Orthorexia: I've been listening to a podcast... - Healthy Eating

Healthy Eating

62,158 members8,210 posts

Orthorexia

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator
16 Replies

I've been listening to a podcast series, which spent some time talking about eating disorders. A relatively newly recognised eating disorder is orthorexia, which is an obsession with healthy eating. As this is a healthy eating forum, I thought it might be a good idea to share the signs and symptoms, in case it might help anyone:

daa.asn.au/smart-eating-for...

Sufferers of Orthorexia may come to view foods they deem unhealthy as akin to poison, and may spend a large proportion of their day on social media, searching for recipes and nutritional information.

If you do feel you may be affected, then it is worth visiting your GP to discuss getting help. It is possible to overcome the disorder and develop a healthy relationship with food again :)

Written by
Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
flo72003 profile image
flo72003

Interesting reading! Thanks for posting it :)

Matt2584 profile image
Matt2584

Orthorexia or it’s full name Orthorexia Nervosa. When one is nervous about eating the correct foods.

Personally, I think this ‘orthorexia’ business is a load of twaddle.

The reason people will go out of there way to eat as clean foods as they can is because the food industry deliberately fill our foods with harmful compounds that should not even be there in the first place!

And to make matters worse, manufacturers will lie about the safety of these compounds, hence food fraud which was a post Jerry made.

So that is why I think ‘orthorexia’ is a load of... what-knot.

As I have said before, you can find decent, genuine info on the internet and you can also run into a bunch of lies too.

A person needs to decipher between the good and the bad info.

At the end of the day though, what is so wrong in avoiding foods with poison in it and eating cleaner?

In my view that isn’t orthorexia is just bloody common sense :).

What is NOT common sense is making up a term such as ‘orthorexia nervosa’ and saying it is a mental disorder.

So now, this bit of misinformation is going to make people think “Oh no, I have a mental disorder. I better start eating harmful foods again”.

It’s all about money at the end of the day.

But then saying that though, people who choose to eat clean pay out more if they are not growing there own food.

If they do grow there own then obviously food is free.

Rant over.

Sorry, this kind of information winds me up.

Why do we have to live in such a corrupt world that is full of greed?

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply toMatt2584

I'm afraid we'll have to disagree on this one - in my opinion, Orthorexia is a very real eating disorder. If someone does come forward suffering with it, I think it's very important to support them, and not dismiss their concerns.

It is very common for people who formerly suffered anorexia, for example, to develop orthorexia, as a means to hide their eating disorder from loved ones. It's a great excuse to go out and only eat 100calories worth of steamed veggies, instead of a full meal, without the comments from family that you need to eat something.

Women who suffer Orthorexia will often lose their period as a result of not getting the nutrition they need, and the stress it puts their bodies under.

An interest in healthy eating is ok, but for some people this does become an obsession that gets out of hand, and affects their health.

Bong1968 profile image
Bong1968 in reply toMatt2584

You contradict yourself.

Firstly...

As I have said before, you can find decent, genuine info on the internet and you can also run into a bunch of lies too.

A person needs to decipher between the good and the bad info.’

You then go on to say..

So now, this bit of misinformation is going to make people think “Oh no, I have a mental disorder. I better start eating harmful foods again”.’

A very definite and patronising assumption that everyone believes what they read online to be gospel, despite your previous comments about the authenticity of internet articles.

As someone who has suffered from serious health issues themselves, I am surprised that you consider orthorexia to be ‘a load of twaddle’.

I am certain that for sufferers of the condition it is VERY real.

I wonder how you would have felt if your condition was dismissed in such an offhand manner?

I believe the OP was sharing the link as they found it interesting, informative and wanted to raise awareness - hence the comment to recommend potential sufferers to seek advice from their GP.

They should not have to defend their post just because your opinion differs.

I personally believe that it’s only a matter of time before orthorexia is linked to mental health but, hey, that’s just my opinion.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply toBong1968

It's ok, I don't think Matt is intendeding to cause harm, it's just coming from lack of awareness.

I think the condition in general doesn't have a lot of awareness at the moment, but even conditions that do (e.g. anorexia), still have a lot of misunderstanding around them anyway.

Matt2584 profile image
Matt2584 in reply toBong1968

Cooper is right, I’m not intending to cause harm.

Why are you surprised that as I have a brain injury I find orthorexia rubbish?

Am I supposed to believe every word that is written? Sorry, but I aint no sheep. I don’t follow the crowd.

Well people who have this condition can call it real if they like, however I don’t and that is my opinion.

You wonder how I would feel if my condition was dismissed in an offhand manner do you.

It would depend on the dismissal. If one person dismissed it, it wouldn’t bother me so much.

If everybody around me dismissed then it might make me cry :).

I think most of us know that there is truthful information on the net and false information.

The OP could have found the article interesting, informative and wanted to raise awareness.

The OP should not have to defend their post, but they choose to.

Just because my opinion differs doesn’t mean people have to agree with me.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply toMatt2584

I don't think it was the best article on the condition, but I did like the symptom list at the end.

If you do want to see more, I liked this interview with a sufferer: youtu.be/gl71xitLtVI

There's a longer presentation from a dietician as well, I'm about halfway through myself so can't vouch for the whole thing:

youtu.be/j44N9xkk_yg

They both explain how the condition varies so much from just being about healthy eating alone.

Matt2584 profile image
Matt2584 in reply toCooper27

I only had a peep (6 mins) of the first video and still think it sounds like rubbish, but that’s my opinion.

The video is from a mainstream source as well, ABC news, so that tells me right away that it’s most likely rubbish.

But what I’d like to know, and I don’t know if I missed something here, but how can you be malnourished by meticulously eating healthy?

Surely if you are eating healthy you are being well nourished.

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply toMatt2584

I listened to a podcast by a lady who had suffered orthorexia, she said it started with a fear of gluten, dairy, fat and red meat, so she started out as a low fat, gluten free vegan. She then developed a fear of soya and carbs, which led to cutting out tofu, legumes, grains and potatoes, which really didn't leave a lot to eat. Her whole diet basically was built around steamed low carb vegetables & salad (no fruit, because fruit has carbs). It leaves the diet lacking in lots of essential nutrients, essential fatty acids, calories!

She also mentioned a need to work out every day, and would get anxiety if she had to miss a trip to the gym.

Anyone can eat a "healthy diet" and end up malnourished if they don't get the right nutrients, or if they don't eat enough calories.

I wouldn't dismiss the person because of the new agency she chose to give an interview to. I've been surprised by some of the well researched and empathetically written stories I've seen in the daily mail in the past :)

Bong1968 profile image
Bong1968 in reply toMatt2584

Thanks for your reply.

I’d like to clarify that I didn’t suggest that you having a brain injury was the reason that you find orthorexia rubbish.

Obviously I don’t know if you experienced any negative attitudes/opinions from people while you were waiting to be diagnosed but if you didn’t then I consider you to be very lucky. The nature of you condition is not relevant here.

I’m just surprised that, having experienced being ill yourself, you would be so offhand about a different condition.

I certainly don’t expect you to believe everything that is written. That’s why I don’t understand when you say that people have to decipher what is good and bad but then go on to say that ‘misinformation’, especially in this instance, will make people think they have a mental disorder!

Surely most people can make their own minds up as to whether or not they believe an article? 🐑

I know people who are very sensitive about how people perceive them when they are unwell and having their condition disbelieved and deemed as twaddle Is not helpful.

I agree that everyone is entitle to have their own options and the world would be pretty boring if we all saw things in the same light.

So yes - it looks like we disagree here. C’est la vie...

As long as I didn’t make you cry I won’t lose sleep over it! 🙂

Matt2584 profile image
Matt2584 in reply toBong1968

I know you didn’t suggest me having a brain injury was the reason why I find orthorexia rubbish but I would like to know why you are surprised that I don’t believe in it.

Cos that sounds, to me and correct me if I’m wrong, but it sounds like when it is broadcasted on tv or written in articles by “dieticians” or what-have-you that Orthorexia is a real thing then people must go along with what they say and that is a grand explanation of a sheep.

That’s right, the nature of my condition is not relevant.

Before my injury, I would not have had the same thoughts as I was only a kid when it happened.

What I am saying is the original article was talking about orthorexia. People might believe in the condition, people might not believe. However, I don’t believe. I think it is mostly made up or as mainstream media tend to do ‘make a mountain out of a molehill’... and that’s my opinion.

You would think that most people could make their own minds up about an article but there are many people out there who will go along with what mainstream media tell them.

Matt2584 profile image
Matt2584 in reply toBong1968

Our foods are tainted by all sorts of chemicals, GMOs, carcinogens and so on and that is not my opinion that is a fact.

It makes me wonder what all these chemicals, GMOs... etc does to our bodies in the long run.

Zest profile image
Zest

Hi Cooper27

Thanks for sharing this article.

Zest :-)

I came across this article this morning: "Social media influencers fuelled my 'clean eating' disorder "

news.sky.com/story/social-m...

Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator in reply to

I read this too, glad to see it's getting coverage!

in reply toCooper27

That can only be a good thing, whether that's to keep us on our toes so we don't get sucked into obsessive behaviour about our own eating habits or to better understand and be compassionate towards those who've struggled with this condition.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

This week is Eating Disorders Awareness week.

Good morning everyone, As many people have issues with food and in the UK there are a known 1.25...

Need advice on how to temporarily suspend healthy eating

I have changed my diet drastically in the last few months - from eating mostly processed foods with...
FrankW profile image

Increase calories after diet for weight maintenance

Hi all I'm coming to the point where I'm happy with my weight and want to maintain this. I've done...
pfm401 profile image

Smart watch personalised nutrition is coming...

I read this with interest and my opinion it has a few flaws, like human nature, unpredictability...

Failing

Hey guys, In the last few years I feel like I’m failing all the time: I really want to lose weight,...

Moderation team

See all
Activity2004 profile image
Activity2004Administrator
Kitten-whiskers profile image
Kitten-whiskersAdministrator
Cooper27 profile image
Cooper27Administrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.