Question for those with joints pain: Hi every... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

132,661 members158,711 posts

Question for those with joints pain

MoNi88 profile image
28 Replies

Hi every one ..

Couple days ago i posted question about running and joint pain etc.. but today my question is bit different..

If you have tried one of those joint strengthening tablets (like Cod Liver Oil etc) have you found them any help - im looking for first hand feedback on any of those joint-pills and what has helped with pain during running, how long did it take to work ect. I've asked a pharmacist today- he said go online.. so here i am :-\

MoNi :-)

Written by
MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
28 Replies

Hi MoNi

I'm not sure the Pharmacist meant this sort of online lol. I'm not a lover of putting anything other than Guinness in my body, so I cant advice sorry.

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to

lol well.. i wanted to ask the (you) people that are running cuz they would know the pain and challenges of running.. :-P thanks for post tho.. good to hear from you :-)

Ladyidle profile image
LadyidleGraduate in reply to

LOL!!! That's my kind of medication (she says, topping up the wine glass). Cheers! (And hoping I won't regret it when I run tomorrow!)

in reply to Ladyidle

lol and Cheers to you too my Lady. I'm off for my weekly quota of Guinness shortly. Have a glass for me.

Potty profile image
PottyGraduate in reply to

Involuntary snigger, then Hussain, very funny :-)

funny enough I have been thinking about taking some cod liver oil tab's as I have had a problem with knee pain ,but that is being caused by other things ...

I am not med expert but it can do any harm can it?

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to

the pharmacist told me something about glucosamine(?) and to check that but he said u have to take it about 5-6 months before you notice any change.. :-\

in reply to MoNi88

I think it is a personal choice , some would swear by natural things, some by diet etc etc if it works for you go with it

useitorloseit profile image
useitorloseitGraduate in reply to

I take codliver oil and glucosamine combined pills. I'm not sure they do anything for my joints, but my nails are great!

in reply to useitorloseit

I could live with having nice nails too :D

Rob_and_his_westie profile image
Rob_and_his_westieGraduate

Sorry to say that they never did a thing for me. A neighbour of mine recommend the regular consumption of the juice of squeezed limes. That didn't work either, but given its a benign thing to take, it might be worth a try.

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to Rob_and_his_westie

thanks Rob! that's a good thing i'll look into that :-)

PS just to say I read your bio! Well done! Very impressed with all the achievements in your list giving the health trouble u and ur Westie had/have!! Very inspiring! :-D

Rob_and_his_westie profile image
Rob_and_his_westieGraduate in reply to MoNi88

If it inspires you, then it served its purpose. For me (and Bailey, my Westie) we do not regard these things as troubles, but merely obstacles that life threw in our way. We found a way to move past them, I'm certain you'll do the same too.

runningnearbeirut profile image
runningnearbeirutGraduate in reply to Rob_and_his_westie

I'd say it depends on the cause of your joint pain. Mine started in the joint between my big toe and foot and was AGONY at times such that I had to pull over while driving (it was my right foot). I ended up with a steroid injection into the joint, and was told it was basically a pre-arthritic condition (I was in my mid-30s at the time).

Anyway, the point is that if I have lots of citrus juice, I find I can notice some pain in that and one or 2 other joints, and I thought it was fairly well known that citrus juices can cause the build up of whatever it is that can cause gout. I take glucosamine and don't care if it's "just a placebo".... the intense pain hasn't returned in that joint or started up in any others. Perhaps it would have been just a one-off, but I buy a year's supply at a time to bring out here and therefore it's fairly cheap and seems worth it to me.

Rob_and_his_westie profile image
Rob_and_his_westieGraduate in reply to runningnearbeirut

All very true. Whatever works, works and no two people are the same. Much like running where I use those gel pack energy things because I think they work for me. Whether they really do or not, who can say?

AdamB profile image
AdamBGraduate

My wife, who suffers from arthritis swears by glucosmine. However, it's not an instant relief. It takes months for them to work. On the occasions that she's stopped taking them though for one reason or another, she has had increased pain after about 2 to 3 months and is back taking them again. Glucosomine is not a quick fix.

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to AdamB

Thanks Adam that was very helpful! :-)

Rignold profile image
Rignold

healthy diet from the outset, lots of oily fish, flaxseed, etc. eliminate refined sugars and grains etc, usual stuff. If you fuel the body correctly in teh first instance, then the supplements are not really needed.

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to Rignold

WOW thank you EVER so much for that post!! I never knew there could be connection between grains and joint pains. I just had a look at couple articles about it and it was very helpful! Thanks again!!

Pigivi profile image
Pigivi in reply to MoNi88

and potatoes can be quite bad too....

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to Pigivi

Really? Thats been always part of my diet :(

Kasmcc100 profile image
Kasmcc100Graduate

I am, unfortunately, severely allergic to anything that comes out of water. No fish or shellfish products for me (including glucosamine).

I have ground flaxseed and sunflower seeds every day. And a fish free Omega 3-6-9 tablet to make up for it.

I cant say it does anything for joint pain, but it is great for my skin and nails.

My mum has arthritis and swears by Pernaton (made from green lipped muscles) but I can't speak from experience on that one.

MoNi88 profile image
MoNi88 in reply to Kasmcc100

Thanks for sharing, ill look more for that Pernaton. :-)

misswobble profile image
misswobbleGraduate

I have an arthtitic big toe and i take a daily omega 3 fish oil capsule which works in keeping the pain at bay.

nicolaclaire profile image
nicolaclaire

I take glucosamine and cod liver oil, I still have joint pain but not as bad, I was recommended flaxseed in a health shop and I found adding a sprinkle to food every day did help too...... (It had an effect quite quickly too) I'm also worse if I've run too fast usually when I'm running with someone else and don't notice I'm doing it! Good luck trying to find the thing that helps for you!

Theziggy profile image
TheziggyGraduate

I started taking glucosamine (as a last resort - as I very sceptical about it) and would have to say that I think it must be working as my knee pain has subsided. I also think it kicked in faster for me than the 5 to 6 months that people are mentioning.

Unfitdad59 profile image
Unfitdad59Graduate

I am 60 and was starting to get aches in my knees. A friend of mine is a physio and she told me to try glucosomine. She said evidence of what it can do is purely anecdotal but if I was going to take it I need to take 3000mg a day and try it for three months and then decide. Now I am as sceptical as the next man and think that pills like these are snake oil so have never imbibed. But I figured what's the worst that can happen? Also, 3000mg is way more than the suppliers tell you to take. All I can tell you is I run 2-3 times a week with very little joint pain. Would it be the same if I didn't take it? Is it a placebo? I for one am prepared to believe that it works for me so for now will continue my course. Good luck with what you decide to do.

rmnsuk profile image
rmnsukGraduate

I took glucosamine for about a year. It didn't really help with joint pain and when I stopped it didn't make any difference to my joints. When I stopped it did help my tummy problems.

Be sceptical about glucosamine, but if it works or you...

You may also like...

Joint or muscle pain?

my question is..... Do you think this is just muscle Pain and I should try the knee strengthening...

Question about calf pain

periods of running with no walking...ie week 6 run 3 onwards? Thank you if you can help. We have...

Question for those with experience of winter running

winter running and it is fast approaching! My question is... What is your essential winter...

W5R3 completed but SI joint pain

sacroiliac joint pain which I haven't had before. I am running in some rather old trail running...

Joint pain after 3 runs

but I am noticing I have pain in my hip joints. Has anyone experienced that? Any suggestions or...