Confused about the different types of magnesium... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,246 members166,486 posts

Confused about the different types of magnesium, and which one is the most easily absorbed. Can anyone help please?

16 Replies
Read more about...
16 Replies
humanbean profile image
humanbean

Magnesium oxide is in lots of multivitamin pills, and it really is a waste of time. I read once that only 4% of it is absorbed.

The ones I've read about that are more easily absorbed are magnesium citrate (take it at night - it allegedly helps people to relax), and magnesium oil. The oil is applied to the skin and rubbed in, not swallowed. If you are magnesium deficient then the oil can cause slight itching or a prickly feeling, but it should wear off once deficiency reduces.

Magnesium oil can be made very cheaply - google it - or bought ready-made.

in reply tohumanbean

Many thanks for this - really helpful

S

PinkNinja profile image
PinkNinja in reply tohumanbean

Totally agree.

I take magnesium citrate, 400mg twice a day.

You can also put Epsom salts in a bath and you will absorb the magnesium through the skin. Great for sore muscles or aches and pains. You can get it from some chemist shops.

Carolyn x

in reply toPinkNinja

Thanks Carolyn - a couple more questions. Why do you take so much? I read that the daily dose for women was 300mg. How much epsom salts do you use and how long do you have to stay in the bath?

Thanks

Sue

PinkNinja profile image
PinkNinja in reply to

My magnesium supplement actually recommends that dose. I did read somewhere that that's how much I should be taking. It's a good idea to start on a smaller dose though for a couple of days. Everyone is different and that's the dose that seems to suit me :)

In not sure about the dosage for Epsom salt baths. I haven't had one for years. Perhaps I should start again.

Carolyn x

silverfox7 profile image
silverfox7

I joined the magnesium group and asked what best to take as people on there take large doses of what I can only describe as a cocktail! I bought the oxide before a read it doesn't absorb much but I've continues in the absence of anything else but I am intending to get some citrate. I was also concerned about over dosing but am told too much -diarrhoea though to be cautious with that at first as it can just be your body getting used to it so with anything that could have this affect start small, alternate days may be to check if a problem why.

PinkNinja profile image
PinkNinja in reply tosilverfox7

You're more likely to get diarrhoea with the oxide. It's caused by the unabsorbed magnesium so taking a more easily absorbed form should carry a lower risk. You are wise to start slowly though.

Enzovince profile image
Enzovince in reply toPinkNinja

Hi according to Dr. Mercola the best form of Magnesium is Liquid Nano Ionic form...

For those of you in the UK or Europe i have used this site to get Nano Ionic Magnesium - 60ml..

visit the thehealthcorner.co.uk

I would say 95% of the Western Population is low in Magnesium

Magnesium: A Mighty Mineral Indeed! Muscle contraction, glucose metabolism, electrical impulses of the heart, bone formation all rely on this mighty mineral to get the job done! If truth be told, the human body cannot function normally without magnesium.

great stufff

Yana profile image
Yana

This might help.

articles.mercola.com/sites/...

Mrs_Somerset profile image
Mrs_Somerset

I do love this site - thank-you for asking the question Sue-F!

I have been taking Magnesium for a while, I did not even realise that there were different types of food suppliment Magnesium - DOH

I have been taking 300mg Magnesium for about 3 years now, just looked and it is Magnesium Oxide - will now find some citrate and give it a go.

Thanks again guys, really useful info here :-)

Jackie profile image
Jackie

Hi Multi vit and minerals, the best, are a good idea, any way, especially the minerals, compare them for the best.

I have to have magnesium oxide on a script, under renal and cardiac specialists. As I have that, the only one really absorbed, then I have to have weekly tests, just for the magnesium and U`s and E`s because it affects the Potassium, it must kidney bloods. This is because magnesium and potassium ( also calcium and sodium) are electrolytes and must always be in range. ,magnesium is a tiny range, so easily out.

I hope that helps.

Jackie

Thanks everyone for the very helpful replies. I think I know where to start now.

Sue

belwom profile image
belwom

I would say a handful of Epsom salts in the bath if taken regularly. To combat a cold, my homeopath actually advised to put in a whole pound in a half-filled bath. I would find that rather a lot so do not tend to use that quantity. Epsom salts in the bath is also good against sore joints and muscles. I use the magnesium oil at bedtime, as I like not having to take yet another tablet/capsule.

Marz profile image
Marz

I take liquid magnesium that comes in a glass phial - magnesium Pidolate - by Galenica. Must do some research ! Each phial contains 10ml and I take it in water.

Enzovince profile image
Enzovince

Hi according to Dr. Mercola the best form of Magnesium is Liquid Nano Ionic form...

For those of you in the UK or Europe i have used this site to get Nano Ionic Magnesium - 60ml..

visit the thehealthcorner.co.uk

I would say 95% of the Western Population is low in Magnesium

Magnesium: A Mighty Mineral Indeed! Muscle contraction, glucose metabolism, electrical impulses of the heart, bone formation all rely on this mighty mineral to get the job done! If truth be told, the human body cannot function normally without magnesium.

great stufff

in reply toEnzovince

Thank you.

Sue

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Very Confused! Can Anyone Help Please?

I got the results back for my thyroid test and 24 hour urine Metanephrine test and I’m really...
Trip2020 profile image

confused, different opinions, and intermittent symptoms. Help please.

should I take vitamin D with kidney calcifications and stage 3 renal failure, endo said yes???? Gp...
merissa profile image

Vitamin B12 ... Which is the best one please?

Hi, I'm ordering my next loads of vitamins from Amazon so that I have a good stock and don't have...
Tinx71 profile image

Confused and Worried about Recent Bloods - Help Please.

1) Bloods done in March '16: TSH 3.15 / FT3 4.1 pmol/L (3.9 - 6.7) / FT4 13.4 pmol/L (12 - 22)....
Rainbow100 profile image

About B12 and the use of supplements - help please as I am very confused.

I recently asked a question about testing for B12 if you take a supplement. The answers seemed to...
SnowdropB profile image