Carrying a little extra weight decreases mo... - Diabetes India

Diabetes India

61,866 members12,103 posts

Carrying a little extra weight decreases mortality from type 2 diabetes

Meetu77 profile image
8 Replies

"Patients with type 2 diabetes who are overweight but not obese live longer than those who are underweight or normal-weight, according to a study is published in Annals of Internal Medicine."

sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/05/150504182245.htm

So don't aim for BMI 19 or 20.

BMI 24 is far better than BMI 20 -- switch to LCHF and you won't even have to bother about BMI ;) ;)

Obviously they have added a small note to keep the mainstream happy.

Researchers slowly are proving what we diabetics on LCHF diet have been saying since long. We don't even bother about BMI as it is a useless number, unless overly obese. It's just a cover up for a BAD diet (High Carb Low Fat) which is called "Healthy and Balanced" by the so called scientists pushing that diet for selling more drugs.

Written by
Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
makarim profile image
makarim

A good article.Push it on and on.Thanks

Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77 in reply tomakarim

BMI is useless and aiming for 20 BMI is dangerous. :)

Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77

Something more on same lines -- sciencedaily.com/releases/2...

So don't aim for 19.5 or 20 BMI

;) ;)

kjfreeze profile image
kjfreeze

My thoughts suggest that these scientists are loco and have been smoking weed. There is no way that someone with additional fat is going to spring to health better than one who has less fat. This article even suggested a lot of variables exists. I think it's just another way of keeping a diabetic happy with staying on medication. Good luck with that!

Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77 in reply tokjfreeze

There's a difference between being OBESE and being Oveweight. Obese need to come down on weight, but aiming for 19.5 or 20 BMI isn't better than 24 or 25.

kjfreeze profile image
kjfreeze in reply toMeetu77

There has to be an attack on visceral fat. Keeping a BMI at 24 or 25 will keep fat in the liver and pancreas. There are a lot of parameters associated with this concept. You just can't punch out a random BMI and suggest it is a good thing simply because some "scientists" suggest it is slightly better than comparable. Proper weight management by the use of organic and free-range, the use of whole-food supplements, exercise, plenty of rest, etc., all are factors that these studies DO NOT take into account. I say don't get lazy and compromise your health on some study because I guarantee you when folks hear that they can do good at BMI's of 25, there will be another wave of mortality that these "scientists" hadn't accounted for.

Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77 in reply tokjfreeze

BMI is all based on correlational studies so irrelevant and that's why you have so many conflicting studies. Correlation does not mean causation.

All heavy weight boxers have been overweight by BMI standards and yet carried the least body fat.

Meetu77 profile image
Meetu77

"in consequence more food and more insulin."

Not so in case of LCHF. This applies to a High Carb Low Fat diet only.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

A leading Endochrinolgist advises a Thin Type-2 Diabetic! Interesting!

Here is what a leading Endochrinolgist from a leading Hospital has to say to a T2 patient of 44...
namaha profile image
Administrator

Have Type 2 diabetes? Don't lose hope

Despite popular belief, getting a diabetes diagnosis does not necessarily mean a lifetime of...
dialife profile image

Obese T2 DM Vs Thin T2 DM

Are you Obese T2 or Thin and skinny T2?? I have been studying the Etiology & mechanism of Obese T2...
namaha profile image
Administrator

A Simple inexpensive Blood test can Predict whether you carry a CV risk in future or/and you carry a risk of type 2 Diabetes/metabolic synd

I was interacting yesterday with one of my close Cardiologist Friend (we were school friends), he...
namaha profile image
Administrator

Reversing Type 2 Diabetes

It has been possible to work out the basic mechanisms which lead to type 2 diabetes. Too much fat...
ranj profile image

Moderation team

See all
Activity2004 profile image
Activity2004Administrator
barani19 profile image
barani19Administrator
namaha profile image
namahaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.