Gait analysis: not an exact science? - Bridge to 10K

Bridge to 10K

14,490 members19,516 posts

Gait analysis: not an exact science?

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10

So, in the course of stalking/fondling my soon to be new running shoes, I have had gait analysis. Twice. Same running company (Runners Need), two different branches / store assistants. First one said I over-pronated with one of my feet. That's news to me. I run in a neutral shoe (bought after gait analysis in November 17), and have had no problems. Very next day had gait analysis at different branch. Assistant sees no over-pronation at all.

PFFFFFFT! Do these people even know what they are doing?

Had to order in my size of Cloudflyers; they should arrive tomorrow. Not the colour I dreamed of, but after running in another pair of On running shoes (the Cloudflow), I am smitten, in love, head over heels. Like running on air…

Sadie-runs (on Clouds) x

29 Replies
HeleneCorsa
HeleneCorsaGraduate10

Ooh pictures please! I need to see the shoes you have been fondling!

I have had conflicting advice re gait analysis and have bought far too many running shoes as a result. Regardless of whatever science may or may not be involved, I feel that I run more happily in a neutral shoe. I don't get along so well with the more stable ones, though I have to admit that the very boring old Asics GT 1000-6 (?? may not be correct name), which is supposed to be a stability shoe, has proved to be excellent especially for longer distances on uneven terrain. It's uninspiring but I so often find myself reaching for it.

Am intrigued by On shoes - everyone seems to rave about them and they are definitely nicer looking than most.

Tasha99
Tasha99Graduate10 in reply to HeleneCorsa

Omg they’re so comfy but no good for me - major over pronation 😭

roseabi
roseabiAdministrator

No science whatsoever! Just choose the shoes that you feel comfortable in.

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to roseabi

All too easy to get blinded / baffled by conflicting advice; I overthink things at the best of times! So yes, I am going by the feels now. :-)

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10

Haven't got them yet, Helene! Had to order them in to store as they didn't have my size, but should have them soon. On are an interesting brand. They don't actually make shoes for specific gaits; they claim that the shoes adapt to all gaits. I have only ever heard positive things about them…so very curious to try them. My ASICS have done me proud, but I just felt I needed a lighter shoe, and a half size bigger now I am running for longer. I promise to post a picture the minute I have them!

Have not heard from you in ages! I hope that you are doing well, dear Helene. x

Tbae
Tbae in reply to Sadie-runs

Only a half size larger.

Hey I am novice.

Atb Sadie hope they are perfect.

Read on here 1- 2 larger than normal.

Also morning time versus late afternoon fitting considerations, after your feet day usage and enlargement.

Atb., got to be perfect right.Put the responsibility where it should be on the store.

Atb.

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to Tbae

Oh, let me explain – I already wear a running shoe that is one size larger than my normal day shoe – what I am saying here is that I think I need to be 1.5 sizes larger now! So, day shoe = size 5; running shoe = size 6.5. :-)

FlickM3
FlickM3Graduate10 in reply to Sadie-runs

yes indeed: I take 7-7 1/2 in day shoes but my Cloudflyers are 8 1/2 and the Clouds are 9 !!!

Tbae
Tbae in reply to Tbae

Clarity on above 1.0 / 1.5/ 2.0 larger than your normal size.

The manufacturer/ supplier has this responsibility to advise.??

I agree with you, fit and feel is everything, but be sure and have plenty usage expansion space.

Wishing you a lovely experience with your lovely new friends.

Peace of mind in a phone call.Put them on the spot if you feel you need to.

Atb.

Tbae
Tbae in reply to Tbae

Brillant.Lovely new friends.Sorted.

TedG
TedGGraduate10

I know that feeling Sadie, same happened to me....ended up being £110 out of pocket! 😠

Enjoy your new shoes, as I said, my bro loves his Cloudflows 🤗

Whatsapp
WhatsappGraduate10

A 'gait analysis' can be carried out by any well-meaning sales assistant, who will give you an authoritive diagnosis even though it is not really your 'gait' that they have analysed.

If you want to get a 'proper' analysis you would need to go to one of those labs the professionals go to where they look at more than just your feet. This article explains the situation well: runnersconnect.net/running-...

As roseabi says, choose trainers you feel comfortable in.

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to Whatsapp

Yep, very true.

I have been running in a neutral shoe for 9 months now an no shoe related injuries that I can think of, so all good. :-)

misswobble
misswobbleGraduate10

The guy at our best local run shop, is a brill runner, and is always racing on all kinds of terrains and he does love the Cloud family. There’s a new one recently out

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10

You are lucky! I am not entirely convinced some of the people I have spoken to really know what they are talking about… One guy keeps pushing me toward ultra cushioned shoes that I know I do not need; I am wanting to get away from heavier shoes!

Bluebirdrunner
BluebirdrunnerGraduate10

I'm dreaming of clouds now Sadie.... they sound wonderful

..just need to wear my Asics out a bit more first!😊x

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to Bluebirdrunner

Well, my ASICS are probably fine for a wee while, my excuse is I need a pair to rotate. 😁 x

Elfe5
Elfe560minGraduate

Must - run - with - greater - consistency!! 😀

Alternatively...

The first guy had a squint in one eye! 😂

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to Elfe5

Who knows what was going on! I am inclined to trust the 2nd woman - she seemed more sensible! She said that most people mildly pronate, and that running on a treadmill can cause your gait to change...pffft! Sick of it! Going to go with what feels right. 😁 x

Hidden
Hidden

Lovely! I love reading your posts about your running-shoe love affair :)

Funny what you say about gait analysis. When, to my shame, I couldn't get the hang of treadmill running, the chap just looked at me walking and declared that I under-pronate, which makes sense. I'd come to that conclusion from my own research. I'm skeptical about these fancy treadmill/camera setups. In the end I just got myself some inserts, and it's all good!

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to Hidden

Seriously? He was having you on, surely? Can you tell if someone under pronates by looking at them walking?! I swear these people are making it up as they are going along...😂

Hidden
Hidden in reply to Sadie-runs

Well apparently you can, because they put the weight on the outside of their foot, and on their heel, as I naturally do, because of the high arch, no point putting weight on a bit of foot that isn't there.

I asked him would I risk injury by continuing to run in the trainers I had, and he said most probably not, so I'm really not sure why they bother with gait analysis at all lol! I was really embarassed that I couldn't get the hang of the treadmill though :/

Sqkr
Sqkr in reply to Sadie-runs

You can see my pronation issues when I'm stood still 😂

A man ran past me yesterday when I walked home from work and he was over-pronating so badly in his running shoes that I genuinely worried for his ankles 😣 I think gait analysis is interesting if you don't know much about the mechanics of feet, as would be the case for the majority of new runners I would have thought. It helps you narrow down the endless wall of shoe options too! I ended up feeling I could trust my shop as without giving anything away to them at all they were able to spot my hypermobility and also made me try on four different pairs of shoes, and talked me through the slow motion video of me running in each. It took about forty minutes, and although I'd gone in saying I'd be happy to walk out without shoes if I didn't like their sales approach I felt confident enough to buy the second pair I tried on. I think there's also a lot to be said for a shop that will accept a 30 day return on a shoe they have recommended, used or otherwise! I suspect the trustworthiness of each shop can vary dramatically however, and enthusiasm is also no substitute for knowledge...

I have had a pair of cloudflyers in an online basket for weeks now. This chat is not helping me resist!

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10

Glad to hear you have had a good experience - I think I have just been unlucky! I’ll let you know how I get on with my On shoes once I get them. They are supposed to be good for any gait...but maybe not severe over pronators?

I was having lots of Achilles problems running and a friend advised me to consult a sports podiatrist (this was in France). He spent 30 mins analysing me and then custom made some insoles for me. I then bought some neutral running shoes and used theses insoles - - the problem is solved ! The insoles were not cheap but worth every penny/€ :-)

ju-ju-
ju-ju-Graduate10

Finally, you will get your shoes.... and that’s interesting re the gait analysis...

Sadie-runs
Sadie-runsGraduate10 in reply to ju-ju-

There is definitely a place for it (gait analysis) - but for someone who is 98% neutral, I don’t half get cheesed off with conflicting opinions! It’s like they are looking for probs where there are none! And I am beside myself with anticipation of me new runners, ju-ju. 😁

mrrun
mrrunGraduate10

My size 11 spades looking as if put together by a hapless sculptor, definitely need proper analysis and l went to a place run by runners who look after you, a lab if you wish. They saw me three times, each time different people, and got it right every time. Hence me running like an agitated gazelle, pain free, wind in the hair.

You may also like...