Unbearable "Charley Horse", Inner Right Thigh - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,317 members40,425 posts

Unbearable "Charley Horse", Inner Right Thigh

schmuppy profile image
38 Replies

PMR for nearly 1 year, currently on 10 mg pred - last night I was awakened with the worst Charley Horse I've ever had in my life, in a place I've never had one. My inner thigh muscle was pulling itself tighter and tigher, into a cramp so bad I thought I would have to call 911. it was hard to find a position to stretch it out in. I happened to have a can of Sprite zero next to my bed, and drank some of that thinking it was dehydration. After a few minutes of holding my entire leg up perpendicular to my body (thank God I can still do this), it went away.

Have any of you had this kind of thing happen? I've had the calf muscles seize up, and drunk water or OJ (for the potassium) to try and relieve it, but this is the first time I've had this kind of insane thigh pain. Could this be B12 or Iron deficiency or something caused by the pred?

Written by
schmuppy profile image
schmuppy
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
38 Replies
Maisie1958 profile image
Maisie1958

Sorry no advice but perhaps try magnesium supplements or Epsom Salt bath? Just wanted to say had to google Charley Horse-brilliant term for cramp/muscle spasm.

I do hope it’s a one off -very painful and disconcerting.

All good wishes from the UK.

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy in reply toMaisie1958

Will def try the magnesium. Thanks Maisie! :-)

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57

Greetings Schmuppy

I can sort-of relate. In my early PMR / high-dosage Pred days, I frequently had eye-watering calf muscle cramps at night (always the left one). Apparently not dangerous but nasty all the same. No idea about how or why, possibly something to do with the Preds? All I can say is the cramps passed as I reduced the Preds.

That said, I'm sure the forum Aunties will be along soon with their expert take on this topic.

'Uncle' MB

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy in reply tomarkbenjamin57

Thanks Mark - it was wicked scary. :-)

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

As Maisie suggests, maybe low magnesium - first thing to try if you lived here.

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy in reply toPMRpro

Thank you! :-)

Constance13 profile image
Constance13

Charley Horse??? Whatever next? Where do people get these expressions from?

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy in reply toConstance13

I'm a "Yank", so it's unique to here I guess. :-)

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane in reply toschmuppy

No there are plenty of you guys. Charlie Horse! A good expression.

Mikb profile image
Mikb in reply toschmuppy

I'm Canadian and we say it here too.

lindaoquilts profile image
lindaoquilts

I have also experienced those excruciating cramps, calves, inner thighs, feet, even shins (both at the same time). So bad, they have brought me to my knees literally, as well as tears. My solution, and I swear by it: one tablespoon of Apple cider vinegar. Count to 60, and cramp is gone. I even travel with the vinegar so I am prepared at all times. I once had to creep around the kitchen of an inn, in the middle of the night just to find the vinegar. Hope this helps. Linda

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy in reply tolindaoquilts

Thank you I will totally try that!

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

Magnesium is good for cramp. That sounds horrendous!

Calf muscle & foot arch cramp for myself. Easy to do an injury trying to unlock the spasm!

Painful indeed. Massage & copious swearing has been my poor solution! Always good to share how it is.

kay7954 profile image
kay7954

I have been plagued by horrible muscle cramps for nearly 20 years due to fibromyalgia. It did get worse when I was diagnosed with GCA/PMR. I take 400mg of magnesium with breakfast and dinner. I do not have that problem now. I hope it helps.

patriciawhite profile image
patriciawhite

I have had hip to heel cramp up ,Intense ,I ended up putting the shower on it and just running it in desperation it happened a couple of times .Its never happened again thank goodness .No idea why. I do have cramps but nothing on this scale .I did find the running warm (hottish) water helped .I left the plug in the bath .So my heels were in the warm .

Oldman-1 profile image
Oldman-1

Mmm .. wife and me both get this in varing degrees of something similar, but explain it as cramp. Treating it is a different matter. As for me, almost to a tee, this was how my version of PMA started. Couldn`t walk, anything to do with movement of the left hip/ thigh muscle was painful. Successfully treated with steriods.

Louisepenygraig profile image
Louisepenygraig

I had to read this to find out what charley horse was! I have suffered from cramps in my calves and feet so now take magnesium at night which seems to help

Knees7 profile image
Knees7

Yes I have had severe cramping since starting prednisone

stellafmdm profile image
stellafmdm

I take Magnesium at bed time along with 200mg of quinine which sorts the cramp problem for me

piglette profile image
piglette in reply tostellafmdm

Are you in U.K.? My surgery have now stopped prescribing quinine sulfate sadly, I know it is now banned in the States as well for human consumption. I found it absolutely brilliant for cramp.

stellafmdm profile image
stellafmdm in reply topiglette

Yes I'm in UK and no problems with a prescription for Quinine. If you can't get it try Tonic water which has some in and may help

piglette profile image
piglette in reply tostellafmdm

With tonic water you need to drink gallons as the amount of quinine in a bottle is so small unfortunately. The amount of quinine in tonic water has been reduced it seems. Possibly because of the recent scare about taking it. I have just read the book The Fever Tree about the history of quinine. Quite fascinating.

stellafmdm profile image
stellafmdm in reply topiglette

Thanks, must read it!

walker5 profile image
walker5

Schmuppy,

I’m a Yank, too.

I’ve had some nasty Charlie-horses and would blame dehydration or electrolyte (especially potassium) imbalance, as you thought. And I’ll look into magnesium supplements as others mentioned, but caution of getting too much. I think best to obtain thru diet (same for potassium).

Quinine is banned in the USA except for use as an antimalarial drug due to risk of serious side effects or death.

This won’t help a thigh cramp, but can prevent calf cramps. Don’t point your toes down when stretching. I only flex feet up toward shins. This also helps prevent plantar fasciitis flare-ups, if you do it frequently.

And yes, probably massage is the only way to stop an inner thigh spasm, or trying to walk it off. They are painful!

Chihuahua1 profile image
Chihuahua1 in reply towalker5

I get quinine in small amounts regularly by drinking Indian tonic water here in the UK. I also take a magnesium supplement and I have all but cured my cramps.If you don't want to risk too much magnesium orally then you can take regular baths in Epsom salts and the body will absorb what it needs from the bath water; told to me by a health food specialist

BeansHB profile image
BeansHB

Hi Schmuppy. I have not had a thigh cramp, but have had MANY other excruciating leg and foot cramps (even before being on prednisone). The things I've found to be most helpful are taking daily Calcium Magnesium supplements - the ones I take require 3 pills per day. I take two in the morning and one before going to bed. I also have a stash of "immediate release" chewable magnesium tablets by my bed, along with a bottle of Highland's Homeopathic Leg Cramp tablets. They work within 2 minutes (which still seems like an eternity). I have also tried ACV to no success. I just end up with a mouth that's puckered from the vinegar, which makes it hard to go back to sleep. Best of luck finding a good way to manage the cramping. I know it's miserable!

whitefishbay profile image
whitefishbay

I've lived in London for @ 35 years and I have not heard that expression in that long. In England we just call it leg cramp. Ha. Charley Horse is such a great term. I am only on 1 mg pred and lately in the evening I get cramps in my feet - toes stretch out funny and also my legs. Weird. I just try to walk alot every day and wear the right shoes. Magnesium is probably the answer.

SusanEleven profile image
SusanEleven

I’ve had brutal inner thigh cramps a few times in my nearly three years with pmr. The pain woke me up and was so intense it scared me. I was able to get out of bed and walk it off each time. My rheum told me to take daily magnesium.

Jayge profile image
Jayge in reply toSusanEleven

How many pills and there are several types of magnesium did your rheum advise?

SusanEleven profile image
SusanEleven in reply toJayge

Magnesium Citrate is supposed to absorb better than other forms so that’s what I use. It’s not as common on the shelves here in the US as Magnesium Oxide but I found a citrate form after poking around in a few stores. 400mg/day.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toJayge

Magnesium is magnesium - the theory is that the various salts (oxide, citrate, carbonate etc) are significant for other purposes.

Hi schmuppy. I too get really painful cramps, usually in left in calf. It doesn't go into spasms more like symptoms you have, muscle is rigid and feels like it's being stretched fit to split. It also makes my toes curl up!! I try to put leg on floor. and either push down onto toes/feet or try and stand up. It happened last night, first time in ages but I've not been taking magnesium tablets recently - took one this morning though! Didn't help I had two cats sleeping on bed at the time, one got caterpaulted off with offending leg as I tried to move it. I'm down to 10mg pred daily now and it's much better than when I was on 16mg. This pmr journey really tests us. Try the magnesium it may help you.

Blondenettie profile image
Blondenettie

The Washington Post in 1907, started that “charley horse” was used in reference to pitcher Charley “Old Hoss” Radbourne who suffered from cramps will playing in games during the 1880s. That’s where Charley horse came about.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toBlondenettie

Thanks - have always wondered!

schmuppy profile image
schmuppy

Thank you guys so, so much for all the amazing advice! I have started taking daily magnesium and potassium, remembering to drink more water, and added banana and OJ back into my daily diet. So far so good! I didn't realize the pred was leaching so much of those minerals out of my system. Bless everyone on this forum - I don't know what I'd do without you all. Healing vibes for all of us. OXOXOXO

Rimmy profile image
Rimmy

I know how 'awful' this can be. I injured my Achilles tendon a few weeks ago (better now) and around then had terrible nocturnal cramps for 2 weeks every night (3 hours on end) before they stopped. Nothing worked at the time and even the strong painkillers given by my GP didn't help - only jumping in a hot bath. I only did these nocturnal dips as the cramps lasted so long and no change of position, stretching or anything else gave any relief. Our muscles and tendons are affected by Pred - in fact it is the 'micro-architecture' which changes and being prone to cramps seems to be related to that - at least from what I have read. Supplements are unlikely to 'fix' this problem although people do talk lots about them - but that is the kind of cramping which is almost 'normal' cf with the extreme versions 'we' have had.

Best wishes

Rimmy

Msfixit profile image
Msfixit

Lemongrass oil rubbed on the offending leg is truly a miracle. Also, drinking pickle juice. I know - sounds crazy, but they both work.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Left thigh pain

I know how tempting it is to blame everything on either Prednisone or my GCA, and I suppose that's...
montebello profile image

Thigh pain

I've had PMR for 8 years and then GCA. And came off steroids because I was up and down, then I...
Healthliving profile image

Right sided Hip/thigh pain

Hi everyone Reduced my Pred by the slow method to 8 mg mid-May. Everything seemed ok for a few...
Wenben profile image

Right thigh quite severe pain

I am 4 years into PMR, on 7mg/day pred and although I've gotten to 5.5 twice on a very slow taper,...
Neck680 profile image

Severe Upper Inner Thigh Pain

I got out of bed on Thursday morning and once I started walking, my left inner upper thigh - not...

Moderation team

SophieMB profile image
SophieMBPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.