I want to have a circumcision, which ... - Men's Health Foru...

Men's Health Forum (Penis Health)

35,453 members8,881 posts

I want to have a circumcision, which style would be the best?

c3ifador profile image
29 Replies

Hello, I am a 23 years old brazilian that after I discovered my mother's family were Jewish (there in Portugal they maintain the traditions) before coming to brazil in 1920 we were raised without religion and after years of depression I searched for my family's history and I was delighted with joy finding myself, I don't know why, I tried to rationalize it and put into words but I can't, I just feel like I finally belong somewhere.

Since last year I did searched for styles of circumcision for cosmetic purposes, I do penis enlargement exercises since I am 19 and now I have a penis measuring erect bone pressed 20,3x14,8cm non bone pressed is 18,5x14,8cm. I like to think I am a grower because my flaccid penis somewhere between nbpel 11 and 13cm, but on some days I can read on the tape 14~15cm flaccid length. The first thought I had was to have a high and tight circumcision, but I think you guys are the ones who have the knowledge here and please give your opinions.

I think I have a lot of skin because those exercises stretched it to a point I never had before that is foreskin covering my glans while erected and at the base and shaft I gained skin through pumping. Those are the reasons I think I may have the high and tight circumcision.

I uploaded these photos on imgur app, here's the link imgur.com/a/Hbh8vUi

These photos were taken last week.

Edit: forgot to mention that I also want to take out the frenulum because it stretched so much.

Written by
c3ifador profile image
c3ifador
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
29 Replies
Yy928 profile image
Yy928

other than your wishes for the type of circumcision, it’s the most important that the right amount of skin will be removed and that the style also suits

in reply to Yy928

High and tight. But make sure not too tight.

xhardwarex profile image
xhardwarex in reply to

I agree with this.

Are doing this for religious reasons?

c3ifador profile image
c3ifador in reply to

No rabino asked me to do it, I am doing first because my father (which is Christian did it) grandfather (jew) greatgrandfather and so on did it. Adding all this for cosmetic reasons, I just prefer the cut appearance.

in reply to c3ifador

You will need to discuss the options with a surgeon.

c3ifador profile image
c3ifador in reply to

Yes, next week I will meet up with the doctor and discuss this.

Zsr method. Quick and easy

in reply to

No. Its not recommended if you are doing it for cosmetic reasons.

martintrente profile image
martintrente in reply to

Hi Krishna

Why is ZSR not recommended for a cosmetic circumcision ?

I am consiodering circumcision, and all comments I get about ZSR are super positive (including from the doctor)

in reply to martintrente

Send me a private message

Realtalk1021 profile image
Realtalk1021

What penis enlargement exercises do u do and how much have you grown?

c3ifador profile image
c3ifador in reply to Realtalk1021

I am not on this forum to talk about PE.

apeters profile image
apeters

Since you appear not to have a current medical problem requiring circumcision, it will be regarded as purely elective. Whether for cosmetic, prophylactic or religious reasons an elective circumcision is best done in a specialist circumcision clinic if you can find one, rather than a hospital (which is geared to treating actual current problems). A clinic will be better able to accept that there is a cosmetic/aesthetic aspect to any elective adult circumcision and adjust their methods accordingly.

There is no 'best' style as one style doesn't suit all. From what you have written, it would seem that you are a 'grower' (erect length much greater than flaccid) and therefore you cannot have a result which is tight when flaccid - but can have it tight when erect. A properly experienced circumcision doctor will be able to deal with this properly.

People have personal preferences as to 'high' or 'low' and only YOU can decide which you prefer. (For myself it's low).

A properly done circumcision should take out the redundant frenulum automatically (unless the patient specifically wants it left), but you need to tell the surgeon what you want in this respect.

anon2508 profile image
anon2508 in reply to apeters

i am a grower so that rules out tight ?! is there any advantages/disadvantages to high or low ?

in reply to anon2508

Having a high cut utilizes the inner foreskin for optimal erogenous sensitivity. I have a high and tight cut and it’s too tight and I’m a grower too. But you might give a look at high and loose cuts which would still have optimal inner skin sensitivity but enough skin for your penis during erections circlist.com/styles/page1.html

in reply to anon2508

I agree with td21

Rokyraj profile image
Rokyraj

You should do ZSR CIRCUMCISION. the best one and only.

Nudeglans profile image
Nudeglans

I would go for a tight circumcision with the frenulum removed. I’m very happy like that.

ml66uk profile image
ml66uk in reply to Nudeglans

That sounds like the worst possible option to me.

Clay237 profile image
Clay237

Consider that if you are doing PE exercises, you are constantly pulling and stretching the shaft. As a consequence, you are constantly lengthening the skin tissue. You may end up back to square one after some time.

I think it is not worth the procedure given your situation.

As1014 profile image
As1014

If ur doing it for Judaism the only kosher way is a high cut

ml66uk profile image
ml66uk in reply to As1014

Until around 130AD, nobody Jewish got a high cut.

xsevenx profile image
xsevenx in reply to ml66uk

What’s the significance of that date? Not Jewish. Just curious.

ml66uk profile image
ml66uk in reply to xsevenx

That was when some rabbis decided they didn't want Jewish men being able to pass themselves off as gentile (ie not Jewish), so they changed the style of circumcision from "brit milah", where only the overhang was cut off the baby's penis, to "brit periah", which removed most or all of the foreskin.

The terms "high cut" and "low cut" can mean opposite things to different people btw. The usual form of Jewish circumcision these days removes a lot more tissue than the historical form though.

anon2508 profile image
anon2508

penis enlargement exercises ? which cut did you choose and are you happy with your decision ?

Rijoy profile image
Rijoy

Low or high,it is better to keep the frenulum with moderate cut.

Mefirts profile image
Mefirts

The best for what? Good looking or keeping more sensitivity? If you chose second one the better is not doing it at all.

alray711 profile image
alray711

Speaking from personal experience, don't have it done too tight. When you masturbate it's nice to have a small amount of loose skin. If skin is too tight being fully erect can cause some discomfort and it will be necessary to always use lube.

You may also like...

Wanting to be circumcised

look of a circumcised penis, and wished mine was. I only have a little amount of tightness, but...

Should I consider circumcision?

about how tight to go, how tight is too tight? I mean I want it to look really tight when I’m erect...

I have very severe phimosis, what options do I have that are not circumcision?

back is the same whether erect or flaccid meaning that the state of my erection does not affect the...

Do I need a Circumcision? Or just to stretch more (I’m new here)

I’ve always had a tight foreskin, I could not pull my foreskin back when flaccid but now I can pull

Frenuloplasty or Circumcision Which one will be the best?

will be not be successful then have to go for Circumcision during the operation time itslef. As m...