Fat vs Lean: Benefit vs Cost: I was reading this... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

132,672 members158,716 posts

Fat vs Lean: Benefit vs Cost

Rignold profile image
9 Replies

I was reading this yesterday and thought would share. The Infographic is the shortform version, the accompanying article goes into more detail.

Many of us run with weight loss as one of our goals, many of us are a tad overweight. For most of us, what we mean by that is we want to lose fat - losing lean body mass is not a desirable outcome, although a great number of restricted calorie diets achieve precisly that.

How lean is lean, however? How lean do we need to be to look a certain way? How lean does one have to be to have visble abs? What are the health benefits at the various degrees of leanness and at what point does the health scale start to tip the other way? and, equally importantly, what does it take to achieve the varying degrees of leanness? How much exercise, how much food?

Well, that is what this article and graphic address, and in a very straightforward way. I confess I was surprised by some of it. It certainly puts it all into perspective.

Hopefully will spark some interesting discussion too. See what you think:

precisionnutrition.com/cost...

precisionnutrition.com/cost...

Written by
Rignold profile image
Rignold
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
9 Replies
misswobble profile image
misswobbleGraduate

Very good.  Makes for interesting reading, in a clear way.  I was umming and aahing about which category I was in.  

Son1 profile image
Son1Graduate

That's interesting and I can feel less guilty about sleeping loads now :-)

nhs2015 profile image
nhs2015Graduate

To me 22 to 25% for a female is best but then no mention of eating carbs so really anything between 20 and 25% is a good medium. 

Rignold profile image
Rignold in reply to nhs2015

No mention of carbs = no eating of carbs. Blecch yuck carbs.

nhs2015 profile image
nhs2015Graduate in reply to Rignold

Mmmmmm, love carb 😄

Rignold profile image
Rignold in reply to nhs2015

Step away from the carbs, Ma'am.

Irishprincess profile image
IrishprincessGraduate

Mmmn very interesting reading. It all sounds simple which at the end of the day it is, but as with everything, there are always exceptions. Years ago my body fat percentage was 17% but I didn't exercise much, ate what I wanted, drank alcohol every night, blah blah. I certainly wasn't an athlete of any description! I don't know what my BFP is now, but I can still eat what I want without gaining weight and my biggest challenge since running longer distances is maintaining it. I read once that you can be slim but fat inside and that was probably me before but now I'm hoping I'm slim inside too!

Thanks for posting Rig. I might have another egg now!

Realfoodieclub profile image
RealfoodieclubGraduate

Thanks for this.  This is something I have been thinking of quite a lot recently.  I would like to go in the under 25% fat and have just begun to realise the way to get there is to watch the amount of "sweaty" cardio I do. I need to train a bit smarter not harder.  So after my HM next week there is going to be a big change in my training.  I'm looking forard to it. 

Curlygurly2 profile image
Curlygurly2Graduate

I had a DEXA scan recently, I was gobsmacked to find I have 33 % body fat, I always thought I was quite lean! They told me that I am at the lower end of normal for my gender and age. I still find it a bit horrific, I keep imagining 25 KGs of butter or lard sitting on the table, that's what is inside me!

You may also like...

Benefits!

see some data that confirms that I'm improving my health, especially in the face of physical and...

Lean Mean Running Machine

scary stuff but i ha dmy new head torch lighting the way :) A run for fun as much as anything but...

Inside every fat chap...

so ridiculous on day 1 was achievable. But 30mins? That's an awful long way off. Isn't it?

RunningForBroke vs. Treadmill

When the low is -21 degrees C (-6 degrees F) and the high is -14 degrees C (6 degrees F) you don't...

✅ W6R3; Physical and Mental Benefits

So, I've just completed W6R3. But I cant stress how slooooooooooooowly I did it🐢 🐢 🐢 I'm not...