New toys: Ooh - I like my new watch. Ran for... - Bridge to 10K

Bridge to 10K

16,527 membersβ€’26,591 posts

New toys

JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinnyGraduate10
β€’8 Replies

Ooh - I like my new watch. Ran for the first time with it today, also with trusty Runkeeper piping up out of my pocket, and my watch made my first km about 40 seconds faster than Runkeeper. My first km is very often my slowest according to Runkeeper, as was the case today. But my watch told me it was not much slower than the rest. So who to believe? Both times were good in comparison to recent performance, so I'm not really bothered - just gives me more things to play around with! What fun!πŸƒ

Written by
JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinny
Graduate10
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
8 Replies
β€’
Oldfloss profile image
OldflossAdministratorGraduate10

Believe the best result... ( like I always believe the best weather forecasts :))

Lucky you, it sound like a great new toy... I love all this running stuff! :) x

Tomas profile image
TomasGraduate10

Congratulations with the new toy. Errr, new tool! :)

The "usual" comments re watches and phones is that a GPS watch is going to be more precise because it's engineered with one sole purpose, whereas a phone is a jack of all trades, with a GPS chip thrown in almost as an afterthought.

Having said that, phones tend to make the route appear longer (because as the GPS isn't as precise, it seems that you're criss crossing a lot more), so I would not have been surprised at all if you had told that the phone announced the first km sooner than the watch. But the other way around is a bit strange.

Are you ensuring that both devices have a firm satellite lock before setting off?

JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinnyGraduate10β€’ in reply toTomas

Garmin had GPS before I even left the house. Runkeeper zooms in on a map and I only start when I'm correctly localized. I'll keep my eye on things, might just be a one-off - Runkeeper once had me running at 4:30 / km, which was plain WRONG, so I know these things sometimes go harewire!

davelinks profile image
davelinksGraduate10

I would go with the Garmin.. and don't fall over while looking at it JaySee!πŸ˜‰

Accuracy

The problem with smartphones is that they sacrifice in certain areas to make room for everything else. A phone camera will never produce images as high-quality as an SLR.

So it is for smartphone GPS sensors. While these vary from phone to phone, the sensors are usually substandard compared to GPS watches. This means they are less accurate in terms of recording your speed and distance. This accuracy issue is less apparent when it’s averaged out over longer distances (like driving in a car). But when running, especially shorter distances, it can be glaring.😊

JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinnyGraduate10β€’ in reply todavelinks

I fall over with or without a watch, Dave. It's those damned rocks and roots!

davelinks profile image
davelinksGraduate10β€’ in reply toJaySeeSkinny

Yes, I know! I've nearly come a cropper on tree roots & pot holes. I hate to hear of people taking tumbles. Poor MW had a smack in the mouth when she fell and a friend of mine tripped over a tree route coming downhill and got a smack in the mouth!πŸ˜”

misswobble profile image
misswobbleGraduate10

ooooh lovely! A new watch! You will have all those stats to play with. I am not very good at stats , or owt else really. Sad to say. LOL

I did have my new phone to play with today though on my run. So busy faffing with the darned thing I forgot to run. It didn't go well

Your first k should be slower! You need to warm up before plunging headlong into a run

JaySeeSkinny profile image
JaySeeSkinnyGraduate10β€’ in reply tomisswobble

That's what the warm up walk is for! My first k is always phenomenally slow. Well so far anyway.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

10k run #8 : felt slow - measured fast

Whilst hubby is protesting for better climate policies up in Glasgow, I and sonny was left behind...
CBDB profile image
Graduate10β€’

New Toys announced!!!

Hello, your friendly techie runner is pleased to notify you of a whole new set of toys... Christmas...
MarkyD profile image
Graduate10β€’

New 10km training plan

I have been using Runkeeper (basic version) for a while now - since my Garmin watch decided to stop...
skysue16 profile image
Graduate10β€’

CR9 - Jeffing works?

Hiya, Today I went for the Jeffing ratio 90:30 and I have to admit, apparently Jeffing works! The...
β€’

First HRT run with new Garmin Forerunner 55

Last week, I (finally!) got my Garmin Forerunner 55 primarily to do heart rate training (I had...
ChannelRunner2 profile image
Graduate10β€’

Moderation team

See all
Annieapple profile image
AnnieappleAdministrator
Yesletsgo profile image
YesletsgoAdministrator
MissUnderstanding profile image
MissUnderstandingAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.