Obesity: a national security issue? - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,083 members61,310 posts

Obesity: a national security issue?

IvanTheHorrible profile image
IvanTheHorribleMaintainer
12 Replies

This video is from 2012, and things have not got better since then. This is a US General describing the impact of deteriorating health among young people on the performance of the armed forces, and he also touches on the human and economic cost of this epidemic:

youtube.com/watch?v=sWN13pK...

His basic point is that while governments have undoubtedly made this worse with misguided policies, they now cannot or will not fix it. It's up to every individual to sort out their own lives and the lives of their children. It's only the usual TED-talk 15 minutes, so well worth watching.

Written by
IvanTheHorrible profile image
IvanTheHorrible
Maintainer
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator2 stone

Thanks for posting this, I'll have a look later this morning :)

13Valerie profile image
13Valerie

Fantastic and scary... The statistics are shocking.. thanks for sharing

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61

Very, very sobering read. 😢 Is history repeating itself? The NHS was the result of mal-nourished population being unfit to fight in the Boer War . . . Are we really heading that way again?

IvanTheHorrible profile image
IvanTheHorribleMaintainer in reply toIndigoBlue61

Is that right? I never knew about that.

Incidentally, I hope that's not an indication of your age ;)

The Brits have always been a bit of unhealthy lot; the only difference between the upper classes and the lower was the type of unhealthy food they enjoyed. Was it George Orwell who commented on the working classes subsisting on tea, white bread, and potatoes? Way before that, William Cobbett was ranting about tea-drinking and people who refused to cook proper meals or grow some vegetables. My mum occasionally reminisces about how dreadful food was when she was young (50s/early 60s). Meanwhile, the idle rich have always been ... idle, with effete dietary habits. It's quite a surprise we made it through two world wars.

Of course the video is talking about Americans, but it's not radically different in the UK. PE, as far as I know, isn't on the curriculum anymore, and the stats about games TV-watching are probably similar. What bothers me is this: the army fitness tests aren't particularly demanding. I'm heading for 50 and I can meet the US recruitment standards (although not the UK ones, which are tougher). It's not so much that we might need to fight a war one day - although there is that - but there are a lot of other jobs that demand a similar level of fitness, and a whole generation of kids won't be able to do them. Not every kid is academically inclined, or wants to settle into a desk job in front of a computer screen. Other options - which they might find interesting and fulfilling - are being deliberately taken away from them.

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61 in reply toIvanTheHorrible

Haha . . . No I wasnt around during the Boer War actually 🤣 but the NHS was partly the result of the lack of fit and healthy men to fight.

Maybe it takes something as equally startling before things change again

BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator2 stone

Thanks for posting this. Very depressing, as we aren't far behind.

I was a child in your mum's era and though food was pretty uninspiring, with nothing like the variety we have on the shelves today, at least it was food. And we just ate food. At meals. Three times a day. Sitting at a table, with cutlery. (Sounding like a real dinosaur now, with apologies to your mum)

I've been puzzling about when 'snacking' became a 'thing', an expected part of everyday eating. I think that as a child a snack would be something you might have if your meal was delayed, not something you had as well as meals. And the idea of comestibles (not sure I should say food) being packaged as 'snacks' is bizarre to me. We have such a distorted relationship with food, and I'm not excluding myself, or I wouldn't be here.

in reply toBridgeGirl

As a little girl, I remember crisps "appearing", with the little bag of salt in the pack. I remember sweet treats and chocolate, but we didn't get them every day. A treat was a treat in the Olden Days !🤗

BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator2 stone in reply to

Yes, by definition a 'treat' is something outside the ordinary.

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61 in reply toBridgeGirl

Interesting about snacks. When I began this journey and was planning how best to utilise my (newly restricted) calories, snacks were the first to go, I wasn’t going to compromise my meals by spending calories on snacks!! Then I read somewhere about healthy adults being able to go 5/6 hours between meals. So I agree, when did snacking become ‘normal’?

in reply toIndigoBlue61

At the risk of being somewhat cynical, I do believe that the Food Industry Advertisers "normalised" snacking. Decades ago !

BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator2 stone in reply to

Yes, they turned it into a commodity, and now it's seen as normal

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61 in reply to

As a way of making extra profit!!! 😡

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

This is amazing.. So much more than I imagined

A huge Thank you so much for the welcome I have been given. I work to be a realistic optimist on a...
Minniewinny profile image
5 stone

Obesity, comfort eating and 10 stone to lose! :-O

Hi, I joined recently as I had a wake up call (a) when I got on the scales and (b) when I checked...

obesity

I'm so Fed up with being big. Iv Exercised for a week now. Feeling real good. Iv even dumped the...
Julieanne05 profile image

Obesity

Hiya I’m 19 very soon and I’ve at my heaviest weighing 19 and a half stones and. It’s really making...
Rhinestone_ profile image

Clinical obesity shock!

Hello, i'm new here. I'm 5'3" and weigh 12stone 10lb. I was shocked to be described as 'clinically...
LizzieG101 profile image

Moderation team

See all
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator
BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.