ADRENAVIVE ..OR NUTRI ADRENAL ? ANY THOUGHTS ON... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,935 members161,763 posts

ADRENAVIVE ..OR NUTRI ADRENAL ? ANY THOUGHTS ON THIS ANYONE ?

Jollypolly profile image
20 Replies

ADRENAVIVE OR NUTRI ADRENAL ? !

There is the question!

Has anyone else recently switched from Adrenavive to Nutri Adrenal ?

Cost of Adrenavive being the main reason ?...

I’m in the process of switching,..I’ve switched half .....I think successfully.

I was taking two doses of Adrenavive a day...one Adrenavive 111 at 5 am with my NDT

And one Adrenavive 111 at 11 am with a vitamin c

When I’ve been in a better place I was taking an Adrenavive 11 then instead.

Two Adrenavive 111 daily equals roughly £33 monthly....rather a lot I’d say !

Four Nutri Adrenal a day costs about £17.50 month .....a much better scenario...

But I’ve only guessed at these equivalents...I’m not sure there is an exact equivalence....but wonder if in experience other people would find that two Nutri would equal one Adrenavive 111..and therefore one Nutri would equal one Adrenavive 11.....

ANY THOUGHTS ON ALL THIS ANYBODY ?

We need to individually get this right, as in times of more severe stress, where we’ve successfully treated ourselves with Adrenavive......we need the confidence to know that we’re safe to continue along the road with Nutri Adrenal as a reasonable substitute.

I use Dr Rinds temperature graph with his method of measuring Adrenal stress ....I’ve always found Adrenavive up to the task of getting my temperatures stable so I can raise my NDT......Nutri needs to do that particular job as well ...

So I’m on half and half at present....and would like to switch completely,,,.

Could do with any input from others who’ve been down a similar path,..and then I may have the courage to go the whole hog and simple take two lots of two Nutri Adrenal daily,

Written by
Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
20 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

Jollypolly

I was using Adrenavive lll, my adrenal tests were disappointing even after almost a year on it.

Because of the cost and the fact the new stock wasn't in when I needed to order my next lot of Adrenavive, I decided to change. I was going to have Nutri Adrenal then found Nutricology Adrenal glandular which is the same as Nutri Adrenal but cheaper (still a good brand). It's too early to say if it's going to be better, equal to or worse than Adrenavive.

The one thing to remember is that Adrenavive is Adrenal Cortex only. Nutri Adrenal and Nutricology Adrenal are glandulars - the whole gland providing tissue from both the medulla and the cortex, so it's not a straight swap. There wont be as much cortex in Nutri or Nutricology Adrenals as there is in Adrenavive lll.

Jollypolly Edited to add - Adrenavive lll is 250mg adrenal cortex. Each capsule of Nutri Adrenal or Nutricology Adrenal is 100mg adrenal glandular (total of cortex plus medulla). So 2 x Nutri/Nutricology Adrenal is less in total amount than 1 x Adrenavive lll, then take into account it doesn't give the exact amount of cortex in the glandulars, so it has to be less than Adrenavive lll.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to SeasideSusie

Hi Susie

Well yes..I can see that not really the same product at all..

I asked Dr P about it very briefly ..

He said he’d done both supplements...he’s on Adrenavive now I think..

But he didn’t give me any idea of practical equivalence...

With reference to your allusion to tests following use of Adrenavive...

I’ve done no tests at all dut to cost,but in experience.li have to say that with adjustments to dosing with Adrenavive, I am able to get and then keep my temps stable.

Interesting about your alternative product,.ill look into that..thanks.

The adviser at Nutri said to me that there are no hormones in Nutri Adrenal..

But she thought there must be in Adrenavive..

I have no idea at all ! And not sure what difference that would make anyway, in either !

The bliss of ignorance !

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to Jollypolly

I can't remember the details now, but a while ago there was something about NutriAdvanced saying "such and such" was in Adrenavive. I contacted The Natural Choice to ask about this and was assured that the only ingredients in Adrenavive are adrenal cortex and rice flour (filler) and that they had no idea why NutiAdvanced was giving incorrect information about a product they don't produce.

If you change to the glandular, I'd be interested to hear how it goes :)

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to SeasideSusie

Yes,,will aim to remember to let you know if I finish the swap.

I’m sincerely hoping others will contact me...there must be someone out there who’s swapped...I can’t be the Pioneer!

mischa profile image
mischa in reply to SeasideSusie

Seaside Susie see my post to Jollypolly.

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to mischa

Thanks mischa.

I'll see how I go with the adrenal glandular considering I haven't done too well on the adrenal cortex. If the glandular pushes me even further back I'll try the Klaire brand cortex - nice price! Or maybe I should try both together - get a bit of everything :)

mischa profile image
mischa

I too am finding Adrenavive a bit too pricey. I've found another adrenal cortex - 250mg per capsule at a price of £32.61 for 120 capsules. A lot cheaper than Adrenavive. It's by Klaire and there are a couple of sites online where you can purchase them. I buy mine from Your Health Basket. I've found no difference between the two.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to mischa

Well thanks for this Mischa..very helpful indeed..you’re a star !!

That’s brilliant..about the same price as Nutri Adrenal.

Three questions

1 Do / can you have confidence that this cortex by Klaire is high quality, safe and reliable etc etc ? No Purity issues ?

2 You’ve also tried Adrenavive then..? And have you also tried Nutri Adrenal ? Any comments on that ?

3. Do YOU follow Dr Rinds method of determining adrenal and thyroid health..using his temperature graph....?

Thanks again Mischa...very grateful...will follow this up.

Very best wishes...

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to Jollypolly

A BIG PS

IVE TRIED THORNE ADRENAL AND FIND IT NOT GOOD AT ALL...ANYONE ELSE DOUND THIS ?

mischa profile image
mischa in reply to Jollypolly

On their website, it is said to be BSE free and hypo allergenic, i.e. "free from common allergens including dairy proteins and gluten".

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to mischa

Have you tried Nutri Adrenal?

Have you tried Thorne adrenal cortex ?

mischa profile image
mischa in reply to Jollypolly

No I haven't tried either of those. Thorne, if you are taking a large amount of adrenal cortex, isn't cost effective. Thorne is only 50mg per capsule - works out dearer. Nutri Adrenal, I believe, is still the whole glandular but in a smaller quantity (100mg) than Nutri Adrenal Extra which is 200mg.

You probably are like me taking other supplements so would prefer to keep costs down but without compromising on quality.

Like Angel_of_the_North, I used to take Nutri Meds which was very much like Adrenavive but they stopped making them. Klaire is very similar to these.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to mischa

That is unbelievably helpful ! I’m so grateful for the info,thanks a million.x

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to mischa

Hey Mischa..

I now have a bottle of Klaire labs Xortex,,.it appears to equal Adrenavive 111...

Tell me...did you find them to be equivalent ? And do you think you can do a straight swap over,,.and not notice any difference ?

mischa profile image
mischa in reply to Jollypolly

I didn't do a straight swap, I had to transition gradually. I am very sensitive to any changes with regards to thyroid meds and adrenal cortex and with the cortex I did notice an adjustment of about a week or so - I went a little hypo.

The Klaire capsules you will notice are smaller than the Adrenavive although both contain 250mg. It means that the Adrenavive although only has one type of filler in actual fact contains more filler than the klaire hence the larger size of the Adrenavive.

There was a period of my body adjusting to the new adrenal cortex. But it certainly is effective. We are all different as to how we react to adrenal cortex. if I take too much - even the smallest amount - I get very hot but that is just how I react to cortex regardless of the make. I feel over stimulated.

I think it may well be easier for you.

Please let me know how you get on - I would love to know.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to mischa

Thanks Mischa..very helpful...I did actually launch straight in this am...I still took my one Adrenavive 111 at 5..but then swapped the 11 am one for Klaire,,I’ll see how that goes for a week.,

Many thanks again.

Marion

I didn't find Nutri adrenal (or extra) any use at all, but Adrenavive III and its predecessor Nutri-meds Adrenal cortex (which you can't get in the UK any more) both work well for me symptom-wise.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly in reply to Angel_of_the_North

That’s interesting...I did wonder...I’m surviving at the moment ..just..I feel...having swapped my mid morning Adrenavive for Nutri Adrenal,,but I’m very aware it may just not be food enough..and perhaps I’ve rightly felt reluctant to swap my morning dose..l.

I shall look into thi xortex Mischa has mentioned...

Angel_of_the_North profile image
Angel_of_the_North in reply to Jollypolly

If you don't mind the fillers, there are also other brands with 250 cortex. I tried most of them at one time or another, but never found anything as good as Nutri-meds or Adrenavive.

Jollypolly profile image
Jollypolly

Well..the only other one I’ve tried is Thorne,land for some reason is didn’t sit well with me at all..

You may also like...

Switching from Adrenavive 11 and 111 to Nutri Adrenal

I’m considering Switching from Adrenavive to Nutri Adrenal as price of Adrenavive has become...

Adrenavive III for adrenal fatigue?

that Adrenavive is about half the cost of Nutri-Meds, and recommended I give it a try, but...

Nutri Adrenals?

anyone tried the Nutri Adrenal supplements? They seem to do quite a few different ones, and I don't...

Nutri Adrenal Extra

of adrenal, and the recommended dosage is 1-2 capsules daily, so I assume 400 mg would equal two...

nutri thyroid and nutri adrenal

Can anyone give me some advice on nutri thyroid and nutri adrenal. Being new to this what is it and...