Correct dose for Thyroid S compared ot Natureth... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,809 members161,637 posts

Correct dose for Thyroid S compared ot Naturethroid.

archipoeta profile image
19 Replies

Hello.

I used to take 1.75 grains (113.75 mcg) Naturethroid when it still worked.

What's the equivalent of Thyroid S? What have people found.

I've been managing since I ran out of Naturethroid on alternate days of 1 gr and 1.25 gr of Armour, a nibble of T4 and .25/50 grain of NP at nights, depending on how I felt. i know it's not ideal - I swing between slumpy and slightly jumpy - but it's been a lot better than nothing

Hopefully establishing a proper dosage will bring some stability.

Written by
archipoeta profile image
archipoeta
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
19 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

archipoeta

They are both said to have the same amount of hormone content per 1 grain: T4 - 38mcg, T3 - 9mcg.

So try a straight swap with your Naturethroid dose and see how it goes.

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to SeasideSusie

Thank you, dear Susie!

tulipsfromamsterdam profile image
tulipsfromamsterdam in reply to SeasideSusie

I thought one grain had t4 38mcg and 9mcg of T3

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to tulipsfromamsterdam

Yes, you are correct, that is a typo. I will correct it.

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply to SeasideSusie

archipoeta

I made a typo with the amount of T4 in one grain, I have corrected it now.

T4 = 38mcg, T3 = 9 mcg.

Thyroid-S has a lot more fillers than Naturethroid so may not be absorbed the same way. You have to experiment to see if they work the same or if you need slightly more Thyroid-S.But, why are you alternating between 1 and 1.25 of Armour and 25/50 of NT? It´s usually recommended to take the same amount of T3 every day due to its short-life.

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to

One grain wasn't enough, one and a quarter too much, if I took either dosage for any length of time. I added a nibble of T3, and had another nibble if I felt slumpy later.

TSH110 profile image
TSH110

I found Naturethroid slightly less potent than thyroid S, but that was the old version of both so it probably doesn’t apply any more. I didn’t find a huge difference to be honest.

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to TSH110

Thank you very much!

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to TSH110

What do you take now?

TSH110 profile image
TSH110 in reply to archipoeta

ThyroidS 1.75 grains

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to TSH110

How do you divide the grain?

TSH110 profile image
TSH110 in reply to archipoeta

Teeth

in reply to TSH110

that was the old version of both

Has it been confirmed that Thyroid-S has been reformulated?

TSH110 profile image
TSH110 in reply to

Don’t know but I have old stock pre it getting hard to source so it was the original formulation. Some say the newer batches are less potent. But it may be the same recipe as before. Would be interesting to know for sure.

in reply to TSH110

Unfortunately, I don´t think we will ever know as Thai manufacturers don´t seem to make that kind of info public.

serenfach profile image
serenfach

I found Thyroid S worked better for me, same dose at the time. Currently on two in the morning and one at night. Brilliant dreams!

archipoeta profile image
archipoeta in reply to serenfach

Thank you very much!

TSH110 profile image
TSH110 in reply to serenfach

Sounds good! I take all of mine am. All at night and I find it hard to sleep never thought to split it like you are doing. I had to at first into two doses am and pm but found after a couple of years taking it all at once was fine. I very rarely remember my dreams I fall asleep too fast and wake up too slowly to have any recall!

You may also like...

Naturethroid and thyroid s

Hello I've been reading about the ineffectiveness of the new batch of naturethroid. I bought a 6...

Thyroid-S compared to Armour?

like to move to Armour or one of the other brands of NDT. Someone has recommended Thyroid S to me...

Naturethroid to thyroid-s

Hi I have ordered thyroid - s, currently been taking nature throid, 3 grains which I take all at...

Is Thyroid-S stronger than Naturethroid?

any opinions whether they think Thyroid-S is stronger than Naturethroid? Love to all, Sheenah

No Thyroid (thyroid cancer) Naturethroid/Metavive

I have been using Naturethroid for a few years, which started off well. However like a lot of...