Finally... the answer to that question.... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

134,100 members159,470 posts

Finally... the answer to that question....

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate
12 Replies

I went for a lovely run this morning. As I am not Mo Farah, I had the privilege of seeing all the beautiful autumn colours in the vineyards, feeling the happy vibes, and majorly riling Gary the Gremlin, who was (of course) intent on doing other things this morning. He trailed along behind me for the entire run, pulling his shorts out of his bum and wailing that he needed the loo and wanted to go home.

On finishing our "nearly-8-K", Gary nose-dived into his armchair, sniffed and informed me that all this exercise would lead me down the slippery path of self-destruction, and that my mother would be proved right when my knees finally gave in after all this torture.

So is running really bad for your knees? We've all heard it said ominously by non-runners, at least once. Off we went on a trip around Tinternet (spot that Peter Kay reference there) and I found a report about a very interesting research paper (real science as opposed to Facebook "90 year-old granny transforms herself into five year-old child with a bunch of bananas and a pot of Dulux" science). The researchers didn't set out to study runners, but saw that part of their sample group had run regularly or continued to do so. They expected to see damage to their knees, but actually discovered the complete opposite: runners are less likely to suffer from knee osteoporosis. Gary is sulking. The article is here: runnersworld.com/general-in...

As for me, I feel like I'm the Hobnob of the running world.

youtube.com/watch?v=ZkO-oru...

Written by
mfamilias profile image
mfamilias
Graduate
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinnyGraduate

Now we know! Haven't read the article yet but had heard something similar. And more or less experienced it myself - my knees feel in better shape since I started running than they did before. Because they're being used the cartilage is being oxygenated better and can regenerate better. Might also have something to do with the 40 lbs of blubber I'm no longer carrying around😈

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate in reply toJaySeeSkinny

They do say that it's probably not just the running, but also the benefits of lower weight through regular exercise.

pollyp1 profile image
pollyp1Graduate

I agree with everything JaySeeSkinny says. Thanks for sharing.

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate in reply topollyp1

The magic of running: eat, run lose weight then keep it stable :)

pollyp1 profile image
pollyp1Graduate in reply tomfamilias

Even more magic of running - it just smooths everything out for me - one of the things that tipped me into trying was reading two references in as many days to the research that it helps, rather than hinders, knees. After 25 odd years of aches and pains following a high speed high impact car crash I feel sooo much better!

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate in reply topollyp1

Thant's fantastic! I bet you're glad you chose to read up on running that day rather than finding a recipe for triple choc chip cookies to eat in front of the telly. I often wonder what makes us decide on one thing rather than another - the implications can be life-changing :)

pollyp1 profile image
pollyp1Graduate in reply tomfamilias

Immensely so. Interestingly I was reading about osteo-arthritis as I recall, and then a friend knocked my other argument (I'm to old) out of the court by telling me that she had entered the 2017 London Marathon and she's four months older than me. And then I was walking in torrential rain in the woods, and the chap in front of me, who was was dressed just like me - in jeans, work boots and a mac - was RUNNING (very, very slowly) and I thought 'if he can do it, so can I'. And I started then and there, counting minutes in my head (I knew of c25k and the idea of intervals but had not yet listened to any podcasts). And I totally fell in love with it. It's helped with weight loss and kept me sane. :-D - Something to do with when the student is ready the teacher appears!

roseabi profile image
roseabi

Lol Gary the Gremlin :D

Yes, we all have excellent knees and no excuses! :)

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate in reply toroseabi

Gary is a star - Oldfloss drew him!

roseabi profile image
roseabi in reply tomfamilias

I found the drawing - awesome! :D

Irishprincess profile image
IrishprincessGraduate

Good article Mfam and an interesting outcome. I've not seen the one about "90 year old granny..........." but it must be true as it's on Tinernet 😊

Delighted to see that Gary is still sulking ☹️

mfamilias profile image
mfamiliasGraduate in reply toIrishprincess

Nor have I, but there are a lot of other things that are just as impossible :)

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Out with the old and in with the new!

Well this morning tried out my new running shoes. Now I know their not as posh as some of the...

First run, first fall, and Gary's confession.

Happy new year to all! This morning I pulled on my trainers and set out for my first run of 2017. I...
mfamilias profile image
Graduate

W2R1 knees to support or not to support-that is the question 😊

About 4 years ago I started running, I didn't use a program but was a lot fitter then. I had to...
Lifejourney profile image

My visit to the osteopath about my knees

Long post alert - though I think it's worth it! I thought it might be helpful to the runners and...
Steve_L profile image
Graduate

An update from Mfam

A sign of life from mfam: the trainer-clad snail is still alive and kicking her heels in the French...
mfamilias profile image
Graduate

Moderation team

See all
Yesletsgo profile image
YesletsgoAdministrator
MissUnderstanding profile image
MissUnderstandingAdministrator
Oldfloss profile image
OldflossAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.