Tramps like us.........: ted.com/talks... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

133,933 members159,344 posts

Tramps like us.........

SlowLoris profile image
8 Replies

ted.com/talks/christopher_m...

My niece visited recently and during conversation she was amazed that I'd never heard of Ted Talks. As I'm currently laid up and have time on my hands I had a look and found this. Copy and paste the link to see Christopher McDougall's talk.

I'm not suggesting we all take up barefoot running. It's a different technique and personally I think I'm way too old to start.

Yours

Bruce

Written by
SlowLoris profile image
SlowLoris
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
8 Replies
Midriff_Crisis profile image
Midriff_CrisisGraduate

The kind of barefoot running that involves wearing vibram fivefingers shoes has a long way to go before it's considered anything other than a bit weird. And actually, it's just as commodified as any other sort of footwear, so the free yourself from this that and the other angle needs to be taken with a huge pinch of vegan friendly low sodium salt substitute.

SlowLoris profile image
SlowLoris in reply to Midriff_Crisis

I agree. It was interesting though that, shoes aside, we all evolved to be long distance runners.

Midriff_Crisis profile image
Midriff_CrisisGraduate in reply to SlowLoris

Absolutely ... it is in our DNA. I think unfortunately we've become a bit like the space puddings in Wall-E. :D

I ran barefoot as a teenager in the 60s. But then I did everything barefoot. I used to walk miles in the countryside or along the lanes, running at intervals for the sheer joy of it. I wouldnt like to try it with the current crop of glass, cans, and other detritus that we’ve littered the landscape with. I still walk barefoot round the house and use very flat shoes, such as baseball boots, in good weather, so I would be happy to gradually lower the drop on my running shoes. At the moment they are 12mm. Having said all that, most of us run on tarmac or concrete, that are entirely unsuited to pounding along with bare feet. The barefoot movement was popular a few years ago, but I think people were getting impact injuries for the reason Ive just mentioned.

IannodaTruffe profile image
IannodaTruffeMentor

Going barefoot is a wonderful idea and research in India has shown that children who have never worn shoes have fewer medical issues with their feet than those who wear shoes.

So maybe we should all do it.

My problem is that I have spent most of the last thirty odd years wearing rigid steel toe capped safety boots with steel mid soles. My feet are soft and would not last long uncovered without major impact or puncture injury in our climate and environment. I doubt that "barefoot" shoes would provide enough protection for my delicate, footwear distorted leg appendages and in four and a half years I have had one running injury, but none since having gait analysis and buying appropriate supportive shoes.

If you build your running body slowly and train carefully, then I believe you can avoid running injuries and that most injuries are in fact caused by doing too much for your current level of adaptation, rather than because the shoes cause problems themselves.

It is a fascinating area for debate, but how many barefoot runners have you seen in the UK over the last couple of weeks of inclement weather.........maybe we should all move to California.

SlowLoris profile image
SlowLoris

I remember the EVA cushioned soles taking off in the UK. In fact any sort of proper cushioning didn't seem to be around when I was a kid. I also remember running taking off as a fitness craze in the 70s. I was always running around in tennis shoes like Dunlop Green Flash before then.

I think my original post has sparked a conversation about barefoot running when it was the rest of McDougall's talk that I found more interesting.

My biggest problem is not my style or technique but the fact that I stopped running around after childhood.

Rignold profile image
Rignold

Leaving aside the barefoot issue, the real problem I have always had with Chris McDougall is the fact that he presented his book Born to Run as if it were a factual non fiction document, and has continued to do so in talks and articles since. Other people who appear in the book, particularly Scott Jurek and Jen Shelton have gone on record as saying that much of the account has been embellished at best and in several places entirely made up.

Whilst some degree of literary licence is to be expected to make books interesting to read, McDougall presented and continues to present his work based on his journalistic credentials, and this seems disingenuous to put it mildly, particularly given the superhuman and oddly spiritual feats documented.

Theziggy profile image
TheziggyGraduate

Barefoot running needs a clean debris and dog-poo free smooth running surface methinks 8-)

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Week 4 and I am TERRIFIED!

Hi everyone I am about to start week 4 and the thought of having to run for 5 whole minutes scares...

Legs feel like lead!

Hello, I graduated from c25k last month and have done 5km at few times now (32mins pb 🥳) Feeling...

My app doesn't play music when I'm running

This may be a silly question but how do I get music to play when I'm running? When Laura stops...

Feel a bit like a cheat

I'm on week 8. Finished my first run yesterday and was by far the hardest one yet. I was shouting...

Legs feel like lead

Hey, I've only just completed the 2nd week of c25k.....but my legs feel like lead. I'm doing it...