Confused - Everything is going in the right di... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

132,694 members158,725 posts

Confused - Everything is going in the right direction, except the scales!! 😕

53 Replies

I am a little bit in awe of how C25K works its magic.⭐️

In just little under a month since I first started, I have reached the middle of Wk4, with the lovely Laura telling me I am now officially running more than I am walking. 😄Fantastic. I am proud of myself for staying on track (even on my "meh" days), I feel better physically and can't believe the difference it has made to my mood. That is all good!! There is however, one little thing that I have noticed which confuses me....

...my bathroom scales are going in the wrong direction 😐 🤔.

I am sensible about what I eat, but I now weigh more than when I started. Although weight loss is not my prime goal for doing C25K, I'll admit to hoping to lose a little as I went along.

I am curious if this has happened to others, why this happens, and if my scales will hopefully start heading in the other direction at some point?

And no, I am not secretly scoffing my children's Easter eggs!! 🐣

53 Replies
Buddy34 profile image
Buddy34Graduate

What I did notice was the numbers on the scales not going down as much as I wanted but my body shape has totally changed for the better . You may notice more once you are doing the longer runs hope this helps 😊

in reply to Buddy34

That's encouraging, thank you! I will hold out for those longer runs and see what happens.

Couchpotato2 profile image
Couchpotato2Graduate in reply to

Yes same with me. I weighed myself today for the first time since before C25k and I’ve lost 3kg but I feel way better and I’m sure my body is shaping up

RunRunRun13 profile image
RunRunRun13Graduate

Remember muscle weighs more than fat and your not consistently running long periods to see weight fall off but the fat will start turning into muscle. Once you start running longer you may see a difference but I never weigh myself - just go with how my clothes feel. You will see your body shape start to change too along the way, don’t think I have lost a lot but can see definition and more toned.

I have banned the scales in this house 😂

in reply to RunRunRun13

Returning the scales to the back of the airing cupboard as soon as I finish this reply!!

Thank you 🤪

primaballerina profile image
primaballerina in reply to

Good idea... I too have found no downward weight change, but fitting into size 12 trousers now!

CrazyDogLady19 profile image
CrazyDogLady19Graduate

2 weeks ago I received about 4 compliments in the same week re weight loss I had skipped the scales whilst on the program because it always has a negative effect on my mood..imagine my shock when I stepped on the scales and weighed more by a lb or so, a day of unproductive sulking followed. My body shape has changed my relationship with food is improving I feel like I can achieve for the first time in ages, the scales will now be used to weigh luggage only .... I’m sure my body will catch up, in fact I’m certain but for now I’m going to focus on improving...in all areas. Keep going sounds like your doing great 👍😊

in reply to CrazyDogLady19

Thank you!! I'm taking your advice, and that of RRR13. The scales are now confined to the back of the airing cupboard!!

I might do a sneaky weigh-in at the end of C25K, but I will be prepared for the gremlins just in case.... and I will concentrate on everything that is going well. Thank you 😊

CrazyDogLady19 profile image
CrazyDogLady19Graduate in reply to

Brilliant! 👏👏

Franglaise profile image
FranglaiseGraduate

Take a look at slimming world...you dont have to join a group, a lot of recipes are online. It is just about some healthy swaps eg the bechemel sauce in lasagne.

I dont eat bread often and only occasionally have alcohol

Sounds a bit dull, but truly it hasnt been hard...and more importantly is sustainable...so the stones wont come back. Totally worth it for the 2 and à half stones I have lost since Christmas...think the scales are still budging thanks to running. My husband hasnt even realised he has been eating healthier...until he got on the scales too...plus, you can still have treats.

Week 9.... Coming for my badge.

Im not a slimming World consultant...just a believer and someone it has worked for.

Plus I feel amazing...healthier than my twenties.

Thank you for the advice about the recipes, I will give it a go. I also have a husband who could benefit from it too!!

I have a big birthday coming up, so my aim is to do '5K by 50'. If I can lose a few pounds on the way it would be a boost.

primaballerina profile image
primaballerina in reply to

Me too... my (big) birthday is on Wednesday... I hopefully do my Graduation run tomorrow....!

in reply to primaballerina

Have a wonderful week celebrating both! 😊

Franglaise profile image
FranglaiseGraduate in reply to primaballerina

Thats so well timed...have à great week Birthday and graduation week.

Franglaise profile image
FranglaiseGraduate

You definately would with just a few changes...wouldnt feel like a diet either...all the best...warning though...it does be come very addictive...but like c25k!

Thank you and good luck for Wk9!!

SaskAlliecat profile image
SaskAlliecatGraduate

I find I get really hungry after running (there is even a term for it - being "rungry"). Early on, it seemed like my increased appetite was more than the calories I would burn so even if you are eating healthy, just be aware of how much you might be eating and what you're eating if weight loss is important to you.

in reply to SaskAlliecat

Oh I definitely think that's me! The "rungries", love it. I have eaten fruit, but I will watch it. Thank you 😊

E27M14 profile image
E27M14Graduate in reply to

I found in the early weeks I was really hungry after running so I deliberately planned my runs to be just before meal time. Mostly I come home from work, quick change and go straight back out. By the time I get back it’s time to prepare dinner. That way I’m not adding extra meals or snacks to my day.

I have lost almost 2 stone but most of that has been after graduating. I’m not following any particular diet, just making healthier choices and no late night snacking!

in reply to E27M14

From reading your post and others I am beginning to realise that weight loss seems to happen post graduation, when people consolidate runs and then step up to 10K. I have been really hungry since starting C25K and I have snacked, but carefully, however I've definitely snacked when I haven't been much of a snacker before!!

Shazzlar profile image
Shazzlar

I know exactly how you feel! I just can’t shift my extra weight. I look back on when I did a half marathon 3 years ago and I really want to get back to how I looked then. Being able to do 5k a couple of times a week should help over time though so I’ll keep at it. Just started to track calories with My Fitness Pal as well so am hoping that will help.

in reply to Shazzlar

Shazzlar - thank you. I hadn't thought of My Fitness Pal - That's a good idea. I admire you having a half-marathon under your belt! 😊

SeeJillRun profile image
SeeJillRunGraduate in reply to

Love My Fitness Pal, I’ve lost 5.3lbs in the month since I started using it. Link it up to Pacer n it gives you extra calories for your steps and tracked activities too. If I fancy a treat n it’s not within my calorie allowance I go for a walk or do some yoga to make up for it

in reply to SeeJillRun

Shazzlar & SeeJillRun - My Fitness Pal is now on my iPhone! Thank you both for recommending 😊 xx

SeeJillRun profile image
SeeJillRunGraduate in reply to

You’re welcome 😊 xx

Shazzlar profile image
Shazzlar in reply to

It was 3 years ago and I was 54. I’d always wanted to do a marathon but never got there. Believe me if I can do it -anyone can. When I’m struggling ( on week 5 now) I keep telling myself that I’ve done it before and can do it again. It helps to play inspiring music as well. I’m encouraged by the people who’ve replied and said they haven’t lost weight but shape has changed- I could live with that lol 😂

in reply to Shazzlar

Shazzlar & SeeJillRun - My Fitness Pal is now on my iPhone! Thank you both for recommending 😊 xx

Shazzlar profile image
Shazzlar in reply to

Good luck with it - slimming world is another good way of eating.

Beccym profile image
BeccymGraduate

Weight loss is a side effect for some but not all. The most important thing is that you're moving more and doing it.

As you run more your body shape will change even if you don't lose weight.

in reply to Beccym

Thank you. It would be nice to finally lose the remains of the 15 year old 'mummy tummy' by my big birthday, even if running just tones it up!!

Beccym profile image
BeccymGraduate in reply to

Be warned this running lark is a bit addictive. I am 50 next year and am running a Marathon just before.

Good luck with the rest of the program just enjoy it and how it makes you feel. I love running it keeps me sane.

in reply to Beccym

I can completely see how addiction can set in! I know I am only a few weeks in, but I am surprised by how much I get out of each run, even on my off days.

It is brilliant to hear that you will be doing a marathon next year. I'm beginning to think very differently about my impending 50s after chatting with folk on here. Hope all goes well for you and thank you!

Flyingred profile image
FlyingredGraduate

Yes, I was disappointed in the first 8 weeks of C25K that my weight didn't go down. I noticed around week 6-7 that my waist was trimmer and people complimented me on losing weight.

When you get to week 9 and you're running for 30 minutes you will burn a lot more calories with each run, so from there it gets progressively easier. If you start to analyse your runs (what went well, what you might do to improve) you'll find yourself reviewing what you eat and naturally reducing unhealthy foods and eating more veggies and fruit. There's an excellent book, 'Born to Run' by Christopher MacDougall, which inspired me and influenced a few significant lifestyle changes, all for the better.

10 months after starting C25K, I'm down from 83 kg to 67 kg and have shed 4 inches off my waist, so it works if you stick with the programme. Good luck!

in reply to Flyingred

Thank you for recommending the book. It is good to know that the 15 year old mummy tummy I've been carrying has a chance of disappearing eventually, even if I still weigh the same for a while. I'm now understanding that muscle is heavier, hence my slight weight gain.

You have done brilliantly on the programme, so I shall stick with it. I have put the scales in the back of the airing cupboard, and they will stay there for a while....😊.

Flyingred profile image
FlyingredGraduate in reply to

Thanks for your kind words. Just stick to the programme and follow the instructions and you'll be fine. As for your 15 year-old mum tum, with C25K, I now fit into (and wear) a suit I had made to measure in 2000, so anything's possible!

Iamnegan profile image
Iamnegan

I have just completed w4 r3, alongside slimming world, and I agree, my weight is quite stable despite eating properly. At weigh in yesterday I was advised that you retain water when changing your exercise regime, so I’m keeping going, and loving it I may add!

in reply to Iamnegan

I have been drinking a lot of water! That makes me feel better. I’m also enjoying this C25K malarkey far more than I expected to! We are at similar stages. I do my last run of Wk4 on Tuesday, then it’s on to the Wk5 that everyone goes on about!! Good luck with yours 😀

Iamnegan profile image
Iamnegan in reply to

And yours too, never have been able to run at all. Ever. And now I’m going into week 5, this is amazing!! Keep going ☺️

Pianism profile image
PianismGraduate

Stick with it kiddo and the scales will move eventually.

I lost masses of weight initially but I did a radical diet change plus started walking around 5 miles per day. However, I'm sure my shape has changed much more than the scales say it should have.

I have no doubt that as your general level of activity increased through and beyond the programme, you will get into the needed calorie deficit. :)

in reply to Pianism

Thank you Pianism!

I just couldn't understand why my weight had gone up and not down since starting a few weeks ago. Everyone's posts have been really helpful in understanding why this might happen and more importantly, telling me not to worry about it. Losing weight wasn't my main driving force behind doing C25K, but I was kind of hoping to finally shift the mummy tummy a little as I went along. What I have gained so far from running every few days is more than I could ever have imagined, and the folks on this forum have contributed to that more than they could know.

On another note entirely.... How is the Grand Tour of the Park Runs going? You are a little towards my old stomping ground in the North West before I became a Southern Softie down here in the beautiful South Downs.

Pianism profile image
PianismGraduate in reply to

I'm only touring once a month as I'm rather fond of Marple parkrun, and somehow it feels like I'm being unfaithful!! Lol Also, I have piano students Saturday mornings so want to limit the number of times where I'm home later than usually.

So only one new one done yet, but very much looking forward to the next one. :)

Am_i_really_running profile image
Am_i_really_runningGraduate

Remember it's only a number and I know you feel as many do that its an important one. The main thing is how you feel about yourself and as others have said your shape will change as you progress through this adventure.

in reply to Am_i_really_running

Thank you, wise words ☺️. I am going to focus on other things.

How's Wk5 going? You must be well on your way through by now?

Ang33333 profile image
Ang33333Graduate

I didn't lose any weight through running alone. A change in what I was eating - and how much - has made the difference. Running is now helping me to maintain. Good luck !

in reply to Ang33333

Thank you! 😊

Take some measurements and ditch the scales. Two years on I weigh exactly the same as I did when I started but have gone from 12 to size 8 jeans and size 14 to size 12 on top, without any dieting. Unless you wear a sign advertising your weight, no one will ever know! :)

I don't think muscle weighs more or less than fat but it takes up less space (think about the old question- which weighs more, a tonne of feathers or a tonne of lead? :)

😊 I put the scales in the back of the airing cupboard yesterday. Taking measurements is a much better idea - thank you.

5KAims profile image
5KAims

A lot of people put on weight when they start stuff like this, you probably only burn an extra 250-300 calories or so in the run for the first few weeks. almost equal to one chocolate bar or half a small lunch. A lot of people will ‘refuel’ after a run and so eat the calories they burned in the run if not more so. that’s fine to do, you probably feel more hungry after a run and it’s good for your body’s recovery but if you eat more calories extra because of the run than you burnt in the run you still put on weight.

If you ate exactly the same as you did before you wouldn’t even lose weight very quickly as the burnt calories aren’t really that much of a deficit anyway. The bonus of doing this is much much more about getting fitter and a little stronger.

You will burn more calories as your runs increase so if you don’t eat any more calories you may start to see some weight loss once you are running for the half hour.

in reply to 5KAims

Thank you, a really helpful reply and that all makes sense. I have been refuelling after runs because I have been getting sooo 😋 hungry afterwards!!

5KAims profile image
5KAims in reply to

Your welcome, I was worried it would come across as harsh but wasn’t meant that way. One pound of weight loss is generally know as 3000-3500 calories, so to lose a pound a week you have to eat that much less than you usually do or burn that much off. A mix of both is good but weight loss is mainly eating less tbh. For your strength, fitness, mental health and generally feeling good about yourself stuff like the couch to 5K is much better I think and can only help in general :)

in reply to 5KAims

Not harsh at all. I’m very grateful you replied 😊

Coco-Major profile image
Coco-MajorGraduate

I can also recommend Slimming World..I’ve started the C25K program as a way of keeping the weight off and toning up. I’ve lost almost 3 stone since just before Christmas and am now in week 6 and starting to see some definite shape change. The ‘pinch of nom’ website and book are great for lower fat healthy but substantial meals 😊

Shoot profile image
Shoot

Don’t weigh yourself. Measure your target area you will be burning the fat and building muscle hence the reason the scale goes up.

You may also like...

First step in the right direction!!!

So today, I did my first day of C25K!! I have had many attempts at it in the past but the lack of...

Oh well push me on the right direction and call me a runner

posted even at week 8 which was where my brick wall happened people took the time to post...

Giving it a go... Nothing to lose (apart from the weight) but everything to gain!

Got some scales to measure weight (haven't done for many years) BMI, Water etc and started a...

A failed run but a step in the right direction

supposed to do 2x8mins today (wk5r2). That didn’t happen. I only completed 1x8min and 1x5min. My...

Week 1 Run 1 A step in the right direction?

belong to a North West Clog group. Reasons for starting? I need to lose weight, I am in my 50th...