Undecided as to which way to go with ... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,008 members26,183 posts

Undecided as to which way to go with rising PSA

Tied2work profile image
22 Replies

Had RP in 2006. PSA in 2007 was 0.03. PSA in 2017 was 0.152. Now at 0.698

My Urologist says I should do nothing because of elapsed time, doubling time and present PSA level. He says some cells probably have metastasized already. He feels it will never become a problem in my lifetime( I'm 75).

My RO says I have an 84% cure rate with 6 mos. ADT and 8 weeks Radiation. He feels cells are localized in the fossa. Thoughts?

Written by
Tied2work profile image
Tied2work
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

They are both right. Although I would qualify what your urologist said - you probably won't die from it, but growing metastases may be a problem. They may cause pain, fractures and spinal compression. So watchful waiting (systemic therapy to treat symptoms when they arise) or salvage radiation are both reasonable options. The question is - what do YOU want to do?

Tied2work profile image
Tied2work in reply to Tall_Allen

Probably leaning towards the radiation. At least I got a shot at getting rid of the damn thing. Just a little worried about any permanent damage from the radiation

Steve507 profile image
Steve507 in reply to Tied2work

I did salvage radiation last January. Walk in the park. Today, much much safer and focused for efficacy than 12 years ago.

TFBUNDY profile image
TFBUNDY in reply to Tall_Allen

Have you any idea why Ferrotran never made mainstream MRI contrast agent? Used effectively in Nijmegen I understand. It's finely divided nano particles of iron oxide. Seems a very good idea to me. Better than Gadolinium contrast agents. Identify those LNMs early...

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to TFBUNDY

The iron oxide nanoparticle (USPIO) they use at Radboud in Nijmegen called Combidex (ferumoxtran-10). My understanding is that they hold the patent and still use it there. Other USPIO formulations have not been successful.

cigafred profile image
cigafred in reply to TFBUNDY

The nano-iron application to the FDA was severely flawed, as explained to me by Dr. Barentsz, who runs the program at Radboud in Nijmegen where I had the scan. Among other things they did not even have a radiologist on the team that prepared the application.

GP24 profile image
GP24

You have a doubling time of 1.8 years. Therefore your PSA value could make you nervous in a few years. I would get the radiation and live without ADT in the coming years.

Tied2work profile image
Tied2work in reply to GP24

That’s what I’m leaning towards. Thx

ParrotY profile image
ParrotY in reply to GP24

Do whatever you can to avoid ADT, it's not a nice experience

psma scan to get some intel?

Tied2work profile image
Tied2work in reply to

Had the Axumin scan. As I suspected it didn’t show anything.

rscic profile image
rscic

Add a Medical Oncologist to your Medical Team.

Cancer2x profile image
Cancer2x

Same trip here. RRP in 1996. Recurrence in 2005. PSA slowly climbing, last was 0.58. Axumin negative. Wait? Treat? How, and why?

Horse12888 profile image
Horse12888

Tall Allen: I'm not getting this, and it's possible that Tied isn't either. "Localized in fossa?" Which fossa? Is this based on a scan? If he is in fact metastatic, how is it possible that there is an 84% cure rate? And how does such a precise number derive?

Channelhomec profile image
Channelhomec

Had salvage radiation no side effects ,was not that bad just holding a full bladder can be hard> had a psa of 0.14 now 0.04 hope it stays put for a while... about 2years now good luck

Tied2work profile image
Tied2work in reply to Channelhomec

Did you have ADT along with the radiation?

Channelhomec profile image
Channelhomec

NO Radiation oncologist > felt no need as of now had glesson 3+4 one small positive margin at apical> took 6 years to reach 0.14 what was your glesson #

Tied2work profile image
Tied2work in reply to Channelhomec

3+3

ImaSurvivor1 profile image
ImaSurvivor1

I think they are both right, but I think you should get a lot more information about the long term side effects of the radiation and ADT treatments. The RO "thinks" he knows where cancerous cells are, but he doesn't "know" that's where they are. I declined a similar recommendation for radiation "down there" and ADT in 2015 after my 2012 prostatectomy, but I wasn't willing to risk the likely effects of radiation and ADT for the chance that it might be a cure. Six years later my PSA has slowly risen to 0.6 with no treatment, except good diet, exercise, stress reduction, and some supplements. I've also participated in some trials and studies to get the latest radio tracer scans, and no cancer has shown up yet. If/when the ever-improving scans locate one or more tumors, I'll seek localized treatment (radiation or surgery) to get them. Meanwhile, I am having many years of great quality of life, uncompromised by debilitating effects of radiation and ADT.

Harry_B profile image
Harry_B

Suggest care and caution with radiation. I had an L3 lesion treated by SBRT which led to a compression fracture and quite a lot of pain. Now being relieved by acupuncture. I also had pelvic salvage radiation which resulted in serious bowel adhesions and then major bowel surgery to relieve two serious strictures. On the positive side, my PSA is undetectable due in large measure to the radiation therapy, chemo and ADT so its a balance. I'm not suggesting not to proceed with radiation, just to get fully informed as to the risks that apply to the treatment being proposed for you. All the best.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Quit your job and then "Buy low, Sell high".........

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Friday 09/03/2021 7:50 PM DST

Bowmaster profile image
Bowmaster

I had prostate removed 2002 and five years after that PSA came back and started going up ever since . Till 2020 it was going slowly and than I had COVID-19 and since than things started going nuts. From 12 it went to 25 than to 45 than to 79 and now it is 109 . I have never taken any meds or treatments . Just had PET PSMA scan done and things are not good . All along my doctor kept saying don't worry there is nothing . Well mow I am very worried !!! Waiting on the doctors to say what is the next step .

You may also like...

Rising PSA After Treatment

years. PSA now rising indicating a biochemical recurrence: 11 August 2017 - psa 1.65 25 August 2017...

Apalutamide and rising PSA

mathematical level, my PSA increased 50%, one can infer a 6 month doubling time. My PSA has never...

Rising PSA on taxotere

13 point drop in his PSA to 87 in September. Yesterday's lab work shows a PSA of 92 which is where

PSA rising but scans clear

no longer visible. My urologist says scans are more reliable signals than PSA and does not think any

PSA rising…..Duke Champ?

In November I posted my concerns that my psa increased from.01 to.27 after 15 months of Zytiga. Test