Humira or Enbrel?: Anyone have thoughts? Benefits of... - NRAS

NRAS

37,263 members46,132 posts

Humira or Enbrel?

nablur profile image
8 Replies

Anyone have thoughts? Benefits of one over the other? My rheumy says I can change now after the welt and redness with Hunira. I’m interested in your thoughts :

a. Is one better than the other?

b. Did you have any allergic reactions? Injection site reactions?

c. Does Enbrel hurt to inject also?

Thanks!

Jill

Written by
nablur profile image
nablur
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
ragurl profile image
ragurl

Took both , Enbrel for 7 years switched to Humira for 10 years now. Both worked great, Enbrel started losing effectiveness so we switched to Humira. Humira still working but got an infection last year had to go off Humira for a year when I restarted damage had occurred and Humira slow to work again . I use syringe instead of pen. Pen hurts . Good luck

nablur profile image
nablur in reply toragurl

Thank you for your answer, Ragurl.

The Dr. is leaving it up to me and I asked her to please just decide. Didn’t know syringe is pain free either. Since I was using it for mtx, I’m sure I could do it for this too. ❤️

Barrister profile image
Barrister

When I was on Humira it was a syringe and have to say, that hurt as much as the pen which I have for Benepali (Enbrel). I’ve taken both Enbrel and now Benepali and got site reaction with Enbrel for the first few injections and then it settle. Occasionally get a small itchy site when I use Benepali but it soon goes. Humira stopped working for me and changed to Enbrel which worked really well but gradually lost effectiveness so started Methotrexate with Enbrel which seemed fine but hospital now switched me to Benepali which I don’t believe is as effective.

Clemmie

nablur profile image
nablur in reply toBarrister

Thanks Clemmie!

Sarahg62 profile image
Sarahg62

Good morning. I was on Enbrel for 10 years, then out of the blue I developed Uveitis. Apparently Enbrel is the only one that doesn’t keep this eye complaint at bay, I also noticed that if I had to come off Enbrel for any reason ( infection) the effects wore off very quickly . I was switched to Humira - works just as well, been on it for 2 1/2 years, and had no problems.

nablur profile image
nablur in reply toSarahg62

Thank you Sarah. 🙏🏻

ruth_p profile image
ruth_p

I found Enbrel worked better than Humira (until it stopped), it was also less stingy. I never had any site reactions with either, but I did when I started tocilizumab but that went away after about a month. Enbrel you inject weekly whereas Humira was two weekly. I hope this helps 🙂

nablur profile image
nablur in reply toruth_p

Oh, thanks Ruth. I didn’t know about the weekly vs biweekly. Definitely helpful. ❤️

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

ENBREL or HUMIRA

Hi everyone just looking for some advice on which one works the best as next week I am going to be...
micky40 profile image

Enbrel, Humira or Simponi?

That is the question! I have had a first meeting with my Rneumatology nurse (despite idiot taxi...
Neonkitty profile image

Humira

Hi all, after a 6 week break from meds due to bloods am back on the wagon i had 1st Humira...
sarah1967 profile image

Enbrel

Hi all, I am starting Enbrel this week after having been on humira for 6 mos. I had no bad...
Hammit39 profile image

Enbrel update

well ladies and gentlemen I have done the third week of enbrel and it is going well so far. No...

Moderation team

See all
KateL-NRAS profile image
KateL-NRASAdministrator
Donagh-NRAS profile image
Donagh-NRASAdministrator
Nicola-NRAS profile image
Nicola-NRASAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.