You have my sympathy—my GP also isn’t happy about me taking NDT, however, we now have a note on my record that says “patient has capacity to make her own decisions about care”. That was after I put him straight on quite a few misconceptions he held:
It’s unregulated and you don’t know what’s in it—no, it’s not, Armour is made by a proper pharmaceutical company and they have to conform to normal standards.
Your TSH says you’re on too much—no, FT4 and FT3 show that’s not the case, my TSH has been suppressed for years because of the T3 and reducing my dose has little to no effect on that
You’ll develop goggly eyes if you take too much—no, pretty sure I won’t (I don’t have autoimmune thyroiditis. And secondly, after a decade of being on NDT, I think that would have happened already if it was going to!).
I think he still believes he’s right but he ran out of arguments, not least because when I asked for evidence of what he said he couldn’t actually provide any.
Anyway…
If you left it 24 hours before testing your FT3 is actually higher than it appears. We tend to recommend splitting the NDT dosage into 2 before testing—half in the morning, half 12 hours before the test—to get a better picture of FT3 levels.
How do you feel? That’s the important thing right now. Do you feel over-replaced? Just a note of caution that you might feel fine for now (I did for quite a while with similar levels) but you may find eventually that you develop symptoms of over medication (in my case palpitations). It might be worth experimenting with reducing just a smidge—say a quarter grain—to see how that feels.
H , I am on 2 and quarter a day . I feel really good in myself . I’ve even come off antidepressants as a consequence of being on NDT and feeling better - I do not take any thyroxine .
I tried dropping the half a dose but I felt the symptoms coming back . Would you suggest me dropping to two and a half one day , then two the next ? Many thanks x
Pleased to see you have dropped your dose from 7 months ago when I last replied and glad you are still feeling good and managed to drop the anti depressants.
You need a consistent dose with NDT - so no you can't chop and change dose on a daily basis.
Is this dose split ?
If this was 24 hours from last - I'd suggest you maybe slightly over medicated -
and dose adjustments are by 1/4 grains - not halves.
If these are blood tests were at 12 hours from last dose I wouldn't be saying reduce -
but if this is after 24 hours your T3 would have been running much higher at the 12 hour interval and very over range -
Are you experiencing any symptoms ?
Have your tried monitoring yourself on blood pressure, pulse and body temperature - as that helped me when I started self medicating some years ago now ?
I found one dose works best for me that I take at a toilet break in the middle of the night so to dovetail in with circadian rhythm of the body.
My blood pressure and pulse remained stable but I found my temperature tracked up from 35.4 to 36.6 where it tends to hover most days 6 years on.
I find it strange that you had no symptoms of over medication when taking 3 + 1/2 grains and felt no different now at 2 + 1/2 grains - or have I got it wrong ?
Just wondering if you went up in 1/2 grains you could have ' missed ' your best dose - as it's advised to increase in 1/4 grains - I went up weekly - others suggest fortnightly -
The Levothyroxinne would have taken around 6=8 weeks to fully leave your body and in that time frame you slowly build up the NDT in 1/4 grains.
There should come a week when you feel just a little bit different - not 'as well ' -
I became edgey and just uncomfortable in my skin -
so you then just drop down to the previous dose - stay on that lower dose 6-8 weeks and then run a blood test - as this is likely your best dose on NDT at this particular time.
You compare this blood test to your bench mark readings -
likely your TSH is now suppressed with your T3 much higher and a T4 possibly much lower in the range to when taking synthetic T4. and this is ok - with hopefully relief from the symptoms which is, after all, the aim of any medication - relief of symptoms.
If you get to 2 grains you stay on this dose for 6-8 weeks and then run a blood test - if symptoms haven't resolved and your T3 not moved much maybe NDT is not the best treatment option for you.
If T3 is moving and you are feeling improved but not quite ' there ' - start again slowly increasing by 1/4 grains until you feel you've gone a bit backwards - as then you need to drop back down as you may have missed your ' best ' dose option.
either way your TSH will be suppressed and your T3 / T4 will not present similar as to when taking synthetics so your doctor will likely be out of his depth,confused and say something stupid and put the onus back on to you.
Hi , I am currently taking 2 and a quarter split into 2 doses a day . It taken me nearly a year to get to where i thought my sweet spot is . ( yes I was definitely over doing it on 3 plus grains looking back )
I am now going to try and drop the quarter and see how I go . Unfortunately I do feel okay on that dose ,
Yes - I understand it can be a very fine line - but you have the power and can do this fine tuning yourself -
though as you also have Hashimoto's to contend with it's likely much harder than for someone like me - without a thyroid - as I haven't any other reason to question my dose -
as I haven't a thyroid misbehaving and giving me a irregular supplies of thyroid hormones - and you'll likely feel better once your thyroid ' stops ' trying altogether - which may of course be around now since you are feeling better with a full spectrum thyroid hormone replacement option.
With NDT its very much about feeling well - I self medicate and haven't seen a doctor for over 7 years now - as I am well - and am not going to put myself back in a firing line for having a TSH at 0.01 -
There are no guidelines specifically for Graves post RAI thyroid so now I've made my own - and considering the latest research - QOL 6-10 years post RAI - why not and why is this toxic substance still a first line treatment and described as a ' therapy ' in what we presume a health care setting ?
I hope you don’t mind me reaching out again. This is now my third day of cutting a quarter out of my daily dose . I feel symptoms have come back ( horse throat, aches and pains etc ) Will this subside over the next few days ? Should I hold on in there until i hopefully wil level out ? Thanks
So this is just day 3 of having dropped your dose by 1/4 grain :
I think I would stay put and see out a week on the lower dose - if your symptoms don't improve - you can always go back up and see if these symptoms were from dropping the dose a little.
It's more about fine tuning now - it could be a coincidence - we don't know yet - your dose looked a bit high to me - but if it needs to there to alleviate symptoms - so be it - listen to your body as you are now in the driving seat.
Are you getting NDT via NHS? If not then frankly its not really any of your GP's business, we are adults with autonomy and can make our own decisions regarding what we put in our bodies.
If you aren't beholden to the NHS for your NDT and you aren't getting any Levo prescriptions then he can be as unhappy as he pleases, but you aren't there to keep him happy. It sounds as though you are doing well on NDT and that's the important thing.
I would maybe tell a white lie, say your private prescriber is happy with your results( even if they are imaginary). If a GP thinks you are under another medical professional that might get him off your back.
Or as you say opt out of NHS thyroid testing. You dont need it, its not required unless you get NHS thyroid meds. If its causing stress then just tell him you are looking after your own thyroid health from now on.
That's great to hear you're well on thyroid. If it was me I'd give the GP the results and tell them you're feeling well on the NDT so they have a record of it. It's a waste doing the TSH test, as T3 suppresses it. It seems crazy that the NHS don't know this, my NHS Endochrinologist says she only goes by TSH and not symptoms even when she was giving me a little T3. My GP recently told me I'll never get better and that she could no longer help me and told me to go private. I've just gone private and started on Armour.
At least your GP was honest and realised you werent going to regain your health on the NHS treatment regime. But not everyone can afford to go private, its a big assumption on her part, and it does make you wonder what our taxes are being used for.
Its a sad indictment on the NHS that more and more of us are having to turn to private medicine just to get basic care. And its also leading to a two tier system where those who can afford it are going private, and those who cant are becoming more unwell.
It is awful how people are kept unwell . Fortunately I bit the bullet and self medicated with the help of this forum and another I use . I wouldn’t have been able to have done it it without the great advice.
Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.
Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.