Very Confused: Hi all, My neurologist says I... - Ataxia UK

Ataxia UK

4,084 members4,658 posts

Very Confused

neta profile image
neta
13 Replies

Hi all,

My neurologist says I have CA borderline MSA and gives me sad looks, He says to exercise but doesn't think it will help me much..But my PT swears that with hard work meaning exercise,, I can improve. One says the rigidiity is the disease; the other says inis mostly fear. Cantle brain really readjust?? Who should I believe/?

Written by
neta profile image
neta
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
13 Replies
nicanna profile image
nicanna

Hi Neta! I have been told I have CA by my Neurologist too so I can totally empathise with you. I have started exercising every day on a static bike to try and build my leg muscles which does seem to help me. Saying that, my balance is still bad but instead of stumbling and falling I tend to just stumble now, touch wood!! I know what your PT means by being rigid through fear because I am, especially when I'm out and about. In the house I seem to walk much better. My Physio gave me a walker to use when I'm out but I'm only 41 and don't want to use it!!! But I did use it to walk along the road, by myself!, and realised it gave me independence again! However, it still lives in the cupboard under the stairs!

I don't know if the symptoms can be reversed but I think teaching your mind and body to adjust over time helps!

Good luck, Nic x

neta profile image
neta in reply tonicanna

Dear Nic, Thanx for sharing Walkers aren't the end of the world. I wish all of our equipment was funkier looking and not so aging. Best N

Herman2301 profile image
Herman2301 in reply tonicanna

I am 46 now but 4 years ago started using a walker to give me my independence back. I took my hubby into the shop and said "what's the most expensive, I'll have that one!" then when I got home, I collapsed in a heap on the floor, in tears, thinking that was it, I was officially old! The reality is, no one notices you whatsoever! They're all too bothered with their own business. Go girl! X

neta profile image
neta in reply toHerman2301

Thanks for sharing XN

wildstyler profile image
wildstyler

Exercise is definitely the answer, it's up to you , it's not what you've got , but it's how you deal with it.

As it is genetic it would be advisable to persuade any offspring you may have to join you in exercising , so they will be prepared for what the future might hold.

neta profile image
neta in reply towildstyler

Sorry 4 the delay..thanx for your input

sunvox profile image
sunvox

Hi Neta -

Yes, the brain can readjust. It's called neuroplasticity and it's well documented. Any exercise you can do will help slow your decline.

-

Since you mention MSA I have a thought. MSA is associated with mitochondrial failures and there is a ton research on micronutrients that may improve mitochondrial health.

-

What are you taking right now?

neta profile image
neta in reply tosunvox

This whole MSA thing is very unclear and debatable. but how much work brings about a brain change ?? Now I take Amantadine thanx for your interest...N

Cerebraljon profile image
Cerebraljon

For the big picture, the neurologists see what you have and see there is no ultimate cure at present, which is harsh for us sufferers to accept, but in many ways physios are more practical, neurologists are hoping for a cure whereas a good physio will help you manage what you got and themore you know about managing your condition the more you will be able to do. Stay strong!

neta profile image
neta in reply toCerebraljon

Spot on and thanks!!,

Capricorn9157 profile image
Capricorn9157

Hi Neta. Exercising can help. My PT gave me some to do at home. I used to go to her clinic but find it is easier at home. I can do them when I can, and the ones I can - although at most I manage 3/4 a day (and cant do them every day).

They do help because it is a great satisfaction when they are done and I feel better. Whether they help physically, I dont know but mentally good.

I cant get out as I can only walk about 150 yards before having to rest, and thats using crutches, and am careful around the home - holding onto furniture or walls etc. Luckily I have a bus stop about 100 yards from my home, which helps getting to GP or hospital.

Do whatever you can, when you can and be proud of your achievements - give yourself a pat on the back :) Dont let your GP's looks get you down (I am sure he is normally 'good looking??'...lol).

There is no 'miracle cure' so we should talk to each other and learn our own limitations.

At the moment I wont give in to a wheelchair and will hold out as long as I can.

GOOD LUCK - and keep smiling :)

neta profile image
neta in reply toCapricorn9157

Sorry 4 the delay--computer woes...thanx 4 your wisdom xxxz=N

Zombi profile image
Zombi

Hello Neta, My wife has Ataxia caused by lifelong epilepsy. She was getting very depressed until we joined out local Litter picking group. She finds the activity very rewarding. Taking her time and with care she cleans out local streets. The exercise and feeling she is helping seems to invigorate her. So I would say find something you can do and go for it.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Still Confused

My PT is adamant the the brain is changeable. My neuro says that's baloney--the brain never...
neta profile image

Confused

Perhaps it is my imagination but its seems that fewer people r responding to thus page... Also...
neta profile image

Confused and very concerned

I was up until eight weeks ago a very healthy person although I have had ongoing lower back pain...
PatJean profile image

I have a question about PTs v. Neuro's

Yesterday, a PT (Australian) came to see me. There's a fundamental difference, I think, in the...
neta profile image

Feeling very tired and disorientated

Hi, was diagnosed with idiopathic late onset cerebellar ataxia back in mid December, but when I saw...
JillJ profile image

Moderation team

See all
HarryB profile image
HarryBAdministrator
VE93 profile image
VE93Administrator
WendyBom profile image
WendyBomModerator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.