PMR mentioned on TV: Hi. I was flicking channels... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

21,229 members40,249 posts

PMR mentioned on TV

Animalover65 profile image
68 Replies

Hi. I was flicking channels last night and clicked onto "doctors behind closed doors".

A mentally sharp 91 year old lady was describing pains in her arms which prevented her moving them above a certain point. The nurse or doctor said there is something called Polymyalgia we can do some tests to see if you need medication for it.

I settled down excitedly to wait for the outcomes at the end of the prog. And they went through the different people and then said the lady had been prescribed steroids to help with her chronic pain. I felt a sense of being underwhelmed that the condition was not mentioned clearly at the end of the programme! Did any one else see it.?

Written by
Animalover65 profile image
Animalover65
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
68 Replies
Kendrew profile image
Kendrew

Hi there,

Yes, I saw it too.

It was rather underwhelming.... but then a program like that doesn't really have the scope or time to give something like PMR the coverage it probably deserves. Everything is quite 'fleeting'.

Wouldn't it be lovely to have a whole program that was dedicated to documenting up to date & realistic information & explanations of everything PMR/GCA related though. Imagine that!!

Animalover65 profile image
Animalover65 in reply toKendrew

Hi Kendrew,

That is what I was thinking, topics can only be touched on briefly.

I was just laughing to myself as was getting excited at the thought of what would be mentioned at the end of the programme and it was blink and you would miss it! But at least it was mentioned.

123-go profile image
123-go in reply toKendrew

It would have to be serialised to cover everything 😁. Many of us would be in remission by the final episode. Wouldn’t it be something if PMR/GCA were fleeting.

I mustn’t be too cynical; perhaps this mention is the start of something useful?

I hope everyone enjoyed the early morning sunshine.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to123-go

Och - it gets a mention every so often - both PMR and GCA have starred in Doc Martin but in a very ineffective and dismissive way since he did the biopsy on the kitchen table and a dose or two of pred had Aunty back to normal ...

Kendrew profile image
Kendrew in reply toPMRpro

Yes!!... I remember that episode. It was dismissed so lightly wasn't it.... it was all dealt with in the same way he'd have advised some paracetamol for a high temperature...... "Here! Take these. Problem solved"!!They'd be better not incorporating conditions like PMR/GCA in these medical dramas if they can't portray them authentically and realistically. Just perpetuates the 'myths' around them.

in reply toPMRpro

🤣🤣🤣

autumnlass profile image
autumnlass in reply toPMRpro

How demeaning and and simplistic to see PMR/GCA in that light. Shame on the directors of DM. 🙄

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toautumnlass

The point is, it’s not it’s not billed as a serious medical programme -it’s billed as an entertainment series with a few medical issues thrown in because the main character happens to be a doctor. I’m sure many watch it for the scenery and lighthearted banter between the major prayers, not to be medically informed. For that, they’d go to a factual medical programme - plenty of them around.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toDorsetLady

It doesn't alter the fact that people will remember that portrayal and wonder why the patient claims they can't do this that or the other.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toPMRpro

Therein lies the problem -too many people believe what they see on TV .

123-go profile image
123-go in reply toDorsetLady

…and in other types of media. 🙄

Suffererc profile image
Suffererc in reply toPMRpro

mite be worth tryin with GPs and asking why we aren’t cured as quickly. There answer would be you enjoy being on steroids 🤣😂

Kendrew profile image
Kendrew in reply toPMRpro

Fair point too.

autumnlass profile image
autumnlass in reply toDorsetLady

Yes very true. My late husband was a GP - I think it would have made him laugh at how lightweight it was! The scenery and the lighthearted banter is quite compelling though - 🤣

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply toautumnlass

My mother was a consultant in Holloway Prison. For those who remember, she was obsessed with Within These Walls with Googie Withers who was the prison governor, and always said there must be someone in there telling them plot lines as she could relate to a lot of them.

Kendrew profile image
Kendrew in reply toSophiestree

I used to love that series!

Kendrew profile image
Kendrew in reply toDorsetLady

Fair point.

diana1998 profile image
diana1998 in reply toautumnlass

I was appalled

diana1998 profile image
diana1998 in reply toPMRpro

Yes, I remember that and thought, this is all very inaccurate with lucky Aunty Ruth right as rain after her steroid dose and then never referred to again.

Suffererc profile image
Suffererc in reply toPMRpro

😂🤣😂🤣😂 that’s what happens isn’t it 😂🤣😂

Pr0jection profile image
Pr0jection in reply toPMRpro

Ha ha, I saw that and thought....if only it were that simple!

Doraflora profile image
Doraflora in reply toPMRpro

oh, I never saw that episode and I’ve watched and rewatched them so often. I love that prog! Mind you, I would clash with Martin if he was my GP🤣

christi48 profile image
christi48 in reply to123-go

It would be great if it piqued listeners' interest and they wrote in asking for more information!

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply tochristi48

Not sure about Doc Martin, as it’s was produced by ITV , but many BBC programmes do have a telephone no to call if people want extra info about what been in the programme.

Shaza123 profile image
Shaza123 in reply toKendrew

yes that would be great but alas it may never happen

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

We definitely need a higher profile, if only for some medics.

Animalover65 profile image
Animalover65 in reply toSheffieldJane

Yes definately! Something like that would be a godsend !

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

I remember snorting - but I did give the doctor brownie points for mentioning it!!

I can't remember - which practice was it? When it was centred on the Bradford practice they tended to have the same patients with chronic conditions appear regularly so you saw how that plays out in a GP practice. The Birmingham practice does it a bit too.

Animalover65 profile image
Animalover65 in reply toPMRpro

LOL yes I suppose a mention is better than nothing!

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toAnimalover65

Might have got more coverage if it had been a male in his 50s rather than a female in her 90s🤔

Charlie1boy profile image
Charlie1boy in reply toDorsetLady

Woops! That sounds like my other half talking!😆

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toCharlie1boy

True though - obviously not aimed at anyone on here -but TV (and maybe life) in general..

..although some of us females don’t take kindly to it 😳

Charlie1boy profile image
Charlie1boy in reply toDorsetLady

yes, my wife would agree with you 100%. 😊

123-go profile image
123-go in reply toCharlie1boy

Good for her 😁.

Animalover65 profile image
Animalover65 in reply toDorsetLady

Absolutely right!

in reply toDorsetLady

I thought that!

musicality profile image
musicality in reply toDorsetLady

Menopause only talked about so much these days because celebs and high profile people have now experienced it. In another 10 years or before, PMR/GCA will be talked about and brought to the forefront much more than our generation has, as the now 40s + generation experience it themselves. I also think they will not be fobbed off with long term harmful steroids, when there are newer, safer drugs.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply tomusicality

" long term harmful steroids, when there are newer, safer drugs."

Except there aren't really ...

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply tomusicality

You have more faith in the 40 year olds than I do - and menopause affects a lot more people than PMR/GCA…

Ambientman profile image
Ambientman

No,I never see it,but I hate the way they keep repeating the stories and have to wait till the end to see outcomes..Not enough publicity on Gca PMR that's for sure.

Exhiker profile image
Exhiker

Yes I saw it, I think they said that she had a course of steroids and that was it. I was a bit disappointed at the end.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toExhiker

And they just classed it as "chronic pain"

Exhiker profile image
Exhiker in reply toPMRpro

Very disappointing. Talk about down playing it!

Everett19 profile image
Everett19

I was watching with my daughter and when lady started describing her symptoms I immediately said PMR! It would have been good if Dr had explained it a bit more fully but they only have an hour for whole programme so no chance.It would be great if there was a medical programme about PMR to make people more aware.

Penny9 profile image
Penny9

I suppose it will depend how long they were filming and whether the lady had been discharged to home to start her steroid treatment. I doubt they would have followed up on progress. It would have been interesting to find out how she was doing.

456again profile image
456again

There is a two-page write up ln PMR in this months Saga magazine. I was surprised when I started flicking through and it jumped out at me.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to456again

Somebody else mentioned that on a zoom meeting recently. Do you know if it’s available free online?

Nextoneplease profile image
Nextoneplease in reply toDorsetLady

This?

saga.co.uk/magazine/health-...

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toNextoneplease

I found that, and an older one about Kate Gilbert …but it doesn’t bring up recent copies…guess that’s because there is a subscription for currents ones….

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toDorsetLady

Wouldn't be so bad if it was accurate. "PMR strikes the over-50s exclusively"

Prof Sarah Mackie would dispute that ...

And the usual rubbish about "15 mins in the sun" for vit D

456again profile image
456again in reply toDorsetLady

I could scan it and post

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to456again

Worth try if you don’t mind -but not sure if HU will allow -they are a bit funny about what you can attach. Photos are okay -but not sure about scanned files -probably depends what your computer saves it as…

Don’t spend a lot of time and effort on it😊

456again profile image
456again in reply toDorsetLady

I did scan and send but think, as you sat, it’s been taken down.

Lclmlbls profile image
Lclmlbls in reply to456again

My friend sent the article to me - it was quite informative and makes people of a certain age aware of the condition. Although I don’t think anyone understands it until they have it.

AuthorJ profile image
AuthorJ in reply to456again

hi. I just read the online article. She was lucky to have recovered in only three years. May we all be so lucky!

Louisa1840 profile image
Louisa1840

When you Google PMR it comes over as such a lightweight condition. I love it when Dorset Lady describes it as "a serious debilitating illness" but I think that the general profile it has is much less dire. Of course there are those who have only had it for 18 months and they get rid of it (lucky them) and then there's the rest of us who are still struggling after many years. it's such an individual illness.

HalleysComet profile image
HalleysComet in reply toLouisa1840

and wouldn’t it be good to know that one could apply for a blue badge so that walking a long way to and from shops was reduced.

If anyone on the forum has succeeded it would be good to know how to get through the system.

Nextoneplease profile image
Nextoneplease in reply toHalleysComet

Yes! A blue badge would be so helpful (sometimes I don’t set out, for fear of not having the stamina to get back!) Yet as I understand it, most of us wouldn’t qualify under current rules…..😟

Richmond162 profile image
Richmond162

hi. Yes I too watched it and was disappointed. But she was good for her age!

Hosers2 profile image
Hosers2

What bothers me is that there doesn’t seem to be a serious study in the past ten years about PMR. No investigations as to possible causes, prevention, cures, etc. PMR gets lumped in with Fibromyalgia quite often because of the similarities in the name. But they are definitely not even remotely related (in my opinion).

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toHosers2

Have you searched for recent studies online?

here are just a couple - found in seconds -

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi...

news-medical.net/news/20191...

Hosers2 profile image
Hosers2 in reply toDorsetLady

Thanks for the links. I read both, beginning to end. Neither showed any investigations as to the possible causes or prevention of PMR, which was my original comment. Both had treatment suggestions, all of which has been known and practiced in the past fifteen years.

The second article has a map showing the incidence of PMR by country. North America and Europe show huge difference than the rest of the world. Mexico has an almost zero incidence of PMR cases.

As you probably know from following my comments, I have always suggested that the cause of PMR might be from our overprescribed and extensive use of statins.

bmjopen.bmj.com/content/12/...

“In 2020, statin utilisation was highest in North America and Europe (279.7 and 159.9 DDDs/TPD, respectively) and substantially lower in Latin America, MENA, East Asia, South Asia and sub-Saharan Africa (66.1, 64.1, 29.3, 16.1 and 24.7 DDD/TPD, respectively).”

If you completely read this article, you will realize it is a study in how to increase the availability and use of statins in third world countries. Another promotion by the Pharmaceutical industry to increase sales.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toHosers2

The same applies to causes of PMR as to any other autoimmune disorder - and the research there applies as much to PMR as to RA, lupus or anything else. I suspect you don't really gey what would be involved in such an undertaking and the cost of such work. That is basic research - and the money isn't available for a relatively easy to manage disorder that is perceived as usually self-limiting that only affects the older generation. It isn't cute and cuddly like babies and doesn/t have massive economic effects. When you win the euromillions or the US equivalent you could fund it ...

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toHosers2

PMRpro has replied in similar to what I would have said... but no, "they" don't know what causes PMR - apart from being of Scandinavian descent {Vikings got to parts of UK -and via their descendants to N. America and Australasia- and Eastern Mediterranean - but not Asia, Africa, South America], environment and genetics.

PMR has been around for over a hundred years [one of the first cases in 1888 by Bruce, another in 1890 by Hutchinson] [albeit maybe not recognised as such nor recorded correctly in significant numbers - ] - long before statins..

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply toHosers2

Plenty of serious studies about PMR but they don't have a lot to do with public perception either. A lot of relevant research is not directly PMR but immunology in general. But in case you hadn't noticed, the last 3 years have been preoccupied with Covid - which also interfered with recruitment for PMR studies that were ongoing. A study takes 5 years and usually more from beginning to end - and a lot of that is getting the funding. They don't come cheap.

Harry8388 profile image
Harry8388

No I didn’t see it but have to say I am underwhelmed whenever I mention PMR and get no response.

prunus profile image
prunus

The articles written by real people in the DM newspaper have given a far more accurate coverage. Unfortunately they have been few and far between.

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply toprunus

My story with GCA in 2014 for example 😊

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

PMR - update on doctor call

Hello lovely folks, thank you for your help yesterday. Spoke to the lady doctor this morning and I...
Gimme profile image

This pmr and gca

To all, this forum is amazing, especially when you have PMR PRO and DORSET LADY with you. My thanks...
morrison profile image

Could this be PMR?

My friend is visiting me and has just told me the following story. In November 2022 she started...

Shingles jab and PMR

A lady I know believes her PMR was caused by the shingles jab she was recently offered at the age...
Casia profile image

NO GCA/PMR............. JUST A TRIBUTE ................

Today, I have spent with my dear little lady friend, marking her 100th Birthday!!!!!!!!!! I have...
karools16 profile image

Moderation team

SophieMB profile image
SophieMBPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.