The truth about exercise (BBC): bbc.co.uk... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

134,175 members159,525 posts

The truth about exercise (BBC)

secan profile image
secanGraduate
15 Replies

bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01cywtq

Has anyone seen it?

I found particularly interesting, although potentially worrying, the research about how people respond differently to exercising.

I'm also a bit sceptical about the 3-minute intense effort regime but I might give it a go once my knee recovers.

What do you think?

Written by
secan profile image
secan
Graduate
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
15 Replies
Bazza1234 profile image
Bazza1234Graduate

Can't view the programme here - but , IF i had one dollar for every theory supposedly supported by "research" I would be very rich. Only this morning, I saw an "advertisement" for some drug that stated "May be helpful for people with high cholesterol" - that of course also means that it may not!!

Bit like those warnings we have on the TV - "This show may contain nudity, sexual references and violence". May ---???? Surely it either does or it doesn't!! Perhaps it is meant to be a some kind of TV version of "click bait" ?? :)

secan profile image
secanGraduate in reply toBazza1234

I don't think that is the case, the programme was presenting a research from the university of... Nottingham? Norfolk? (Can't remember right now) and, more in general I find BBC programmes pretty good and well documented.

JLT52 profile image
JLT52Graduate

I remember watching this when it was first broadcast, I like the presenter because although he is a doctor his diet and exercise regime is not perfect and he comes across as an ordinary flawed human being. If I remember correctly from this and the 5 2 diet he followed, he pointed out that it doesn't suit everyone and at the end of the day you have to find the right exercise/diet for you.

Theziggy profile image
TheziggyGraduate in reply toJLT52

I like Michael Mosley the presenter - he is bucking the trend about low fat being good for you and has made some very interesting documentaries about diet and exercise, I have followed one of his diets and it worked for me.

yatesco profile image
yatescoGraduate in reply toJLT52

My father in law went on the 5 2 diet and lost a whole bunch of weight, and kept it off. He didn't find it too tiresome either.

misswobble profile image
misswobbleGraduate

I think you'dd have to build up to 3 minutes intense exercise. Start small and work your way up. A bit like C25k

yatesco profile image
yatescoGraduate

I did read that sprinting is better for fat burning than the long easy run because sprinting makes the body continue burning fat AFTER it has finished.

I could do 3 minutes intense exercise (well, close, anyway), but it wouldn't replace all the other benefits of running for me (getting out the house, scenery etc.).

Not seen the program but it sounds like hiit with a missing i as in interval. The body coach Jo Wicks has a system where you go as fast as you can for 30secs rest for 60 secs doing cardio and similar doing strength training, you only exercise from 15 to 20 mts. It could be walk/run, jog/sprint whatever your personal level is. I'm giving it a try and am slowly building up the speed as I feel ready.Currently on 4/7mph not very good but I am 57 so I'll take it ;)

RunaroundSue profile image
RunaroundSue

I read this yesterday. I was not surprised at the result.

Belly fat: What's the best way to get rid of it? - bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-367...

baronblaze profile image
baronblaze

I would probably support the conclusion that they reached going from my personal experience. When i used to wear a younger mans clothes and train for football, the short intense exercise until you drop routines seemed to be far more beneficial to fitness and body shape than any long run. The first type was for overall fitness levels the second was to increase your stamina. If you can do both and perversely enjoy them it would be more beneficial for body, mind and fitness than just concentrating on one type.

Katie204 profile image
Katie204Graduate

I have seen this programme and thought the conclusions were very interesting.

If you are going to give this a go, however, I would suggest running the idea past your doctor first, and finding a qualified trainer.

GoogleMe profile image
GoogleMeGraduate

The best sort of regime is going to be the one you actually *do*

Bazza1234 profile image
Bazza1234Graduate in reply toGoogleMe

and keep on doing!! :)

huffnpuffin profile image
huffnpuffinGraduate

The program talks about HIIT exercise - High Intensity Interval Training goggle to your hearts content (see what I did there :) )

Bazza1234 profile image
Bazza1234Graduate in reply tohuffnpuffin

Yes - how did you do it?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

The Truth About...

I just noticed that BBC 1 are repeating The Truth About series. Late tonight is episode 3, the...
UnfitNoMore profile image
Graduate

The Truth About Scientific Claims for Nutrition, Exercise or Weight Loss

I have been blogging here a few months, and absolutely love this place and C25K. I have seen a lot...
Alaiyo profile image
Graduate

The Truth about Sleep

Last night's bbc programme on sleep recommended an early morning walk/run to reset the internal...
ladyharvills profile image
Graduate

The Truth About Weight Loss (Fat Loss)

In my last (stunningly well-read) blog, I started a series on how to get good information about...
Alaiyo profile image
Graduate

The truth about sports products...

BBC 1 worth an iplayer viewing for those that have missed it... I'm going to stick with...
Bxster profile image
Graduate

Moderation team

See all
Annieapple profile image
AnnieappleAdministrator
MissUnderstanding profile image
MissUnderstandingAdministrator
Mummycav profile image
MummycavAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.