Unnumbered post Just a silly question... - My MSAA Community

My MSAA Community

9,432 members21,216 posts

Unnumbered post Just a silly question 19 Ocvt 2020 2

RoyceNewton profile image
26 Replies

Family, help me out here. This is a serious question. Do black women have different ms to everybody else? Why do they feel that they need\want a separate ms group than us? I do not understand why they have a black woman with ms forum.

Before "YOU" jump on my head, my mother is black, from the West Indies, my father is very white from Tasmania, Australia.

So I am just curious, I thought ms got us all, I did not know it got other ethnicities differently.

Royce (your ms writer and brother)

Just curious

Written by
RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
26 Replies
Jesmcd2 profile image
Jesmcd2CommunityAmbassador

Here RoyceNewton read this mymsaa.org/ms-information/o... about who gets MS.. and this mymsaa.org/videos/the-afric...

As far as ANYONE making a separate forum, it's there choice to do so... 🤗💕👻

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toJesmcd2

very true and in this journey that we are on it is all about choice, I just hope that they do not feel excluded that would make me very sad

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toJesmcd2

very interesting read, thankyou

Hi Royce😊

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toSweetheartonvdayl

G'day, back. hope you are well

Sweetheartonvdayl profile image
Sweetheartonvdayl in reply toRoyceNewton

I had a whole reply to you but I lost it ... The answer to your question , is NO. There's no difference @all. The only thing I can think of is DIET.

🙏❤Lisa💕

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toSweetheartonvdayl

hmm thanks, I had not thought of that

greaterexp profile image
greaterexp

I find the question puzzling. If any person wants a separate forum they feel meets their needs better, then they have that freedom. I don’t personally feel a need to have a separate forum for people over 60 with MS, but if I felt that this forum did not meet my needs in that regard, I might decide to try to start my own, understanding that it may be a very small group.

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply togreaterexp

good point

Tazmanian profile image
Tazmanian in reply togreaterexp

I thought you were 25

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toTazmanian

if you are talking to me over50 not sure how much I stopped counting at 50

greaterexp profile image
greaterexp in reply toTazmanian

I haven’t been there for a long time!

MSAA_Staff profile image
MSAA_Staff

Hello RoyceNewton - Multiple sclerosis varies among people of different ethnicities and races. You may be interested in the cover story, "Disease Effects and Needs of Minority Populations with MS" from MSAA's 2017 Winter/Spring issue of The Motivator: mymsaa.org/publications/mot...

Also, in addition to the video resource that Jesmcd2 posted, MSAA recently conducted a webinar discussing health disparities and the impact of COVID-19 on the MS community. To access the recording of this webinar, please visit: mymsaa.org/videos/understan...

Thank you!

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toMSAA_Staff

no thank you very much I am now more educated

jorrell profile image
jorrell

Oh, my friend, I am almost scared to answer your question. My findings over many decades has been that people of any particular race tend to stay together and block themselves off to the outside world, I will say this about any race, I will say this about bird species, and for that matter, insects... I've seen the Praying Mantis hang out with others of their own kind, never saw a wasp try to join their group. Like Jesmcd2 states, it is their choice to do so.

Simply, it is a choice, and I applaud them as they deal with different social issues than others. When it comes to this MS group, all are welcome and were never refused, unless they make edgy comments that are found to be over the edge!

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply tojorrell

Interesting point.

Sandydemop profile image
Sandydemop

YOU are sweet to be so sensitive. Of course everyone is welcome here. I 😍 that about this group. We are all different. Some are connected to a different political party, others are a different religion from me, some are farmers while others have a different sense of humor. It's more important to me that we have this one thing in common. I know you get me when it comes to MS. If I didn't feel safe sharing here, for whatever reason, yes, I would find a different group. Something interesting to share with you is that I belong to a small group of therapists who have MS. We meet once a month (now over zoom) but usually in person. Although the group has been meeting for years, I only joined about 5 years ago. I also attend a support group for those with chronic illness, not all have MS. I have to say there is a plentiful amount of support to deal with MS. If i were African American, maybe i would want to join that group too.

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toSandydemop

You also have a good point, I would be very unhappy if they felt they were excluded, there is a wealth of knowledge and support here

twooldcrows profile image
twooldcrows

great question...is there a difference ????

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply totwooldcrows

From what I saw, they are diagnosed later than most people and because of that I assume progress faster due to late treatment. That is what I understood somebody can correct me if I misunderstood what I read

Cutefreckles72 profile image
Cutefreckles72

I am a black woman within this group and I enjoy chatting with everyone and I don't plan on leaving this group. MS doesn't discriminate why should I.

Amore55 profile image
Amore55 in reply toCutefreckles72

Great answer. Thank you! Love, Kelly xx

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toCutefreckles72

nice to meet you

Sweetheartonvdayl profile image
Sweetheartonvdayl in reply toCutefreckles72

My best friend is mixed , with MS. She also belongs to this wonderful, loving and all inclusive group. The color of your skin never mattered to me- being a nurse & foremost a Christian.🙏🙏🙏

😊❤Lisa💕

RoyceNewton profile image
RoyceNewton in reply toSweetheartonvdayl

yes mixed the way to go :-)

mrsmike9 profile image
mrsmike9

As far as I know the only thing that is different is melanin in their skin. I would think, however that black anyone may need a different forum as unfortunately the "black experience" is vastly different than a white person's is. Different doctor experiences, etc. It is horrible that it happens but it's true.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Unnumbered post The other rule stands 19 Aug 2020 3

If ever I miss your post or you want to yell t me. Do it privately, send me s PM. Thinking...
RoyceNewton profile image

Unnumbered post Am I missing something 15 Aug 2020

Can not ms be diagnosed without a Lumbar Puncture? Mine was 20+ years ago. MRI and evoked...
RoyceNewton profile image

Unnumbered post A thought 22 Nov 2020

My beloved ms family, I hope we are all well and last night was good for you and today meets all...
RoyceNewton profile image

Unnumbered post YOU and me, Us 19 Aug 2020

G'day my siblings. "YOU" and I are sick. We will never get better, no matter what we take or...
RoyceNewton profile image

Unnumbered post Today is really nice 19 Mar 2020

Good Morning my ms family, how are we all today, did "YOU" sleep restfully last night? I most...
RoyceNewton profile image

Moderation team

See all
johnMSAA profile image
johnMSAAPartner
DanaMSAA profile image
DanaMSAAPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.