Armour vs. ERFA: Good morning all. Three weeks... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,786 members161,598 posts

Armour vs. ERFA

credgrave profile image
7 Replies

Good morning all.

Three weeks ago I changed my script from Armour to ERFA largely for financial reasons. One of the symptoms that started me on this whole journey last summer with Armour NDT, aside from the physical list, is something I call my black head.

It’s a very dark, transparent mind-set that says I am disappearing, don’t belong here and I don’t want to do this life anymore.

It looks to anyone around me that I am fine, if a little quiet, but inside its exhausting trying to keep that voice from getting an upper hand.

And it had pretty much gone with 3 x 1/2gr of Armour for nine months along with many physical symptoms. My blood tests are much better. I was just running out of money.

Three weeks on ERFA, the dark mind is slowly seeping back in, and the last 5 days has been noticeably worse.

Then I remembered hearing ERFA is not as strong as Armour but the bottle specifically says do not exceed stated dose which is still 3 x 1/2gr.

So my question is would it be okay to increase to 4 x 1/2gr a day and see if that has an effect?

I could just do it, but wanted to check if there was a reason the bottle says do not exceed... Your feedback would be very much appreciated.

Written by
credgrave profile image
credgrave
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

With NDT you need what you need. Some people are on 4 grains, so your 3 x 1/2 grain is quite a low dose. You could try adding 1/4 grain and see how that goes. If you feel you need more in a couple of weeks, add another 1/4 grain.

credgrave profile image
credgrave in reply to SeasideSusie

Thank you for a very suggestion.

Much appreciated.

researcherUK profile image
researcherUK

I don't think you need to increase by 1 grain in one go.

ERFA is slightly weaker than Armour

Armour 1grain: 38 mcg T4 and 9 mcg T3

ERFA 1 grain: 35 mcg T4 and 8 mcg T3

I would personally add 1/4 grain first and see how you feel. Sometimes, a slight adjustment can make a difference.

credgrave profile image
credgrave in reply to researcherUK

Brilliant. Two suggestions in agreement. I will try adding 1/4 to my day and see how it goes.

Much appreciated!

Rapunzel profile image
Rapunzel

thyrophoenix.com/adjusting_...

:)

credgrave profile image
credgrave in reply to Rapunzel

Wow. Thank you for this link. I've not read such a good case for taking my time. I am frightened and was really enjoying feeling good this last nine months. Who would choose to go back to feeling all that dark stuff again when maybe a pill would stop it. In my experience there is always a compromise in every outcome. Perhaps I will give it a bit more time first and then try another 1/4gr if I still feel like this. I appreciate your reply Rapunzel. Thanks. Food for thought

Rapunzel profile image
Rapunzel

Smashing isn't it? Just paying it forward...someone posted this for me, years ago...glad it may help :)

You may also like...

Armour vs Erfa (never-ending story...)

One only believes in Armour, the other one will prescribe Armour or Erfa, depending on the...

Armour vs Erfa

experience on Erfa and I would be grateful if anyone could pass on (via PM), the ERFA supplier...

Erfa or Armour

about the above NDT's. I am currently on Armour but is very expensive, have found Erfa cheaper in...

Changed from Erfa to Armour now getting headaches

Everyone Ran out of Erfa and could not get supplies quickly so managed to get some Armour. I had...

switch from Erfa to Armour...?

wonder: has anyone successfully switched from Erfa to Armour? I would hesitate to switch, now that...