Why are people still using the BMI? - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,083 members61,310 posts

Why are people still using the BMI?

Jefflindholm profile image
1 Reply

I see a lot of posts in which people talk about their BMI. Why do people still use it? No one takes it seriously. Think about this: if a muscular football player and his sedentary, alcoholic grandmother were both the same height, they would have the same BMI! It tells us nothing of value.

I have lost about 50 KG and I have about 10 more to lose. The BMI tells me to lose another 40. That would put me in the hospital. I use weightzone.com because it gave me much better advice than the BMI. It tells me to lose between 9 KG and 14KG, which makes sense.

Written by
Jefflindholm profile image
Jefflindholm
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
1 Reply
fibronfedup profile image
fibronfedup

Link doesn't work

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

How accurate is the BMI ?

I think many factors have to be taken into consideration when a system like the BMI measures a...

End of the 12 weeks, BMI down from 29 to 25.7 :)

I've completed the 12 week plan, and as with many on here, I will keep going with week 13, 14, 15...

Question about the NHS BMI calculator

Hi all, I'm sure someone will know the answer to this, When you put in your height, weight, and...
Fran182716 profile image

The longest journey starts with the first step!

Weighed in at 106 kg today so really need to tackle weight issue as classed as obese - BMI...

What's the "Healthy BMI" badge for?

I got this badge last week (happily gone now), and I just saw @[1274895] turning it down. I don't...

Moderation team

See all
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.