Cellular T3 & cortisol : I must add the following... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,242 members166,488 posts

Cellular T3 & cortisol

18 Replies

I must add the following edit since I have researched this question after links were kindly provided - this is what I now understand:

Low cortisol causes T3 to work less effectively within the cells. This is because T3 and cortisol are partners within our cells. High cortisol also causes problems and can reduce the effectiveness of T3 within the cells, hence thyroid patients with high cortisol often complain of feeling hypothyroid even when they appear to have reasonable FT3 levels. When patients try to raise T3 levels in the presence of low cortisol, they may find that the body compensates for low cortisol by producing more adrenaline. This can cause anxiety, rapid heart rate, the feeling of heart palpitations etc. This is usually the adrenaline response rather than a direct issue with the T3. Very often, it is the low cortisol that is at the root. (Paul Robinson website)

I am currently reading Peatfield’s book.

He suggests that low cortisol can make thyroid medications either

a. Ineffective

b. Make things worse.

It explains that cortisol facilitates T3 access to the cell, this is the reason given for why low cortisol causes problems. 

However, how can thyroid hormone make things worse if there isn’t access to the cell? Surely T3 is either in the cell, or it’s not. And if someone suffers negative reactions from t3 containing medications (as I do) then surely this suggests that the t3 is indeed getting into the cell, otherwise how come a reaction at all? I’m confused.

I’ve come across many resources that site the same, along these lines: 

Whatever you may be told, adrenal insufficiency in thyroid disorders is very common indeed and should always be considered at the onset of treatment. Failure to respond to thyroid supplementation, or actually feeling less well, is likely more often than not to involve the low adrenal reserve syndrome. (Peatfield “how to look after your thyroid”)

If, upon starting NDT, you experience symptoms, including anxiety, insomnia, shakiness, sweating, dizziness, feeling spaced out its a strong sign that you may need adrenal support. (Tpauk website)

So, I’m confused… in the case where T3 is causing MORE problems (and over medication and raising too fast is ruled out) how can it be low cortisol preventing T3 to access the cells? Surely where more problems are appearing, the T3 is almost certainly getting access to create these symptoms.

All wisdom welcomed!

Read more about...

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

18 Replies
humanbean profile image
humanbean

You might find this link (and the rest of the website) of interest:

hormonerestoration.com/Cort...

And this link might be helpful, although you'll have to search for what you want:

hormonesmatter.com/

In the above site the man who runs it is obsessed with thiamine (vitamin B1) but he covers other hormone and nutrition related stuff too.

This might be useful too:

paulrobinsonthyroid.com/t3-...

in reply tohumanbean

died and gone to heaven! Thank you

Pinkpanther2022 profile image
Pinkpanther2022

could this be why i get palpitations with b vitamin supplements?

samaja profile image
samaja

If you read Paul Robinson's The Thyroid Patient's Manual he actually explains in detail the whole physiological mechanism of what happens in the case of hypocortisolism and how it affects T3 and other thyroid medications.

in reply tosamaja

I have his book, but I haven’t been able to find anything in the book that explicitly explains how it works. Maybe I have the wrong book. I might add also that Paul gave me direct advice on how to manage getting off T3 and it made me unforgivably ill so I prefer to engage in his work very sparingly. In the absence of anyone else providing much of a useful explanation, I will have to read his blog, but couldn’t face supporting him by buying another of his books.

greygoose profile image
greygoose

Well, sorry, interesting as that explanation is, it does not address your original question because it assumes that the T3 is getting into the cells, and what it does there. It doesn't say anything about low/high cortisol preventing T3 getting into the cells.

in reply togreygoose

No, Paul Robinson argues that low cortisol doesn’t stop T3 getting into the cells at all. He says that low cortisol and T3 work together in the cell, and in fact if anything stops the cell up taking T3 it is high cortisol.

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to

ok :)

in reply togreygoose

STTM say something different… *sigh* and the confusion rolls on 😊

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply to

Well, they're the last people I'd trust! Totally not up-to-date with their information.

in reply togreygoose

yes I think you’re bang on there x

diogenes I was wondering whether you had an opinion on this… how co-factors often discussed (Eg. fe, b12, b9, D) and cortisol interact with thyroid hormone in cases where people are unable to “tolerate” thyroid hormones… I wondered if you thought it was “pooling” like STTM say (the thyroid hormone doesn’t access the cell at all and “pools” in the serum outside the cell. Or whether it’s that insufficient cortisol inside of the cell is the problem, which is the argument Paul Robinson suggests. If you have the time or inclination I’d be so interested to hear your thoughts… so far I’ve failed to find anything clear on this matter and I think it holds a significant key in treatment.

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply to

No such thing as pooling. If something doesn't enter the cells it is flushed out through kidneys etc. Its all an aspect of hormonal control. Paul Robinson's concept is best.

in reply todiogenes

thanks so much for you time. Do you have a theory about what is going on in cases of “intolerance” (anxiety, agitation, flu-like symptoms) when some people try to take thyroid hormones.

diogenes profile image
diogenesRemembering in reply to

I don't have a good explanation, except that too much hormone can give anxiety and feverishness.

Joyya here is the post I made trying to understand the cortisol-thyroid hormone connection, hope it helps a little 😊

Joyya profile image
Joyya in reply to

Thanks. Will read it

TiggerMe here you go :)

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

T3 and dropping cortisol levels

Since starting on T3 6 weeks ago my morning cortisol level has dropped. I know that Paul Robinson...
Pearlteapot profile image

Some info on cortisol.

Read an interesting article today, thought I'd post basics. Link at the bottom for whole article....
Katepots profile image

Should I take adrenal support? - Hashimotos.

After a couple of years of being on thyroid medication (T4 then NDT then T4+T3) and it seemingly...
HarrietJW profile image

Effects of thyroid medication, T4/T3 on exhausted adrenal - resulting in RT3 and Thyroid binding globulin

Low Thyroid Function Due to Adrenal Fatigue Hypothyroidism can be primary or secondary. Primary...
cc120 profile image

Help with insight into cortisol test

I just ordered a saliva cortisol test because of symptoms I've been having for a few months now...
silverequus profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.