Hi, I posted about a month ago regarding Vits K2 and D3 as I have decided not to have any more Alendronoc Acid or infusions. My scan shows some osteoporosis and some osteopenia.
I have been on pred for 2.5 years (PMR) starting at 15mg and slowly reducing to 1mg and taking a daily chewable Adcal-D3.
I purchased VitD3 (which I have not taken) and VitK2 which I discovered also included D3 so I have been taking Adcal-D3 and one tablet of VitK2 /D3 for a month. As I have nearly run out I intended to just buy VitK2 (without the added vitD3). I then realised that the Adcal already had D3! So iI went to the local pharmacist to ask him to check my dosages.
He was a mature man who said he had supplied many Adcal tablets but no one ever had asked for vit K2. I told him it helped to absorb the calcium and send it to the correct place but he looked at me as if I was a mad woman! He said I didn’t need it.
So, do I take the Adcal-D3 and try to buy just the K2? Or do I even need the K2 as he implied?
Thanks in advance.
Written by
Urtica
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
I take it because of its proven role in assisting the absorption of Calcium thereby protecting the bones. It is also found to have a role in preventing the calcification of arteries thereby protecting the heart. Studies have shown that it may also have a role in preventing some chronic diseases. Populations such as the Japanese who eat a lot of fermented foods ( rich in K2) have borne this out in comparative studies.
I can imagine my doctor reacting similarly if I brought it up though. There are plenty of reputable articles on line if you google.
You need Vitamin K2, unless you are eating plenty of food containing it. As the average Western diet is now deficient in K2 a supplement is a good idea. Don't be surprised when doctors and pharmacists don't know about K2. They think it's the same as K1 (it isn't) which we get plenty of in our diet if we eat leafy greens. When I first found out about it my daughter was a fairly newly minted registered dietitian and she knew nothing about it until I told her about it.
Australian RDA for K2 is 180 mcg per day. I take two 100 mcg capsules. I don't think you need to be concerned about overdose at these levels.
Standard dosage for Vitamin D is 1000 IU per day, but 2000 is often recommended especially when we are taking pred. I understand that as much as 4000 is safe for most people. It is probably a good idea to have your D level checked at some point. There is really no way to say whether you need more, or less, or whether your levels are optimum, without a test.
Has your D3 (or K2) been measured in a blood test? I ask because a lot of us can be deficient without knowing especially people with auto-immune diseases. My GP will test for it. My daughter is VERY low despite supplementing and working outside all day every day so has just upped her dose by quite a bit.
Not sure. I had bloods done a few week’s ago as I was extremely tired etc. Doc said he would test everything - liver, kidneys, thyroid but no news is good news he said. I did phone surgery to double check that they had got results but no details of exactly what they tested for. I am now waiting for appointment for a sleep apnoea test!
I would chase them up - I take advantage of my entitlement to have my results and over the years it has paid dividends sharing with people who know more than me - and has led to much better treatment for me particularly with the thyroid. Thyroid treatment is in a strange place at the moment with many professionals having different opinions on what is good and where in the range things should be. I now understand most measurements that I have tests for.
I eat prunes too although I can’t remember what they have in which is good for you! I understand VitK2 helps the calcium be absorbed by the bones instead of artery walls.
Oh right - I thought the Alendronic acid and vit D helped to absorb the calcium but you say you dont take alendronic acid? Prunes have lots of fibre which helps with constipation from calcium tablet (or steroids)
Hi Urtica. I stopped the AdcalD3, on the advice of my doctor, as it was giving me heartburn. My doctor, going through my diet with me, was happy that I was getting enough calcium. A blood test (that I asked for!) confirmed it. So now I just take D3 and K2 (both sprays) each morning. Incidentally, a friend of mine going through cancer has been handed AdcalD3 every time she sees the Dr. She has never taken them as she can't stand them, and has regular bloods checked for calcium levels, each time told they are perfect! And the Dr's don't know she's not been taking it! Like me she also has D3 in a spray to make sure she is getting enough as our bodies of course can't store that. All the best. X
I seem to have no problem taking Adcal-D3. As for diet, I don’t drink milk in tea or coffee or on its own so not sure if my diet is high enough in calcium. I am due for a Dexa scan next Feb so will have more of an idea how my bones are doing.
In addition, from my research and the input from HeronNS, I would suggest looking for K-2 in the form of MK-7 rather than MK-4. It appears to be the more valuable form to take.
Thanks, I have ordered the K2 Mk-7. Still not sure whether I should take the D3 capsules as well (which I bought a few weeks ago) as I get it with the Adcal-D3?
I purchase my Vit. K2 on-line from Healthspan. I only have to take one a day. I have been told not to take Calcium and D3 by my endocrinologist as I have hyperparathyroidism and have too much calcium in my blood. The Vit. K2 helps to lower the level in my blood and sends it to the bones.
Thanks for your reply . I have had an over active thyroid four times in the past 50 years but latest blood test was normal. GP has never mentioned extra calcium but it is something for me to be aware of.
Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.
Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.
Further Update
Good diet so no need for Adcal?
Newbie!!
Osteoporosis/PMR treatment
