best calcium citrate : anyone know... - Bone Health and O...

Bone Health and Osteoporosis UK

5,585 members2,456 posts

best calcium citrate

Radars profile image
18 Replies

anyone know which calcium citrate is best is solaray a good one because I take 20mg of pantoprazole a day and it blocks calcium, and I have a hiatus hernia as well as severe osteoporosis, L5 t12.

Written by
Radars profile image
Radars
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
18 Replies
HeronNS profile image
HeronNS

Can't comment on specific brands. Personally I've found capsules more tolerable than solid tablets or caplets, no matter what the supplement. You may also be interested to know that yoghurt is supposed to help with absorbing a calcium supplement. Don't take calcium with some other things (you'll know about medications, but don't take a magnesium supplement at the same time as calcium will prevent it from being properly absorbed), Vitamin D enables the body to absorb calcium, and Vitamin K2 (and magnesium) make sure that calcium gets into the bones. I've also read that citrus helps with calcium absorption, but maybe that's to help with other forms of calcium than calcium citrate?

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase

Hi radars, I’m sure I’ve probably mentioned these before but I was incredibly sensitive to the calcium I was prescribed my my doctors. On a good day I probably get enough calcium from my diet but to be sure I top up with one of these a day.

They are very gentle on the gut - I have IBS and they don’t cause me any problems at all. togetherhealth.co.uk/produc...

They come in capsule form, I’m like HeronNS I take all of my vitamins in capsule form as I also find them more tolerable. I buy my own D3 and it comes in capsule form too.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Fruitandnutcase

thanks, but I can't take a chance with all the other stuff in it.

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Radars

Oh I’m sorry about that. I hope you find something soon. What about the fortified orange juice with added calcium you get in the supermarket. Do you think you might be able to take that?

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Fruitandnutcase

I have got a hiatus hernia so can't drink orange juice.

WillowsMother profile image
WillowsMother in reply to Radars

What about almond milk? That's very good for calcium, and easy to digest- unless you have a nut allergy... you'd need to drink quite a lot - not just a splash in tea!

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to WillowsMother

I drink alpro unsweetened soya milk just the same, I drink it with whey protein powder.

WillowsMother profile image
WillowsMother in reply to Radars

That's good, but if you can tolerate almond milk instead... "Almond milk has fewer calories than soy milk, 17 per 100 grams. It has 188 milligrams of calcium to soy's 25 milligrams. Almond milk is also a good source of riboflavin, a B vitamin, at 0.177 milligrams to soy milk's 0.069 milligrams." I've recently made the switch myself!

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to WillowsMother

yeah ,but I need to gain weight, alpro soya has 120mg per 100mgs.

Raleigh59 profile image
Raleigh59 in reply to Fruitandnutcase

I cannot buy this in the United States.

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Raleigh59

Oh that is a pity. I think AlgaeCal is an American product but it is expensive here in the U.K.

I’m not sure what it costs in the US though or what else is in it.

Raleigh59 profile image
Raleigh59 in reply to Fruitandnutcase

Does this seaweed product contain both calcium and magnesium together?

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Raleigh59

I don’t know if that link will open in the US but according to the advert for it it says.

HARVESTED

Calcified seaweed is sustainably harvested from the coastal waters of the Atlantic.

DRYING & CLEANING

The seaweed is naturally dried in the sun then steamed to clean and purify it without the need for chemicals.

MILLED & SIEVING

The seaweed is then ground and sifted into a fine powder ready for encapsulation.

PURIFICATION

The powder is passed through magnets to remove any heavy metals from the seaweed's natural environment.

TESTING & ENCAPSULATION

The purified powder undergoes heavy metal and microbial testing. Approved powder is then encapsulated.

The trace minerals it includes that are really just that - a trace, although there is a bit more magnesium. I take my own magnesium, boron and K2-Mk7 amongst other things.

cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0...

uncountable3 profile image
uncountable3

As long as you can swallow them and the supplements are actually calcium citrate, it shouldn't make different what brand you use. Alas, Solray fails on the second point. It is actually a blend of Calcium Citrate, Calcium Carbonate, and some herbs that they claim help absorption.

My favorite Calcium Citrate is a Puritan's Pride house brand. 250mg per capsule. I prefer capsules over tablets and caplets because capsules are much easier to swallow. Unfortunately, Puritan's Pride been out of stock for literally a year.

Swanson has a 200 mg calcium citrate capsule. They also sell a 200 mg calcium asporotate. Calcium is claimed to be better absorbed than calcium citrate

711debbie profile image
711debbie

If you use Bone Up by Jarrow, you can get D3, calcium, K and everything else you need in the same pill. They prescribe 2 pills 3 times a day but most people seem to take less than that (either don't need that much or to save money). I only take 1 pill at breakfast and 1 at dinner as a rule, and my doctor said my calcium levels are fine.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to 711debbie

I already take 1000iu d3 and k2 mk-7 200ug.

1000Miler profile image
1000Miler

I take 2 Lamberts "Calasorb" tablets, to top up my calcium intake. They're currently cheapest from Medino (see link) but you can buy them elsewhere, including directly from Lamberts' own website. They're UK based. The tablets also have a small amount of vitamin D3 (just 2 micrograms per tablet). As it's such a small amount, I still also take my usual vitamin D3 supplement, which is 25 micrograms (or 1,000 iu)

medino.com/product/lamberts...

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to 1000Miler

just ordered some from Amazon 400mgs Lamberts

You may also like...

calcium citrate or adcal-d3

not good, would calcium citrate be better, I also take a ppi 20mg of pantoprazole, I have been dx...

Calcium citrate

I can’t take calcium carbonate so take this instead but I’m having trouble finding it in a...

Calcium citrate

I'm having trouble finding a calcium citrate supplement with a good amount of elemental calcium...

Best type of Calcium On PPIs

down to 20mgs on my own. I know it doesnt help bones, I have a hiatus hernia, I would be delighted...

am I absorbing calcium

I take 3omg of lansoprazole daily, I have been reading that ppis stop you from absorbing calcium,...