Debate in Scotland: I've just finished listening... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,947 members166,079 posts

Debate in Scotland

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator
34 Replies

I've just finished listening and it was a very good debate. I don't know the name of the last speaker but obviously she isn't hypo and may not know anyone who is and more or less said we shouldn't self-medicate as it could be dangerous (or words to that effect). She doesn't realise we do so out of desperation. The Minister before her did speak, and he had received an email from a relative whose thyroid gland was removed some years ago (maybe 4 not sure) and she's texted him (I think just before the debate) that she was on 400mcg of levothyroxine all that time, and then GP reduced, and reduced and now he's told her she doesn't need levo AT ALL. He said she is extremely ill. He will probably look into the matter and Elaine Smith, MP is hypo herself, so slow but sure steps hopefully. The problem is they quoted the BTA etc etc and I doubt the MP knows most on this forum know far more about suffering than they do especially by stating that levothyroxine is the hormone of choice - they're choice not ours.

I'd still be ill as many on this forum would be if we didn't research search and some lucky enough to see knowledgeable, sympathetic doctors (few are around these days as most have retired) and alternative to T4. It's all very well saying that the BTA and doctors know best - little does she know and she doesn't realise it isn't dangerous as it is hormones. If we took a double dose by mistake, we'd definitely not do that again.

Written by
shaws profile image
shaws
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
34 Replies
Hillwoman profile image
Hillwoman

I missed the first part of the debate, so didn't hear Elaine Smith's speech. My impressions of what the last speaker said - I think she was actually the govt health minister - are similar to yours. It was an example of a politician falling back on statements from the very professionals who are being criticised. It's happened before with other issues. At least the debate will continue with ES's involvement, and there is still the committee report to come.

The MSP who spoke about his relative said she'd been on T4&T3 combo after TT, then T4 only at 300 mcg, and now on nothing at all. That woman will become very ill indeed.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toHillwoman

If I can find out her name of the Health Minister I will write to her.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toshaws

The Minister of Health's picture doesn't look like the same person.

Hillwoman profile image
Hillwoman in reply toshaws

Oh dear. There will probably be a list of contributors somewhere.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toHillwoman

I think so. So I will have a look tomorrow.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toshaws

One thing was positive that Dr Midgeley was mentioned.

SeasideSusie marigold22

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply toshaws

Yes, I noticed that, along with some positive stuff from Toft.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toSeasideSusie

Oh! if only Dr S was still here he would have also provided enough evidence solely on his treatment/care of hypo patients.

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering in reply toshaws

Indeed :(

in reply toshaws

Shona Robison

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply to

The last women speaking wasn't Shona Robison....off to check her name!

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply toDippyDame

The last speaker was Aileen Campbell MSP Minister for Health and Sport who supports Shona Robison the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Sport.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toDippyDame

Thanks very much.

in reply toDippyDame

OK sorry I got it wrong, thanks.

marigold22 profile image
marigold22

It is all so incredibly protracted. I'm not able to watch it on video now as it makes me angry. The people who verbally oppose Lorraine and Elaine do not know the correct facts.

SeasideSusie profile image
SeasideSusieRemembering

I was watching it but it kept cutting out and I had to keep getting it back. Was on my tablet, my PC monitor doesn't have speakers. Unfortunately, I lost it when the last but one member was speaking (mentioning his relative) so I missed the last speaker - possibly for the best, I might have got a bit worked up!

All in all I thought it was very good, let's hope some good comes of it.

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toSeasideSusie

She is going to get a response from me - I shall have to be 'gentle' and just give her a few facts about listening to BTA et al.

I shall recommend that she might find out more from this forum than all the print-outs from BTA et al.

t3rcam profile image
t3rcam

I totally agree Shaws. I think we should all email the last speaker with our experiences. She needs some educating!

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply tot3rcam

Gently, gently does it. Before we were hypo we listened and took doctors advice. When she gets to the stage that she becomes hypo she will change her mind if she doesn't recover on T4. We have some members on here who have and are well on levo, even if it surprises (or astonishes) us. :)

Ooo I missed this - can anyone tell me if I can find it online?

in reply to

cracker10 Here it is youtube.com/watch?v=-ziACR_...

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply to

I've also put in on a new Post around the time you have :)

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator

Maybe it might be on Youtube in a few weeks as some Scottish Parliament debates are on it at present.

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame in reply toshaws

You will find it on the Scottish Parliament TV website

DippyDame profile image
DippyDame

Well done those at Holyrood...this issue has rumbled on for far too long hopefully this debate will raise the issue that people are suffering/dying because of poor/no thyroid treatment ... and that they are not just "making a fuss".

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR

Wonderful impassioned speech from Elaine Smith :-) The Health minister at the end was quoting the BTA guidelines from 2015. Why not their statement from December 2016, which says that a minority of patients need T3, and it should not be removed from the due to cost? And their October 2017 response to the NHS consultation repeats that

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toTaraJR

She probably thought that was the latest guidelin and despite what they state about not withdrawing if needed, at a stroke the GC have withdrawn T3 regardless of the situation in places patients in. The following is an excerpt by Clutter :

The BTA issued guidance that patients doing well on T3 should not have their prescriptions with-drawn. See FAQS for patients and GPs in british-thyroid-association...

If the CCG instructed your practice to withdraw Liothyronine they should first have consulted on the impact it would have on patients and will be in breach of guidelines if they did not. mills-reeve.com/files/Publi...

CCGs do not have the authority to tell GPs what not to prescribe. Individual GPs, not CCGs, could be found in breach of the General Medical Services contract if they do not prescribe treatment patients have been told "they need".

bmj.com/content/358/bmj.j36...

The GPC has warned that GPs would be in breach of the GMS contract and could get into legal trouble by following the orders and refusing to prescribe patients treatments they have told them they need.

gponline.com/gpc-warning-ig...

Please also sign the petition below requesting better thyroid diagnosis, testing and treatment. change.org/p/itt-campaign-g...

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR in reply toshaws

Yes, thanks for this. I'm in Norfolk and we have small active group who have "working with" (feels like "working against") our CCGs. They have removed T3 from ALL doctors, no consultation. And no consultation or signposting for patients re NHS consultation. But we're on to them...

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply toTaraJR

TaraJR,

CCGs are supposed to consult, they are in breach of guidelines if they do not.

mills-reeve.com/files/Publi...

shaws profile image
shawsAdministrator in reply toTaraJR

I think they've all got hot-headed when they've learned of the cost but cannot they think beforehand, that to withdraw an important hormone and leave the patient without a suitable replacement - not levothyroxine for many - causes and immense stress and also NDT could be sourced. They could easily prescribe the cheaper T3s (I think there's two) but they don't want the responsibility and would rather patients suffer. Lets stop this prescribing lark for levo and T3 after all they are only hormones and do what some other countries do, buy from chemist but not at the prohibitive price in the UK.

Hillwoman profile image
Hillwoman in reply toshaws

Clutter Please could you re-post those BMJ and gponline.com links, as they don't seem to be working.

Thanks

Clutter profile image
Clutter in reply toHillwoman

Hillwoman,

bmj.com/content/358/bmj.j36...

gponline.com/gpc-warning-ig...

mills-reeve.com/files/Publi...

Hillwoman profile image
Hillwoman in reply toClutter

Thanks very much.

TaraJR profile image
TaraJR

Thanks Clutter. Yes we've seen that, and it's in our list of 'ammunition' to take back to CCGs. We've been working closely with our local Healthwatch too; they're very supportive. Though of course, wheels turn slowly...

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Hypothyroidism debate in Westminster Hall today

http://www.parliamentlive.tv/main/Player.aspx?meetingId=14408&wfs=true For thyroid awareness week...
Chippysue profile image

Debate in House of Lords!

I had a meeting with Lord Philip Hunt, Opposition Spokesperson on Health and Social Care, Higher...
lynmynott profile image
Partner

Debate in House of Lords 20.6.18

As you may know, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath led a regret debate in the House of Lords on Wednesday...
lynmynott profile image
Partner

Let's take some action!

Another thread suggested we should march on Downing Street with placards. 10/10 for enthusiasm! And...

T3 debate House of Lords

Hi All Just wondered about the latest guidelines for T3 prescribing. I’m on T3 after years on T4...
Ziburu profile image

Moderation team

See all
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
RedApple profile image
RedAppleAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.