Best FORMS not BRANDS of magnesium, please. The... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,243 members166,489 posts

Best FORMS not BRANDS of magnesium, please. Their efficacy, bioavailability and safety too

Noelnoel profile image
15 Replies

I’ve just read a post which asks for magnesium recommendations. I was about to recommend my brand, TOGETHER but thought I’d better do a bit of research first and now I’m confused. The brand I take is naturally sourced from the sea and claims to be easily absorbed (bioavailable) but contains the oxide form of magnesium in a high proportion, which is said to be one of the least bioavailable. The wording in the blurb though seems to suggest that because it’s naturally sourced and not synthetically made in a lab and contains four other natural forms, that our bodies recognise and utilise (yes I know, s instead of z. Call me old fashioned) it more readily

Please, only those who actually really do know and understand the science regarding different forms of magnesium. I.e., oxide, citrate, glycinate, chelates, etc. Also, the differences between natural and synthetic

Than you

Written by
Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
15 Replies
jimh111 profile image
jimh111

I'll stick to the limits of my knowledge. One of the most readily absorbed forms and natural is water with a high magnesium content. If I buy mineral water I always check the composition. This is backed up by studies, often from Scandinavia where similar towns are on different sides of a mountain with low and high magnesium content result in different rates of cardiac mortality.

I know oxide is very poorly absorbed and hydroxide not much better. I don't know how 'synthetic' forms of magnesium are made but e.g. Mg(OH)2 is Mg(OH)2 whether it comes from a lab or from the sky. I suspect the 'synthetic' forms are simply mined and refined, I don't know.

As for our bodies recognizing 'natural' forms this is plainly nonsense. Magnesium form and content veries so much around the globe (and locally) that there is no one 'natural' form that the body could recognize. What happens if a native of Epsom moves out of town, will their bodies fail to recognize magnesium salts that are not sulphates?

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

Noelnoel

Please, only those who actually really do know and understand the science regarding different forms of magnesium.

Well, I don't know if there is anyone on the forum who is suitably qualified to meet your requirements.

I can offer you links to articles which explain the different forms of magnesium and what they're useful for which you might find helpful:

naturalnews.com/046401_magn...

drjockers.com/best-magnesiu...

afibbers.org/magnesium.html

Other than that, maybe do your own research as there's probably plenty more out there and you'll be able to satisfy yourself with information from what you regard as reliable sites rather than rely on what information lay people here can offer you.

Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel in reply toSeasideSusie

Thank you SeasideSusie and jimh111. I read the links when they we’re posted and found inconsistencies but they we’re nevertheless helpful. I thought perhaps there may be scientist among us who could offer definitive info. The internet is very useful too but also very confusing. I think until I find a better one, I’ll stick to what I know. I have no idea how well or badly I absorb it but what I do know, is on the occasions I’ve gone without it for more than about 8 days, my sleep begins to deteriorate

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply toNoelnoel

If it suits you then there doesn't seem to be any reason to change. I do know that magnesium oxide is said to have laxative properties but you'll soon know about that if it's a problem!

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toSeasideSusie

I thought that was magnesium citrate…

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply togreygoose

Yes, mag citrate does have laxative properties (I use it for that reason) but mag oxide can be used for this purpose too (although I'd go for citrate)

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel in reply toSeasideSusie

Thank you SeasideSusie. I’ve now emailed TOGETHER, let’s see if they can explain their claims ...

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toSeasideSusie

Oh, really? I didn't know that. You learn something new every day! :)

Batty1 profile image
Batty1 in reply toSeasideSusie

Grey goose had a post earlier talking about different magnesium

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply toBatty1

The links in the first reply I posted to Noelnoel are all sites which explain what the different forms of magnesium are suitable for.

Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel

Thank you Scrumbler for the name and yes, SeasideSusie, in someone else’s post - and possibly mine too - provided three very useful links

Re shouting, I find that using it sparingly and wisely discourages wafflers. The few replies I’ve had have been very informative, which is exactly what I wanted. I know that people usually mean well but it’s time-consuming and mostly unproductive to read so many and then thank everyone. Also, the order in which replies arrive becomes confusing and the original question gets lost; we then end up responding to replies that have no relationship to the question. Very frustrating

However, please let me stress that I realise members of this forum are doing their best to offer help and for that, I’m grateful

Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel

It’s both! I can confirm with great vehemence ☺️

I.e., your reply to greygoose, came to me, not her

greygoose profile image
greygoose in reply toNoelnoel

No, it came to me:

Scrumbler in reply to greygoose

I was notified, and that's the way it works.

greygoose profile image
greygoose

Don't blame you. :)

Noelnoel profile image
Noelnoel

I haven’t yet got out of mine!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Magnesium

Hi all. Just a quickie to ask if anybody can direct me to a source of organic form magnesium...
MrsRaven profile image

Magnesium Oxide

Looking to take Magnesium Oxide but struggling to find any tablets that aren't giant size. Does...
dinahdough profile image

Magnesium CAUSING muscle cramps

Forgive the capitals. I have found the sweet spot for magnesium supplementation for constipation...
SteveT3 profile image

pros and cons of various brands of porcine and bovine NDT

Sorry if this has been asked/discussed before. I am currently trying to look at all alternatives...

Best Selenium and Magnesium supplements to buy

I want to try adding some selenium and magnesium to see if I can improve my health, underactive...
carer999 profile image

Moderation team

See all
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.