Malty drinks good or bad idea? - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

115,043 members61,284 posts

Malty drinks good or bad idea?

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs
27 Replies

I have given up drinking wine and am looking for a night time drink whats anyones thoughts on Horlicks or Ovaltine are the wasted calories? thanks. (I only drink soya milk)

Written by
fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly
7lbs
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
27 Replies
IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61

Only you can decide how to spend the calories you have fitbyjuly. In general, I prefer not to drink my calories, and I believe these two products are both high in sugar which is also problematic . . .

However, avoiding wine is an excellent idea, what else have you tried? I used to drink a lot of diet coke but gradually swapped it for diet tonic and now I have fizzy or plain water, with ice and lemon if I’m feeling posh 😊

I do like a milky drink, but I just use a little cinnamon or nutmeg and find the milk on its own quite sweet enough 😊

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs in reply toIndigoBlue61

Thank you I have been drinking a lot of peppermint tea which I enjoy I tend to agree with you re not drinking too many calories. I suppose I am luck as fizzy drinks are not my thing so nothing to miss there!

IndigoBlue61 profile image
IndigoBlue61 in reply tofitbyjuly

We all have our demons don’t we 😊

H61g profile image
H61g in reply tofitbyjuly

I love peppermint tea....only herbal tea I can drink

anigoni profile image
anigoni2 stone

Hi there.. I use barley cup and add a splash of milk or just have milk alone with a few spices.. I don't have hot chocolate any more as that keeps me awake.. and I do have horlicks if my calorie limit allows.. but if not, I just have plain water.. sometimes I have boiling water with lemon in it and a dash of ginger... I like experimenting and feel it is important to have alcohol free days to allow your liver to recover and begin working on all that fat I am trying to lose..

Good luck. :-)

Misslovely profile image
Misslovely

Hi fitbyjuly

If i REALLY want a milky drink i tend to go for Cadburys highlights - but its not often & i sometimes have a Tea which is called Pukka Night Time and this seems to help

me sleep a little more restful

xxx

Marple_J profile image
Marple_J2lbs in reply toMisslovely

I have the pukka night time drink too. I find it nice and soothing before bed. I drink a lot of their flavours including Peppermint and green which I really like. I'm going to get some of those highlight drinks, not thought of those. I looked on this thread to check out people's replies as it was I query I also had ☺

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs in reply toMisslovely

Thanks I will look out for the pukka tea.

Iwilldothisthisyear profile image
Iwilldothisthisyear1kgRestart Oct 2024Restart Feb 2024 in reply toMisslovely

I have been having the night time tea and it has really helped with my not sleeping issue . The only problem I have is that it makes my cats loopy (think crack cocaine level catnip) so I have to share the cup with them 🤭

mcmarvyn profile image
mcmarvyn

Options Hot Chocolate- really, really nice and very low calorie. Cheapest in Iceland usually

My cardiologist tols me that teh ccasional (weekly, his words) are absolutely fine, so I don't drink on school nights but maybe a glass on either Saturday or Sunday is fine for me :)

PandQs profile image
PandQsMaintainer3st 7lbs in reply to

Hi Fredbeare, see my reply to OneandTwo below, re video of Dr Robert Lustig discussing benefit of small amount of red wine

0neandTw0 profile image
0neandTw0

Find all this very interesting! So there's an assumption that drinking [red] wine is a No No??

I'd love to have your views on this as it's my EOD treat.

PandQs profile image
PandQsMaintainer3st 7lbs in reply to0neandTw0

I’ve been very impressed by the work of Dr Robert Lustig especially his “Skinny on Obesity” series of videos. I’ve been following LCHF since viewing them. This is a Q&A session with him where about 4.5 minutes in he discusses alcohol, red wine vs beer which is interesting if you are following the same way of eating, but I recommend watching the whole thing, not just that segment.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=Rj8uQ...

TTandRW profile image
TTandRW

Robinson’s have a range of lovely drinks I found at Christmas. I have them in hot water the flavours are 1. Crushed Apple and cinnamon 2. Raspberry rhubarb and orange blossom 3. Crushed lime and mint.

I’m not a fan of fruit teas etc and don’t like a lot of cold drinks but these are lovely hot as a comforting drink but are also nice cold.

I’ve just checked calories and it works out at about 43 calories if you add 35/36mls of cordial to each 200/250ml water.

There’s 14 servings in a bottle if you use 35/36 mls for each drink as it says on the bottle.

This is quite a strong flavour so you could use a bit less if you wanted to reduce calories etc.

It may sound a lot of calories for a drink but personally I think the flavours are worth it as I’m not keen on other cordials.

The sugar per serving is between 9.5 - 11g (12%) which is amber on the traffic light system.

lm not sure how this would fit into a strict or diabetic diet but in moderation I’m enjoying it in my regime and it’s encouraging me to drink more fluid.

It can be diluted further to lessen the calories and still be just as tasty.

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs in reply toTTandRW

Tried one flavour the Rhubarb Raspberry and Orange is sooooo nice and I like the petit bottle too makes it feel like a real treat.

BunnyTummyLumpy profile image
BunnyTummyLumpy

Must check out Robinson’s. I also like cinnamon tea....the Indian type. Nice in winter. I also have a small cup of pure cocoa on very cold nights.

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs in reply toBunnyTummyLumpy

Some other group members have mentioned pure cocoa sound nice, thank you.

I have chamomile and lime flower tea from the cheap supermarket beginning with A! Its lovely, very mellow especially of a night time.

Have you tried a few squares pf dark chocolate in an a small cup of hot milk? If you really wanted a milky drink then that might work.

Craftyperson profile image
Craftyperson

How about just warm milk or maybe with a bit of cinnamon or nutmeg in or dissolve a few pieces of good quality dark chocolate

BerlinBetty profile image
BerlinBettyVisitor

Hello fitbyjuly. I'm going to be a wee bit controversial here. Yes, these two hot drink products are now choc-full of sugar - far more than is needed to make a decent night-time cuppa, and perhaps therefore best avoided? However, I'm going to part company with folk who with the very best of intentions are guiding you towards various teas/tissanes etc. This is not because they aren't nice enough in their own way but they just don't satisfy in the same way, if you have been brought up, as I was, on the wisdom of a milky drink at night, which takes the blood towards the digestive system rather than the head, so helping you get off to sleep, and which lines the tum benignly. Can I suggest that you try two or three pieces of really good dark chocolate melted gently into a pan of 60% milk, 40% water (don't get up-tight about measurements). This does make a very nice hot chocolate. Or invest in a classy cocoa powder; even the strong ones contain some sugar - but nothing like what commercial hot chocolate contains.

Replacing the malt-based drinks is much more problematic. I can remember Ovaltine used to be very malty but not too sweet, so very satisfying. Now it's so sweet as to be very sickly, and of course not what we slimmers need at all. Perhaps try the home-made chocolate option? There used to be a thing called 'posset' (aging myself now), which involved whisking an egg into some hot milk with a small spoonful of treacle. Yes, sweet, but I bet not as much so as the stuff they sell us now.

I'm not knocking tissanes folks, but there's nothing wrong with a warm milky drink either, providing that we can find something to flavour it which doesn't involve a mountain-sized sugar-rush!

BB x

13Valerie profile image
13Valerie in reply toBerlinBetty

Fab idea Betty! Melting a square of dark chocolate into almond milk will be my night time drink tonight... Sweet dreams!

fitbyjuly profile image
fitbyjuly7lbs in reply toBerlinBetty

Yes sugar rush at bedtime isn't a great idea I think I will stick to hot water with lemon or mint tea earlier on in the evening .

13Valerie profile image
13Valerie

A milky drink made on unsweetened almond milk has the least calories. I'm becoming quite a fan of herbal teas too!

Rhys00 profile image
Rhys00

i drink ovaltine with no sugar as it contains vitimins and minerals which the body needs. i have excluded this drink from my calories as i think what i eat im not having the right vitmin and mineral

Subtle_badger profile image
Subtle_badger in reply toRhys00

I can't find any "ovaltine with no sugar". Ovaltine Light is mostly sugar, the main ingredient being being malt extract (which is sugar), the second ingredient is skim milk, which is largely sugar and the third is glucose, which is literally sugar.

Ovaltine lite is sugar.

Don't drink it. It's not doing you any good. If you need vitamins, get them from your food. If you aren't sure you can, then get multivitamins. If you shop around, you can usually find them at less than 4 p/day. Cheaper than ovaltine, and with no sugar.

Rhys00 profile image
Rhys00 in reply toSubtle_badger

You cannot actually avoid sugar. Most things cintains natural sugars. I will still drink ovaltine as i prefer it. And iprefer a hot drink over food many times.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Oatcakes...good or bad?

Hi, any help would be appreciated. I plan on eating these oatcakes for my food for today. If I add...
Daffodil17 profile image

Diet Drinks

Can anybody out there please help me. I drink loads of it ....maybe that`s a lot of my problem??? I...
ollio profile image

Kicking the fizzy drinks

Okay, so ashamedly, I am struggling to kick the fizzy drink habit. My parents weren't hot on it as...
Fit-ishPlum profile image

Is flavoured water good or bad when trying to lose weight

The reason i ask is because i struggle to drink plain water
louise67 profile image

smoothie good or bad

Hi peeps my question for today is a smoothie the best thing to have in the morning for breakfast or...
gizmo33 profile image

Moderation team

See all
BridgeGirl profile image
BridgeGirlAdministrator
TheTabbyCat profile image
TheTabbyCatAdministrator
TeamAdmin profile image
TeamAdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.