I am very suggestible. I think the clue was that I couldn’t get off Pred for PMR and was still symptomatic after 4 years. I was scanned for headaches but my Temporal Arteries are clear. I also showed differing blood pressure readings, in each arm, at one point, but my Aorta seemed to be functioning normally.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

In case anyone missed this:

I quote the author:

" The whole point of the article was to try and get GPs not to miss GCA but not to try and diagnose it without specialist support either.

GCA is rare in the under-55s, and COVID-19 fearsomely common right now. But I take your point. Maybe the “don’t worry” sounded a bit dismissive - I didn’t mean that - it was in response to a GP reviewer who wanted to know “when should we worry about...”.

Patients <55 with possible GCA definitely need to access specialist care just like anyone else."

And she has contacted Pulse asking them to add a note that the age bit isn't cast in stone."

further:

"... the issue is that GPs see headache with elevated CRP and think that must be GCA - but it could be early covid.

But also these days anyone with cough is thought to have covid and it is sometimes a feature of GCA. So message to GP - don’t miss GCA."

fmkkm profile image
fmkkm

Thanks for pointing this out. The other concern is diagnosed GCA patients who experience a flare. Recently I had a bout of diarrhea (can happen in covid) which was followed by a GCA mini flare for a couple days. Sinus pain, chills and fatigue which are normal for me but following the intestinal problem I was a bit worried.

Never had a fever but am still doing a week strict quarantine.

Rimmy profile image
Rimmy

Thanks for posting this - all quite interesting if somewhat 'worrying' regarding the perennial 'complexities' of diagnosing GCA - now also in relation to COVID -19 which is just what we 'don't need '!!

I can understand Dr Mackie trying to 'warn' other doctors about differentiating certain 'symptoms' - BUT this was all a little confusing I think even knowing a bit about this stuff now. The CRP thing (for example) is really quite bothersome - having seen mine go up and down in ways which are indicative only within my own 'normal' bodily context. This kind of subjective 'relativity' - is something I have seen many others here also refer to over the past 3 or more years.

Also the statement about high steroid dose making 'us' "extremely vulnerable to coronavirus" - does that mean more susceptible to 'infection' - or should that be read as our potential for 'recovery' if we are infected (aka 'survival') ? - not very clear I think .

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Rimmy

I think the steroid dose is relating to immunity in general, because that relates to how easily you would fall prey to it in the first place - and let's face it, that seems easy enough - but then since there is no option other than medical support long enough for the patient's own immune system to overcome the virus. And if they have little or no immune system - that won't happen however long you keep them on life support. Even in otherwise healthy patients requiring ventilation the longer it is required the harder it is to wean them off and in Covid 19 respiratory syndrome it is commonly 2 to 3 weeks which is an awful long time medically speaking.

Uisce58 profile image
Uisce58

Thank you for posting this article-most interesting.

How would you know if you had jaw claudication?

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Uisce58

It causes jaw pain when chewing, especially harder food, which then goes away when you stop the action. only to start again when you resume.

One check suggested by a medical study is to chew gum at one chew per second for 2 minutes. Developing jaw pain is suggestive of a risk of GCA.

You may also like...

Can you 'demand' Tocilizumab for GCA?

got a GCA diagnosis in early April after a temporal biopsy (steroids raised to 60mg before biopsy)....

GCA - PMR doing great after 2 months

this year. I had no visual symptoms or jaw claudication. My sed rate was normal and CRP was...

GCA diagnostic dilemma

4mgs). ‘Visual loss or stroke may occur in GCA, attributed to vascular occlusion; most...

Vascular ultrasound highly sensitive, specific for large-vessel GCA diagnosis

promising!!!! Maybe Vascular ultrasound will surpass the Temporal Artery Biopsy (TAB) as the...

Are GCA symptoms the same each time it returns?

recognise the symptoms. My main GCA symptoms were weight loss, night sweats, sore scalp, sore jaw...