Neuro Physiothreapists any good?

I have been having walking problems which have become worse over the last year. I saw my GP and she gave me some back exercises to do. Which i tried (no use) She also talked about refairing me to a physiothreapist. I have never had much benifit from physio so i asked her is there was anything else. She said there wasa neuro physio but cuts being what they are...

So i offered to pay and she said try the excercises and if no use you can see a neuro physio.

So my question do people get much benifit from them? I dont mind paying but i am reluctant to spend maybe £100s for no benifit.

15 Replies

oldestnewest
  • I had been seeing a neurophysio a couple of years ago and found it reasonably helpful. Shortly afterwards I was reffered into hospital as an in-patient for rehabilitation for five weeks. I found this to be more beneficial as the programme included Intensive physiotherapy, hand therapy, relaxation techniques and psychological assesment. The outcome was very positive as I learned to control my motor movements much better integrated with positive thinking. I gained more self confidence and I can now walk with both a rollator/walker and elbow crutches very easilly now. Without them I lurch and stagger putting my safety at a higher risk. The progress I made while in hospital has helped me immesely. I believe slowing down has been the key to my success. The treatment I recieved was from the NHS and I can't thank them enough for their help.

  • Hello "albion"

    I think Neurological Physiotherapy is very important in finding out what

    exactly is the cause of your Ataxia.

    PROBLEM: how to find a competent Neurological Physiotherapist

    Maybe "Ataxia UK" could publish a list.

    I think I have been lucky in finding a competent doctor - though his

    diagnose didn´t make me happy at all:

    I was diagnosed with ".Autosomal Dominant Cerebellar Atrophy " - a

    diagnose which was confirmed by Magnetic Resonance Tomography of

    the brain

    Regards

    PS "albion" you forgot to tag your question

    Tags are like helpful labels that allow you to find useful posts quickly.

  • For several years I have seen a neuro-physio. I see her every 8 weeks. I am very lucky. She is brilliant. She is private and was recommended by the local speech therapist. She changes my exercises and concentrates on whatever is a problem at the time.

    Although ataxia knowledge is useful, neuro-physios deal with stroke victims, etc, so are very aware of our difficulties. Just try to find one that someone recommends or otherwise keep changing till you are happy.

    Good luck.

  • Hello "Litty",

    I´m not sure which SCA I´m suffering from.

    Actually, I don´t care much - since there is no remedy

    anyway.

    In hospital they diagnosed me with ".Autosomal Dominant Cerebellar Atrophy "

    and strongly advised me to use a rollator.

    I have seen a neuro-therapist twice a week since 1997 . Although

    I think her brilliant as well there might well be new ideas with

    your therapist.

    So, please mail some of the exercises.

    Yours

    Jurgen

  • Hello there

    To be honest I do not think my exercises would be of any real use. They change every time and are specific to my body at the time and it's particular problems. They are also after she has stretched me and tried to see what I am capable of doing. I would not feel very happy giving specific advise that might injure or hurt someone else.

    I do think these general ones are quite good though

    ataxia.org/pdf/Coordinative...

    Hope it helps.

  • Yes, it did help.

    Thank you

  • Hi Albion

    As I am sure you are aware, physiotherapy is essential for people with ataxia. It is not a curative therapy but more about maximising the function you have. It is the physiotherapists's role to give a program of exercises that are suitable for the individual and to ensure those exercises are being carried out properly and safely. It is the patient's role to perform those exercises regularly and, if advised by the physiotherapist, to carry them out daily.

    As I am sure you also know a neurophysiotherapist is a physiotherapist who specialises in neurological conditions. They are much more likely than generic physiotherapists to be able to recommend exercises and formulate a physio program that is tailored to a person with ataxia. Neurophysios understand the specific problems people with neurological problems face and this is often evident by the techniques and exercises that they recommend.

    My own experience with physio has been positive. In fact I went from being a 'high falls risk' to a 'medium falls risk'. I think not because my ataxia improved per se, but thinking about the way I move translating into the way I actually do move has improved. I have been formally discharged from physiotherapy for the moment but know I will be referred back if necessary.

    I continue with the exercises that were recommended for me (everyone is different) which, I feel, continue to be helpful. I have tried to incorporate them into my daily routine and try to make them as less boring as possible, for example by doing them to music.

    All in all, if I were you and the appointment is not horrendously expensive, I would see a neurophysio. It might be that you only see them once but if you don't try you won't know if it works for you.

    I hope this is of some help

    Harriet

  • I was just going to write another comment on the benefits

    of physio & the therapist´s role

    Thank you for your message.

    You write:

    "I continue with the exercises that were recommended for me (everyone is different) which, I feel, continue to be helpful. I have tried to incorporate them into my daily routine and try to make them as less boring as possible, for example by doing them to music"

    You´re right, dear Harriet. I should do my exerc. at home -

    but I´m too lazy.

    Regards.

  • In my experience - no. But when I started to see a neurophysiotherapist I was young and had only just been diagnosed so resented the therapist on principle. A bit like the dentist! But some of the things I was told help me now. If I'd have kept an open mind and my expectations were more reasonable I probably would have had a better experience.

  • Not read all the answers but I saw a Neurophysiotherapist twice in the last week, 1st visit wasn't good I had no confidence in the lady, but on Monday what she proved to me was amazing, how your brain learns from exercises and is able to correct your imbalances etc. All we used was a half blown up air cushion to stand on and it is amazing how you learn to balance on that, walking afterwards was relatively easy. I would recommend one certainly. I live nr Retford and there was never a question of cost etc here. Have a bash at getting one on the NHS again before going private !

  • I saw a neuro physio last week (with my normal physio in attendance) for an initial session, and am due to have my first examination and then hopefully therapy next week.

    Barnet hospital (north London) have been absolutely excellent in trying to help me. In fact they got me referred to my neurologist (who diagnosed me with Ataxia) in the first place. If you live close enough I can strongly recommend them.

    Any tips as to what I should tell the neuro physio? (She has treated Ataxia patients before so that is good...)

  • Ive just had my first physio session yesterday-actually the second one as the first one was taken up with just getting my history!

    The one yesterday proved to be useful-and hard work- and he's given me a programme to follow,hopefully before the NHS sessions - but no idea when these will be.

    The key discovery for me was that when my feet were held down firmly so I stopped thrashing about, I could begin to concentrate on my posture and feel what this is like when I do this properly.......He's firm but funny, which I like, and I think I'm beginning to trust him to help me.....

  • As a result of these comments I have asked the doctor and the OT to refer me to a Neurophysio.The OT has emailed me to say it has been done.I wait with bated breath.

  • Good luck Marie. Hope this helps you manage better.

  • Hello "albion",

    you forgot to tag your question.

    Is it ok by you if our Admins, Harry, tagged it ?

    *******************

    Tags are like helpful labels that allow you to find useful posts quickly. They appear at the bottom of questions and posts. When you write a post you should add relevant tags to your own posts and questions by typing them in the tag box. By clicking on a tag you will be able to find all the questions and posts that have the same tag, making browsing much easier.

    *****************

    Regards

You may also like...