Nature-Throid and Supplements Interaction - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,182 members166,423 posts

Nature-Throid and Supplements Interaction

Rhsana profile image
23 Replies

Hi Everyone,

I hope someone out there can clarify as I am a little confused! I am now finally on NDT; half a grain in the am and half in the afternoon. I know not to eat for 2 hours either side but what about supplements? I am on a long list of supplements and I am worried they will interfere with the NDT.

I know not to take magnesium, calcium and Iron 4 hours either side but what about the following;

Selenium 200 mcg

B-12 5000 mg

Vitamin

D3 5,000 iu

Kelp (Iodine)

Cod Liver Oil 1000 mg

Zinc 25 mg

Thank you!!

Written by
Rhsana profile image
Rhsana
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
23 Replies
Rhsana profile image
Rhsana

Forgot to mention Ashwagandha as well

Clutter profile image
Clutter

Rhsana,

Iron, calcium and vitamin D should be taken 4 hours away from thyroid meds. Other supplements should be taken two hours away. Magnesium can be a relaxant so can be taken at bedtime.

Kelp contains a lot of iodine which you shouldn't need when you are taking thyroid meds. Too much iodine isn't good for hypothyroid and Hashimoto's patients and can raise TSH and trigger Hashi flares.

___________________________________________________________________________________________

I am not a medical professional and this information is not intended to be a substitute for medical guidance from your own doctor. Please check with your personal physician before applying any of these suggestions.

Anthea55 profile image
Anthea55 in reply toClutter

I've also read that zinc is absorbed better at bedtime.

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply toAnthea55

yes, i've been told this also, thank you!

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply toClutter

Hi Clutter,

Thank you for your reply. I was told by my Dr. to take Kelp specifically for the Iodine?

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

Did your doctor test your iodine before telling you to take iodine? If not, then he doesn't know what he's talking about.

There are a lot of doctors who think that all you need to do for a thyroid problem is throw iodine at it. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Excess iodine can cause all sorts of problems - including causing hypothyroidism. True, you need iodine to make thyroid hormone, but if half your factory has burnt down, shovelling in more raw goods isn't going to increase production, is it.

Besides, if you are taking thyroid hormone, you are taking iodine, because every molecule of T4 contains 4 atoms of iodine, which are removed, one by one, and recycled.

Do you know if you have Hashis? If so, taking iodine could make things worse. And won't help because your gland - factory - is slowly being destroyed, and therefore cannot make more hormone. So, taking iodine is really a bad idea.

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Yes, I'm having trouble typing on this site as well. So no worries about the typos. Thanks so much for your reply, I thought that was the case, he suggesting Iodine for a small goiter. Is that still a bad idea?

Thanks again!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

Well, yes, because the goitre is your thyroid, and the iodine goes straight there - and won't necessarily get rid of the goitre. What you need is an optimal dose of thyroid hormones and a complete thyroid panel :

TSH

FT4

FT3

TPOab

TgAB

and iodine if he wants you to keep taking it. :)

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Hey Greygoose,

Thanks so much for all your help! My most recent labs are:

Free T4 (Blood Spot)* 1.2 ng/dL

Free T3 (Blood Spot) 2.8 pg/mL

TSH (Blood Spot) 1.2 μU/mL

TPOab (Blood Spot)* 92 IU/mL

DHEAS (Blood Spot) 153 μg/dL

I can't see anything about Iodine, so I'll stop taking that for now.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

I'm afraid the numbers are meaningless without the ranges. :(

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Apologies!

DHEAS (Blood Spot) 153 μg/dL 40-290

SHBG (Blood Spot) 30 nmol/L 15-120

Free T4 (Blood Spot)* 1.2 ng/dL 0.7-2.5

Free T3 (Blood Spot) 2.8 pg/mL 2.5-6.5

TSH (Blood Spot) 1.2 μU/mL 0.5-3.0

TPOab (Blood Spot)* 92 IU/mL 0-150 (70-150 borderline)

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

Oh, they do make me cross with their 'borderline'. Makes no sense with antibodies, because they fluctuate so much. And you don't know if that's the highest they're going to get or the lowest, or somewhere inbetween. I think the best you can say is 'don't know'.

Your TSH is okish, but your FT3 is much too low. So, you're going to need several increases before you feel any better, or before it has any effect on the goitre.

That is going to suppress your TSH, but it really doesn't matter. You don't need it anymore because you're taking T3 ready-made, as it were.

Don't bother about the FT4, either. That is going to be low when taking any form of T3 because the body doesn't need to hang on to as much. Hope your doctor knows all that! :)

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Greygoose, thank you! I have only just seen this. Had a bit of a fog brain on for the last week! I was started on 32.5mg of Nature-throid twice a day for the first two weeks, but I don't feel much of a difference. :( I think it might need to up the dose!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

Yes, I expect you will. But, not until you've been on it for at least two weeks. :)

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

:) ok Thank you!

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Greygoose, sorry for all the questions, but I cannot figure out how to 'read' my own blood tests. What do the ranges mean? Or does anyone have a link to info on this?

Thank you thank you!! x

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

Have a look at this thread, it might answer your questions :

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply togreygoose

Thank you!!!!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toRhsana

:)

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana

I am also taking Progesterone so I am not sure if I can take magnesium and Zink in the eve?

Margo profile image
Margo

I take magnesium at bedtime, also progesterone. Why wouldn't you think it can be taken at night together Rhsana?

Rhsana profile image
Rhsana in reply toMargo

Because it made me nauseous, I now use the cream instrad

Margo profile image
Margo

Oh dear!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Feeling worse on Nature Throid

Many of you have written posts describing tough times when starting NDT. I am full of admiration...
Joeyis7 profile image

Nature throid.

I've been on Nature Throid for about 8 1/2 weeks. My latest results were tsh 0.4 T4 10.6 t3 4. I...
Digger031145 profile image

Nature throid to armour

Having just bought 15 months worth of nature throid i can see it’s being recalled, which is...
london81 profile image

Nature Throid

I wanted to take Armour, but the doctor said Nature Throid was better because it has T1234. Since...
Maryh1 profile image

Nature throid

Hi everyone, I think from reading previous posts that nature throid was reformulated a while ago....
Elle9 profile image

Moderation team

See all
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.