Brain shrinkage/loss ?: One of the senior... - PSP Association

PSP Association

9,176 members11,301 posts

Brain shrinkage/loss ?

NanBabs profile image
23 Replies

One of the senior carers in P`s nursing home returned from a training session and said she had spoken to the Parkinson`s nurse about PSP. This nurse `told her a lot` about PSP including the fact that `unlike Alzheimer`s PSP sufferers don`t have any loss of brain cells or volume`.

Any comments ?

xx

Written by
NanBabs profile image
NanBabs
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
23 Replies
Satt2015 profile image
Satt2015

Hi nanbabs I kind of disagree with that because my understanding is that the brain cells start to wear out at a much faster rate of someone with Psp

That’s sort of what the neurologist told us when he diagnosed Psp

Make sense? Maybe not......

I’m sure you’ll get lots of responses with a much better explanation than mine lol

Hugs darling x

Heidi-Ann profile image
Heidi-Ann

Hmm. When Jerry was diagnosed with CBD at Mayo 3-1/2 years ago, they compared two of his brain scans. One was done in 2010 and the other in 2014. His brain size had decreased so dramatically in four years that it was clear (and heart wrenching) for us to see. The neurologist said that his brain would continue to lose volume as the disease progressed. I would assume this is true of PSP also??

Karynleitner profile image
Karynleitner in reply to Heidi-Ann

That does sound heart wrenching, sad and frightening. I was wondering if you noticed the decline in his ability in correlation to the data on the scan.

By the time we took Dan to Mayo they felt his disease was fairly advanced, yet he had only minimal visible brain shrinkage. It was however , easy to see a problem in the frontal lobe.

Best of luck to you.

Karyn

Heidi-Ann profile image
Heidi-Ann in reply to Karynleitner

Hi Karyn,

Even though the shrinkage was clear on the scans, in 2014 he was not experiencing any trouble with cognition at all (and still is not), but mainly had left hand coordination problems, and balance and perception difficulty (although no falls yet in 2014).

Blessings to you and Dan. This journey is so hard.

Karynleitner profile image
Karynleitner in reply to Heidi-Ann

Isn’t this the strangest disease ?

Kevin_1 profile image
Kevin_1

Hi NanBabs

Well I've just had a look online...

Here is an MRI scan which shows what is happening in PSP

images.md/progressive-supra...

The cell death is in the mid brain.

But, we don't know how advanced PSP is for this patient.

So yes, maybe, I guess.

However if I am not mistaken some of the frontal lobe in this MRI scan has 'died off' as well.

Best

Kevin

xx

Abrecheisen53 profile image
Abrecheisen53 in reply to Kevin_1

Kevin, the link was very helpful.

Thank you!

Alice x

Kevin_1 profile image
Kevin_1 in reply to Abrecheisen53

Your welcome :)

x

NanBabs profile image
NanBabs in reply to Kevin_1

Thanks for the link Kevin.

Really good images and explanations. In P`s case his cognition has been severely impaired but I know all cases vary. He recognises friends and family even if he can no longer communicate but awareness of time, date, news etc is just not there.

xx

Kevin_1 profile image
Kevin_1 in reply to NanBabs

Hi NanB

I'm sorry to hear that.

Yes, there are differences. I watch Liz's symptoms unfurl little by little.

The last three days she has greeted me by bursting into tears of relief and she grips my hands to tightly when its time for me to leave and more tears. She, like P, seems to understand most things going on. However she gets some things so wrong.

It's miserable, Every day I feel I am abandoning her as if to some horrible care regime. Yet the home is a good one. I see the carers doing their stuff and they are very patient and involved with the people they care for.

She must be having some thoughts of being abandoned or something. I've been unable to find out what they are.

Got home and feel gutted.

xxx

raincitygirl profile image
raincitygirl in reply to Kevin_1

So hard Kevin - to give so much and still feel its not enough. No wonder you're gutted...

Hugs :-) xxx

Anne G

Yvonneandgeorge profile image
Yvonneandgeorge

Yes agree with you all I think parts of the brain do die xxxx

NanBabs profile image
NanBabs

Thank you all for your input - it is exactly as I understood it - the brain `shrinks` because of the Tau proteins killing off the cells. I`m sure when I looked at P`s scans (3 separate ones )over 3 years ago. the neurologist pointed out to the areas where the brain had decreased in size.

If a `specialist` nurse has the wrong information how on earth can we expect to get the proper treatment or understanding for our loved ones ? This carer came away with the news that `the brain is still intact, unaffected by dementia as it would be by Alzheimer`s`. I intend to, gently, put her right when I next see her !

Hugs to you all.

xx

Marie_14 profile image
Marie_14 in reply to NanBabs

Nanbabs show her the evidence on the internet. Maybe she will then understand it?

Marie x

aliciamq profile image
aliciamq

It's my understanding that with PSP ~ one pretty much gets to keep their marbles for the journey which is so sad. I missed any info about volume changing - I'll google it - but like someone once said ~ You'll get 36 answers from 12 Drs.

Heidi-Ann profile image
Heidi-Ann in reply to aliciamq

Yes, I get what you’re saying. Jerry watches the news and although he is barely understandable when he speaks, and is largely immobile, he will occasionally still try to offer background info on a person or situation, like “he was secretary of defense in the .... administration.” His mind is still good. I’m grateful for that, but it also seems like it would be easier for him if he didn’t know what was going on.

raincitygirl profile image
raincitygirl

Our experience (CBD) is the same as Heidi-Ann's. MRI showed both deep mid-brain and cortex volume loss.

Karynleitner profile image
Karynleitner

My husband was diagnosed at Mayo (MN) with PSP . His brain scans were explained similar to the one Kevin has referred to. They feel his mid brain has shrunk a bit and they saw changes in the frontal lobe, more on the left side.

In Dans case, the frontal lobe involvement seemed more noticeable to our non medical observations. The changes to the frontal lobe were easy to see.

crab2093 profile image
crab2093

Although Ch has eye problems , can't stand bright light, seems to not be able to control his feet, laughs and cries easily, falls almost every day, writes and eats slowly he can contribute to conversations and still work out complex fixing problems but having done so is very tired. I'm suggesting that there must be some shrinkage but exactly where it is hard to tell. I understood that the MRI would not show us PSP changes.... just adding my bit.

raincitygirl profile image
raincitygirl in reply to crab2093

How far into it is he Val?

Anne G.

crab2093 profile image
crab2093 in reply to raincitygirl

He was diagnosed April 2017 (a small stroke 12months before that) but there had been changes happening before ( mood, memory & a couple of unexplained falls). Full time use of wheely walker (waiting for a wheel chair) but able to do small amount of time in garden nursery. Eats okay but we mostly have cut up stews, stir fries & fish. If I go out he lies down to reduce chance of falls. I am usually nearby otherwise. Who knows how far in when all are so different?

raincitygirl profile image
raincitygirl in reply to crab2093

Thanks - he sounds a lot like my hubby (who I figure is at least 5 years into it.) You're right: people seem to progress at different rates...

Cheers :-)

Anne G.

wear1947 profile image
wear1947

Dear Nan, there are more than one PSP. In the case of gate freeze, the frontal lobule is not affected at early times. But, this issue is a matter of physicians. The caregiver could not become an specialist, even if she /he is a nurse. Do not rely on this type of comments as an orientation.

Take care of yourself, this is a long journey. Hugs

You may also like...

Shrinkage of the Brain

wife was suffering for over 4 years with PSP. During the treatment, brain scan MRI showed that her...

Dealing with the loss of my father

battle with PSP. He was in a nursing home towards the end but we couldn't have asked any more of...

re training the brain

everybody do you think its possible to re train the brain to send messages down different pathways...

REM sleep disorder may lead to untimely death of brain cells.

Thought I'd share this, sounds about right to me. My dad has PSP and has always had trouble sleeping

complete loss of language

My husband,Bob, has PSP & despite the input of our wonderful Speech & Language Therapist lost...