Low calorie pasty?: Being a Cornishman... - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,075 members61,307 posts

Low calorie pasty?

SloopJohnB profile image
17 Replies

Being a Cornishman, I used to love a proper Cornish pasty. But after cutting down and losing weight I don't get them any more.

I've seen so called low cal recipes but they all involve pastry.

I was wondering if you could achieve same thing but without the pastry? I've not tried it yet but here are my ideas:

Pasty contents are layered - so why not layer in individual pie dishes and cover with foil and bake?

Chop potato into short thin strips. Layer on bottom of dish.

Then chop swede in same way and layer over potato. Then same with onion which goes over swede.

Finally, cut some braising steak into fine strips and lay on top. Chop up bit of parsley to add. Add salt and pepper and cover with foil to seal all in. Or use greaseproof baking paper.

Cook in oven for hour at 160C.

Should work. Anyone fancy trying? Let me know how you get on.

Written by
SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
17 Replies
Lytham profile image
Lytham3 stone

Hi I would add some beaten eggs to make it stiff, pastryless quiche, love it ! Would you like to join our summer challenge? Here is the link :-)

healthunlocked.com/nhsweigh...

Joanney69 profile image
Joanney69

Sounds interesting, SloopJohnB but as a fellow Cornish person I would go the whole hog and have a good quality real pasty 😊 going lower for the rest of the day (& possibly the day after!) to balance it out 😊 I haven't had a pasty since I started here, so about 15 months, but I am going to make some soon. Mine will probably be smaller than it used to be (overhanging the plate! 😳) and I figure with all that veg as well, it's a treat worth having 😊

SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB in reply toJoanney69

My mum used to make some great pasties. I learned from her but never managed to get it right. The Ginster ones in shops are made in Cornwall but flaky pastry never. Shortcrust. But they now own proper pasty company too. West Cornwall Pasty I think.

Joanney69 profile image
Joanney69 in reply toSloopJohnB

Please don't use Ginsters in the same sentence as Cornish Pasty 😂 the problem is, visitors think it's a proper pasty - it really isn't, it's all mush.

You could order online if you really want a good pasty 😊

BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator2 stone in reply toJoanney69

I didn't know you were Cornish :)

When I was a student nurse, one of our little gang friends was Cornish. She used to make brilliant pasties for us with our initials on to allow for any faddy folk who didn't want this or that (not that she was impressed at having to make any variations :D ). Don't think I've ever tasted a pasty so good.

Joanney69 profile image
Joanney69 in reply toBridgeGirl

You can't hear my accent from there 😀

I do the same, Mary - I have a daughter who doesn't like meat in hers, a son who likes extra meat, I like extra onions and the OH is not fussy 😊 so we all have an initial, which is extra pastry - oops 😋

S11m profile image
S11m

I am not a culinary expert - but you could just bung it in a pot and call it a casserole or stew?

Or put a potato topping on it and call it a pie?

Can you send me a sample as an attachment... or a photograph?

It might seem a foreign idea to a Cornishman - but what about haggis?

SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB in reply toS11m

The idea is the layering gives the flavouring. No added stock. Not tried yet. Just putting idea out there.

ozziesmum profile image
ozziesmum in reply toS11m

Ugh, go and wash your mouth out with soap and water! Haggis is horrible, had some when I went to a wedding in Scotland a couple of years ago, never again.

H61g profile image
H61g

I think ive seen somewhere you can make lower calorie pies by using strips of pastry on the top of a pie in an open lattice so that you still get a bit of pastry, but nowhere near as much as you usually would. Might help you get the flavour and some pastry, but a lot less calories as there would be a higher % of filling to pastry?

SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB in reply toH61g

I've seen version where filo pastry used instead of shortcrust.

in reply toSloopJohnB

I was just about to say you could try using filo pastry but i think i'm in agreement with Joanney69 .... if you fancy one, have a proper one and try and balance your other meals out over the week. I've done chicken and ham pie with filo before and although nice, it wasnt as good as it would have been as a proper pie!

None of this pastry lid malarky either ... its only a pie if it has a pastry top and bottom!!

SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB in reply to

Unless it's pub hotpot 🤣

Joanney69 profile image
Joanney69 in reply to

Pasty pie is amazing 😊 pastry top and bottom, but somehow tastes different to a pasty.

I do like a 'stew' pie - like stew, but just beef, potato and swede with a pastry lid - lush 😋😍

ozziesmum profile image
ozziesmum

Sounds nice. Only a 'bit' of parsley? I love the stuff, unfortunately it no longer loves me. At least I would be ok with the potatoes and swede.

SloopJohnB profile image
SloopJohnB in reply toozziesmum

Have you tried the broad leaf parsley?

ozziesmum profile image
ozziesmum in reply toSloopJohnB

Sadly anything that has any sort of leaves is not a good idea. I have to stick more or less to a low residue diet, though there are some fruit/veg I can tolerate. Can't have a jacket potato, at least not the skin, which to my mind is the best bit. can't have salads either.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Low carb frittata loaded with vegetables!

Just made this for the first time. I absolutely love Spanish omelette, but am trying to limit my...
Persephone33 profile image

Spanakopita (Spinach and Feta Filo Pie) - 406 calories

Looking forward to a slice of this with a green salad tonight! Spinach and Feta Filo Pie...
Pineapple27 profile image

Aubergine and Chickpea Curry - 166 calories

Serves 4 Red Peppers -1 Med/119g Chestnut Mushrooms -140g Baby leaf Spinach -175g Tomato Puree,...
Pineapple27 profile image

Healthy Happy New Year Bean Stew - 154 calories

Ah, Christmas has taken its toll on me – and I managed to gain a staggering 12lbs over the...
Pineapple27 profile image

Best low cal "drownie" recipe!!!

For all the dark chocolate lovers.... This is an amazing recipe for dark chocolate vegan and...
Laura4fit profile image

Moderation team

See all
BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.