Help with Strava: I hope someone can help me... - Bridge to 10K

Bridge to 10K

16,525 members26,586 posts

Help with Strava

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10
14 Replies

I hope someone can help me with this. When I’m running with my friend we both use strava. We both started it at exactly the same time, ran together the same distance chatting as we ran and stopped it at the same time.

So here’s the conundrum.... our distances are different by 0.42 miles and our average pace is different by 1.23 mins. This has happened many times now.

We both updated the app before our run yesterday.

How is this possible?

P.s the tap dancing is going great. I love it!!

Written by
littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24
Graduate10
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
14 Replies
K8nno profile image
K8nnoGraduate10

Is the data source the same? Does one of you have a watch? Android or iOS?

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10 in reply toK8nno

We both use iPhone but I wear an I watch too. The strava is started on my phone.

K8nno profile image
K8nnoGraduate10 in reply tolittlemac24

Probably down to Strava picking up GPS data from your  watch. Might be interesting to run a known route with and without your watch to see the difference. Nearly 0.5 mile is a massive discrepancy

limberlou profile image
limberlouGraduate10

Myself and my daughter had this problem too, both of us running alongside each other, counting down at the start, so we would start our Garmin watches at the same time, and at the end too. And our pace and distance varies greatly too.

We think it’s probably that she usually ran on the outside of the pavements, and maybe picked up on different satellites???

I’ve even found that when I’m running along the Tarka Trail Strava thinks I run part of the way IN the river. I don’t stress too much about it all now and just run.

Dexy5 profile image
Dexy5Graduate10

My husband and I can run exactly the same route together using identical Garmin watches and when you look at the map I cross the road and run on the other side, or I can even run on water!

I have heard that using a watch and a phone can affect the GPS signal

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10 in reply toDexy5

I’ll try using just one.

UnfitNoMore profile image
UnfitNoMoreGraduate10

Could be different generations of iPhone... or maybe one has hit the dreaded turning down as battery life ebbs away? Maybe one of you is picking up some “assisted” gps somewhere? Or maybe one of your phones had locked on gps better when you bit hit start. The difference does seem rather large though.

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10 in reply toUnfitNoMore

Yes could be we both have different generation iPhones.

cheekychipmunks profile image
cheekychipmunksGraduate10

I’ve stopped using my phone app (I used MapMyRun) alongside my Garmin as I had a crazy discrepancy between the two a couple of weeks ago. MMR seemed to skip a whole kilometre somewhere along the way, which threw the stats way off.

So now I stick to Garmin alone as I’m sure they were confusing each other - maybe that’s what’s happening with your iPhone/Strava. It would be interesting to see if your friend’s ‘Garmin only’ stats were correct.

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10 in reply tocheekychipmunks

I’ll try using just one next run.

Katiepops profile image
KatiepopsGraduate10

No idea! I have a Garmin watch (which doesn’t agree with my partner’s Garmin watch running beside me!) which informs Strava via Garmin Connect. Strava doesn’t agree with Garmin, which is where it must have got its data from in the first place as I don’t run with the phone it’s downloaded to!

It’s all a mystery. Each week Parkrun is a riot where I end up with 3 slightly different times; over only 3 miles, there’s not much room for them to deviate!

Jolly lucky I’m not a professional athlete, so a minute here, a few seconds there and 0.2 of a mile divergence really doesn’t make a lot of difference to me! Often by the time I’ve got to the end there is so much sweat in my eyes that I can’t see the data anyway! 😂🏃‍♀️🏃‍♀️😊

Granspeed profile image
GranspeedGraduate10

All sounds like a great reason not to over-stress about stats! However, do post if you figure it out, because that’s a big discrepancy and I’d be really interested to know who’s “right”. Do you have different phone companies and could that matter? I thought the gps would be independent, but now...??? 😳🤪

littlemac24 profile image
littlemac24Graduate10 in reply toGranspeed

Yes we do have different phone networks. We are going to test it tomorrow. No watches, and swap phones to see what happens. I will let you all know.

Granspeed profile image
GranspeedGraduate10 in reply tolittlemac24

Great plan. Scientific investigation in action! Will look forward to the results.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Help with Strava please?

I’ve hardly run this month with one thing and another so I’ve just been out again to do another 4K...
Susieq174 profile image
Graduate10

Increasing distance nicely with a good group run.

It seems a lifetime ago that our running group thought that completing the C25K program was our...

More Strava Saga

So...... part 2 of the Strava saga. We went out for a run tonight in the rain (I love running in...
littlemac24 profile image
Graduate10

Cardiff 10k

In April 2018 I started the C25k programme having never run previously. Hundreds of other people...
BethMay profile image

Strava probs update

So thank you everyone for your replies and suggestions yesterday. Today we went for a run again,...
littlemac24 profile image
Graduate10

Moderation team

See all
Oldfloss profile image
OldflossAdministrator
MissUnderstanding profile image
MissUnderstandingAdministrator
Annieapple profile image
AnnieappleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.