do I need a calcium supplement - Bone Health and O...

Bone Health and Osteoporosis UK

5,585 members2,456 posts

do I need a calcium supplement

Radars profile image
37 Replies

just had blood test results, serum calcium level below range, and serum creatinine level below range, do I need a calcium supplement,

Written by
Radars profile image
Radars
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
37 Replies
Kaarina profile image
Kaarina

If you've just had your blood test results you will be advised if you need to take any calcium/ vitamin D supplement. I thought you were prescribed them in the past......

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Kaarina

I already take 1000iu d3 and k2 mk-7 200ug a day, but with severe osteoporosis it's hard to get 1,200mgs of calcium a day because other foods block calcium absorption. don't know what to do because it's dodgy with calcium supplements. because they can go into the arteries,

Kaarina profile image
Kaarina in reply to Radars

Sometimes we have to weigh up the pros and cons. A medic will suggest the next action if there is one. It is up to you whether you heed their advice or not.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Kaarina

I have a phone call from gp on Sunday so I will ask him, also I have just had a spinal x-ray on my spine but they only did my thoracic spine and not my lumbar spine due to mistakes by different gps, I have to go through a referral again.

Kaarina profile image
Kaarina in reply to Radars

Unfortunately nowadays it is not at all unusual to not see one's own doctor but anyone who happens to be available. Consequently there is not that good continuation of care and as you say mistakes are being made which is a waste of time for the patients, clinicians and resources.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Kaarina

which calcium supplement do you think is best, can't take adcal-d3 because of constipation.

Kaarina profile image
Kaarina in reply to Radars

I cannot help you there unfortunately as I do not take a calcium supplement. A medic will be able to suggest an alternative to Adcal-D3 if you explain that this one causes constipation for you.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

If you can not reach that through your diet, please take a calcium supplement, preferably one that contains calcium citrate rather than carbonate".

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Radars

I’m sorry you are having ti start again with another referral for an X-ray - it must be really annoying for you radars!

Did you find anything useful from the thoracic spine X-ray?

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Fruitandnutcase

mild superior fracture with end-plate deformity l1

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Radars

I thought you knew that already - but then they didn’t X-ray the area you wanted xrayed. Did no one with any expertise suggest any sort of treatment for you other than the reclast and vitamins etc. No gentle physio or that sort of thing?

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Fruitandnutcase

no,didn't know I had a thoracic mild fracture, got to wait now for x-ray of lumbar spine, I have got some body exercises to do from the royal osteoporosis society

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply to Radars

Sorry I thought you knew you had an end-plate deformity l1. Hopefully it won’t be too long until you get your next X-ray, it’s too much being in pain while your doctors mess around and order the wrong X-ray or at least not the one you were hoping to have done. Good luck with it.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Fruitandnutcase

yeah I knew I had end-plate deformity from dexa scan but I wanted to know regarding fracture

uncountable3 profile image
uncountable3 in reply to Radars

What are your vitamin D levels? I take 5000iu/day and I only get middling levels. Others do better but you can't know unless you measure.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

Chocolate could block calcium absorption.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

certain foods block calcium .just Google it there's a lot

Seasid profile image
Seasid

Do you drink milk or yoghurt? I personally would not take calcium supplements if I could get it trough eating normal food. You also save some money. I have now lot of milk in my fridge. Why would I buy supplements?

agingfeminist profile image
agingfeminist in reply to Seasid

the benefits from milk are rather unclear. This overview is really useful

bbc.com/future/article/2019...

cheese and yogurt seems to be a better way to go. always take the vit D3 supplement, some evidence that it better to take it with K2.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to agingfeminist

I am too lazy. I just drink milk. I understand what you are saying. Thanks I usually buy milk on mark downs. That's why I have 4 liter milk now in my fridge. It is very convenient.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

yeah, but I have had a zoledronic acid infusion and you are supposed to take a calcium supplement while on it.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

I agree

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

What the prescribing info for Xgeva says is "Administer calcium and vitamin D as necessary to treat or prevent hypocalcemia.. . Monitor calcium levels, throughout Xgeva therapy,especially in the first weeks of initiating therapy, and administer calcium, magnesium, and vitamin D as necessary. ." One should monitor plasma levels of both and supplement if necessary.

pi.amgen.com/-/media/Projec...

Zometa says ,"Coadminister oral calcium supplements of 500 mg and a multiple vitamin containing 400 international units of Vitamin D daily."

accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatf...

Be careful about supplementing calcium if not indicated by low calcium levels, as it may make PCa worse and may have other deleterious cardiovascular and renal effects. Excessive Vitamin D intake has been shown to weaken bones.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Seasid

Here is the link to the information:

accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatf...

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

I have just got my blood test results, serum calcium level below range, red blood cells below range, creatinine level below range.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

Maybe you should consume more calcium in your diet. when I was a young student I always tried to drink 1 liter of milk per day. It was cheap. Talk to a nutritionist.

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Seasid

I received this information from the endocrinology about calcium intake:

"Aim for 1000mg per day.

If you can not reach that through your diet, please take a calcium supplement, preferably one that contains calcium citrate rather than carbonate".

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Seasid

Calcium intake

Calcium intake
emersee profile image
emersee in reply to Seasid

Seasid - that diagram about calcium content is very helpful and concise. Many thanks.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

yeah but there are other foods that block calcium

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

I am not a doctor nor a nutritionist. Could you ask for an appointment so they can help you? Your calcium levels should be better.

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

I have got a gp phone call tomorrow

MyStar86 profile image
MyStar86 in reply to Radars

Good luck with your call tomorrow I hope you get everything sorted! Let us know how you get on, I’ll be thinking of you hoping it goes well 😊

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

What is your glomerular filtration rate?

Radars profile image
Radars in reply to Seasid

what's that

Seasid profile image
Seasid in reply to Radars

Kidney function.

Calculated glomerular filtration rate from your blood creatinine levels. My is between 60 and 90.

Seasid profile image
Seasid

You should monitor your calcium levels. I think eating Ca reach food is ok, but of course you can take calcium supplements if you need it. Most important is that your blood calcium levels are checked and that you keep them in a normal range. You can take calcium supplements in order to achieve that.

You may also like...

Calcium and supplements

had a Vit D test, among many blood tests, as I had cancer treatment in 2016. My Vit D levels were...

Am I getting enough calcium and should I take a supplement

However, blood tests report I do get enough. Doctors have never mentioned I have a lack of calcium....

Advice on Calcium Supplements Please

refused as my astute GP noticed a high level of calcium on my bloods (it would have actually been...

Information on calcium supplements please.

have always been told I do not need a calcium supplement because my levels are very good. This is...

vegan calcium supplement, please

anybody please tell me how to find a vegan calcium supplement that my GP will be willing to...