Opinions?

[Elleeee]

I have put on almost 7 pounds in 5 months. I am so depressed nothing is making this weight budge! I weigh 52kg and I am 5’3 19 year old. Do people see this weight as bad as I do ? I have always been very slim until now

[Hidden]

What have you tried to do about it so far?

[hypercat54]

I have told you several times what I think Elleee and you don't seem to want to hear it. See the link. I put your details in and this is what it came up with. If you want to be unhealthy and underweight that is your choice of course. x

nhs.uk/Tools/Pages/Healthyw...

[b1b1b1 in reply to hypercat54]

Your answers are always so direct and you don't mince words. I like that!!!

[hypercat54 in reply to b1b1b1]

Well the poster has put up several virtually identical posts which I have answered before and she is still asking the same question! x

[b1b1b1 in reply to hypercat54]

Yes, that is the case. However, I meant all of your answers are direct and no word mincing. That is a very good thing.

[Hidden in reply to hypercat54]

If you have answered before then you don't need to answer again... you wont finish answering if the poster keeps asking the same things lol

[Elleeee in reply to hypercat54]

It’s not the same question... I am wanting opinions on the weight I’m at now. When I asked before i was at a different weight

[hypercat54 in reply to Elleeee]

What do you weigh now then? Are you more than 52 kg's?

If the info is the same as you just posted then according to the NHS site (see the link) then your BMI is 20.3 and the healthy range for your weight etc. is between 47.4 kg - 64.3.

Your BM1 to be considered a healthy weight should be between 18.5 and 25. As you will see from the figures you are at the lower scale of your BMI and are not anywhere near overweight.

Obviously we can't see you online so we can't determine whether at 52 kg you are now overweight. Maybe you need to post a picture of yourself so we can see you for ourselves? x

[Elleeee in reply to hypercat54]

But that’s back when I was a lot slimmer... I’ve put a lot on since then x

[hypercat54 in reply to Elleeee]

So what you said in your post isn't what you weigh now? Have you looked at the link coz I put those details in and this shows the result. If you don't believe me then you can always put your details in yoursel! x

[Elleeee in reply to hypercat54]

No I mean how you’re saying that you’ve answered me before on previous posts, that’s when I weighed a lot less than I do now. Yes I’ve checked.

[Hidden]

I got really depressed a year ago and lost 70 pounds. It damaged my liver. Be careful and make sure you eat.