Beware of misdiagnosis! My story... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,325 members66,957 posts

Beware of misdiagnosis! My story...

dgreen88 profile image
22 Replies

Hello. I am writing this because I suspect that what happened to me might well be happening to others. Please read...

Roughly 18 months ago I ended up in hospital with a severe exacerbation - the first in my life at age 57. I had always been an extremely strong and fit dancer, despite smoking off and on, but had quit that habit some time before. When the consultant at Hereford Hospital heard I'd been a smoker he quickly declared "copd" after spending what seemed like 30 seconds with me. Voila. I had copd! Or did I? From the start I was unconvinced. Read on!

Every copd inhaler they had me try made me sicker and the only thing that really relieved symptoms was prednisone. I was in and out of hospital 5 times last year. Finally my diagnosis was adjusted to asthma/copd (ACOS) and I was discharged with ventolin and high dose Fostair inhalers. I'd been living in a damp cottage and moved to a new house and area but continued to deteriorate, managing to stay away from A & E only by taking prednisone for 3 - 5 days every few weeks. This would help for a fortnight or so and then I'd quickly decline again, the dreaded sputum returning that demanded I spend exhausting sessions trying to clear it, most days bringing up about a bowl of the stuff. By now I'd had to stop teaching dance months before, could barely walk, take a shower, dress, or get out of bed without taking several doses of ventolin... Add to this some horrible steroid side effects and you get the picture. I would go to the GP in desperation most weeks, oxygen levels usually down to 90, peak flow at 100 or so. I felt that life as I knew it was over. I was an invalid with a bleak, and probably short, future ahead.

Then one day about 6 or 7 weeks ago I read something on here about eosinophilic asthma. I'd never heard of it, googled to find out more and then looked at my blood test results from the past months. All my eosinophil counts were high, except once when I'd been tested while on steroids. I googled some more... Were my initial doubts about the copd diagnosis correct after all?

By now the GP was so concerned at my terrible state that I was referred to see a consultant at a different hospital in my new area and an appointment came up quickly. I went along armed with my blood tests and research, all ready to do battle with the consultant, but he took one look at my blood tests and said "I see - you have eosinophilic asthma." OMG!!!! He concluded that I did / do not have active copd, prescribed a medication I'd never heard of called Montelukast, and said he'd see me again in 6 weeks.

I started on the Montelukast that evening, just over 3 weeks ago and well over a month since my last prednisone course. The effect was immediate and magical. Suddenly I could breathe again! Daily sputum production went down to a teaspoon. I can walk briskly up pretty steep hills and today did an hour's ballet class without getting out of breath. I've also gradually reduced my Fostair 200/6 from 4 puffs to only 2 puffs a day and haven't touched the ventolin inhaler since I started on the Montelukast.

It's a total transformation. People around me are also amazed - and shocked that I went through such suffering for 18 months only to find that a simple rereading of my case and change in meds could do this. I am of course thrilled but also angry that in all this time no one had, it seems, bothered to look at my blood tests properly or considered a different diagnosis or options. I'm very concerned that this not happen to others. If you also wonder about your diagnosis, please read up on eosinophilic asthma and how it is frequently mistaken for copd, get print outs of your blood tests, and get a second opinion.

In the meantime, thank you to the person who posted about eosinophilic asthma on here!! I'll try to refind that post and thank them directly.

Written by
dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
MELNEL profile image
MELNEL

This really is an interesting story! Thanks for sharing 🌼🌹🌼🌹 happy for you that you have researched and that you can dance again!! 💃💃

Roessner541 profile image
Roessner541

Just curious what your dosage is?my lung doctor prescribed it for me but said it was for allergies. Beginning to lose faith in doctors. A friend of my son's did a test on me with a machine he has for essential oils and he told my son he doesn't think I have COPD.

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88 in reply toRoessner541

It's 10mg. Maybe ask if you can try it, but there's others too. Just don't let them trap you in the wrong diagnosis.

sassy59 profile image
sassy59

Now that’s what you call a result albeit after a dreadful 18 months. Thank goodness your GP referred you to a good consultant.

I wish you continuing good health and thank you for an excellent post. Xxxx

katieoxo60 profile image
katieoxo60

Hi dgreen88, glad to hear you got a confirmed diagnosis and the drugs work. Your life should be much better in future with the correct treatment. Another illness that can mimic COPD is Idopathic pulmonary disease so you were right to investigate your symptoms. Best wishes to you.

Caspiana profile image
Caspiana

Hello dgreen88 .

I am so sorry to read how dreadfully bad your experience was but at the same time so very happy that you are now on the right course of treatment and feeling so very much better. Three cheers for you. All the best for your continued improvement.

Kind regards to you.

Cas xx 💐

Offcut profile image
Offcut

Well done, It does seem that they did not re look at your blood tests when it was not working in the first place?

Glad you are getting on so well now.

Be Well

O2Trees profile image
O2Trees

Crikey - words fail . . . But very happy for you now.

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88

Thank you!

spooks36 profile image
spooks36

Hello 88, glad to read that something is positive now for you. hope it continues. cheers.

Justdoit2015 profile image
Justdoit2015

Good to news, unfortunately a lot of GPs in the UK just go...smoking history = COPD here are some inhalers. I am happy you are getting the help you need.

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88 in reply toJustdoit2015

These weren't just GPs though - they were respiratory consultants considered to be excellent. But they were also rather arrogant. I am going to bring them to account somehow so that they don't do the same to others.

Lilian226 profile image
Lilian226

So pleased there was a good ending to this awful story. Lilian xxxxx

dilly20 profile image
dilly20

im so glad you have been sorted at last i wish you well xx

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88

Thanks again to everyone for their kind wishes.

Beth1949 profile image
Beth1949

What a amazing story. It's another example of relying on the doctor to correctly diagnose. Fortunately, it only affected you for 18 months. Some people are disdiagnosed for years and years.

I've learn to question my doctor and be more proactive. Beth

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88

These weren't GP's but first one and then a second hospital respiratory consultant that misdiagnosed while I was in and out of there like a yoyo over the course of some months. I contested the diagnosis quite vigorously but they treated me like I was being difficult and insisted on their conclusions. I don't know what else I could have done other than ask to see a 3rd consultant and until a few weeks ago I didn't have the info about eosinophilic asthma to put forward. Meanwhile I must have seen a dozen different GPs and respiratory nurses over this 1.5 years but not one questioned the diagnosis even though I talked of my doubts.

Shellc profile image
Shellc

Can I ask what do we look for in blood results . It also annoys me when docs say copd , which is unbrella term for emphysema, bronchitis, I have bronchiectasis which docs frequently call copd , it as finally isn't , so my consultant tells me , I also have asthma ? As in allergies which make my breathing worse

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88

look for the eosinophil count and then to the right you'll see what the normal range should be for whichever lab did the results.

Dedalus profile image
Dedalus in reply todgreen88

Thank you for your post - is the eosinophil count done in everyday blood tests, or do we need to specially request it?

dgreen88 profile image
dgreen88

Yes, it should be part of any standard full blood test.

Dedalus profile image
Dedalus in reply todgreen88

Thank you

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Phyllocontin my story

Hi Jim here, Basically I’m 50 and was on Phyllocontin from about 10 years old and my asthma was...

Newly diagnosed - my story

Hi, I'm now 48 and recently diagnosed with COPD I'd been unwell in December 2019 with flu like...
Breathe-73 profile image

Hi

Hi all I'm new on here, adult onset asthma since December 2015 and a nightmare to control (...
Lyngal profile image

Copd diagnosis 5 years ago now diagnosed with asthma as well

Hi everybody, just reaching out to see if anyone has any information that may be of help to me. I...
Happy321 profile image

Got my PR Assessment date!!

Got my assessement date today!! Have to go next week for first assessment, then officially on the...
marytaz profile image

Moderation team

See all
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator
Claire_ALUK profile image
Claire_ALUKAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.