Is running good for my heart? : This my sound... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

132,718 members158,733 posts

Is running good for my heart?

Songstrez profile image
7 Replies

This my sound like an obvious question but I have the huewai health app and on my 25 min run today it said I spent 6 min in the fat burning zone, 1 min aerobic, 15 min anaerobic and 8 min in extreme with a max heart rate of 168. Is this OK? I want to lose weight but if the majority of the time my hr is anaerobic or extreme will I still lose weight and is it good for my heart?

Written by
Songstrez profile image
Songstrez
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
7 Replies
SueAppleRun profile image
SueAppleRunGraduate

If you are worried your heart is too fast go slower, short amounts of time at max heart rate shouldn’t do any harm if you are otherwise healthy, i am not medical though so if you have concerns pop along to your doctor or nurse and get it checked out

My first few runs were very high heart rate but over time it’s got lower so this plan does make us stronger in lots of ways

Songstrez profile image
Songstrez in reply to SueAppleRun

Thanks willowandsola. I'm already going pretty slow. My husband also said my hr should come down as I get fitter so I'll keep going!

Sparkey5000 profile image
Sparkey5000Graduate in reply to Songstrez

I’ve been running about 9 months now and I stay at around 170 for most of my 30-45 minute runs. I don’t have any ill effects so I thinks it’s a personal thing. But if you are worried nhs website is a good source of info right now when doctors are crazy busy

IannodaTruffe profile image
IannodaTruffeMentor

Maximum heart rate tends to decrease with age, so without knowing your age the question is meaningless.

The zones you refer to are based on averages..........you may not be average.

The only way to ensure they are accurate is to find out your true maximum heart rate and enter that into your device............and then again, many such hr monitors are notoriously inaccurate.

The moral of the story is that if you felt okay, then you probably will be..........forget the figures and enjoy yourself.

A little bit of knowledge can be very dangerous..........

UnfitNoMore profile image
UnfitNoMoreGraduate

As above... also, the “fat burning zone” is a bit of a myth that apps and trackers insist on promoting. health.usnews.com/health-ne...

Fors profile image
ForsGraduate

Hi

My huawai phone tracks me and also the Google Fit app and sometimes I use Back Country Navigator to track a route. They all give different answers for the same run!

I suggest that you just judge how you feel when you do a run, you can always treat it as a practice run if it is not going well!

mom24uk profile image
mom24ukGraduate

As the heart rate is calculated on age, it's difficult to say if it's ok (and I wouldn't be taking medical advice from me over the internet anyway 😂) but I can tell you what mine does. I'm 51 and my heart rate hit 191 in week 4 though it's normally hits the mid to high 170's. I know that I'm "supposed" to go at a max of 169 but it does this even at a brisk walk! I have got slower but I'm more guided by effort now. If I can't talk I'm pushing too hard so I slow down. If my chest felt uncomfortable (which it did a few weeks ago) or I was worried, I'd book in to see the Dr.

You may also like...

Cried after my run AGAIN. But for a good reason

in tears after another run. But this so different. I hit the 20 min run today. (Change of profile...

Not a good run - time to listen to my own advice!!

knew that today and next Monday were the only two days I was going to be able to fit in runs before...

My pre-10k race run and my heart rate stats

breakdown of my heart rate zones Warm Up Zone 46 s (3%) Fat Burning 6m 34s (23%) Aerobic 18m...

W8R3 feeling so good about my run - I can do this.

around to run the 14 mins back to the start I had now run further than ever before and when Laura...

So.. Running is good for you?

have recently been advised to lose some weight for the sake of a health condition (liver disease) -...